In laws at Christmas. Presents ?

We turned it into a joke and had a little prize for the person that got the most negative comment ?

That is just plain rude of them Peasblossom. You should feel sorry for her for being so socially inept!

Sometimes she would say “I don’t like cyclamens” or something like that ?

Well I used to have not just my in-laws but my sisters in-laws as well. I used to give her a plant in a pot and him a bootle of mulled wine.

They had Christmas Day at my house for years and never once said Thank You or brought anything ?

H1954 is spot on.

We agreed in our family 3 years ago to not buy for the adults, just the children. Much easier, and less stress!

If she had bought you Cadburys chocolate was that not a present? Does it matter if gifts cost different amounts? Of course not.

love0c

I had my son's Mil literally dropped on us three days before Christmas. We rushed out and bought her some lovely M&S PJ's. We weighted on her hand and foot the whole time. Our present was a bar of Cadbury chocolate. She does have another daughter and a son. They did not want her for Christmas and she probably wonders why. We will not make the same mistake again.

“Literally” dropped on you ? Hope she’s not a large lady.

Give daughter hers at the start.
For his in-laws, buy vouchers. Keep them in your bag. If no-one has bought you anything, don't get them out.
(It's the embarrassment all round when there's no exchange, not the irritation that that you weren't thought of imo.)

We go to sons for Christmas lunch and so do his in laws. I take wine and desert for the meal. I give in laws shortbread chocs and wine.

I might add we were absolutely exhausted!

I had my son's Mil literally dropped on us three days before Christmas. We rushed out and bought her some lovely M&S PJ's. We weighted on her hand and foot the whole time. Our present was a bar of Cadbury chocolate. She does have another daughter and a son. They did not want her for Christmas and she probably wonders why. We will not make the same mistake again.

In your situation I would give a small gift as Allsorts has suggested.
Your DIL is another matter, not thanking you for her gift is extremely bad manners. We get gifts from our DS and DIL jointly from them and little gifts chosen by DGCs. ( which can be quite amusing)
I’m of the opinion that it is better to give than receive, so continue with your kindness.

I would give to whoever I wanted to irrespective of what they gave me. It is very helpful to know who will all be attending.

I simply don't understand all this extended gift giving! Let me try to explain; n my opinion, buying for adults goes something like this........hyperthetically, I goe to the shops and spend £30 on a gift for each my adult family members, each one of them does the same, on Christmas Day we potentially end up with loads of stuff we either don't want, like,or would ever use! Who benefits?..........the traders!
OP, instead of feeling obliged to buy for the in laws why don't you offer to supply some really good wine for the day or an extra special box of chocolates to share round?
Gifts for children are different in my mind but the endless buying for adults when you know you'll feel aggrieved afterwards plus all the stress and expense just doesn't make sense to me.
Instead of a personal gift for DS and DIL I would be tempted to give them a joint gift too, you might get more acknowledgement from DIL that way.

That's a good idea All sorts. Biscuits would be good.

I would treat my dil as I would my son, I couldn’t buy him and not her. You don’t give to receive so why be embarrassed if you gave in laws something, it was a nice gesture but I would keep it simple, luxury shortbread, chocolates or perhaps or a bottle.

I usually buy a gift for my daughter's in-laws as every second year we are with them at Christmas at my daughter and son-in-laws house. It's not anything big. I wouldn't have thought your Dil would have bought you a separate gift. Surely you get something from your son and her collectively?