Gransnet forums

Relationships

In laws furious we are moving

(91 Posts)
Confuseddil Wed 05-Dec-18 14:41:41

Looking for advice... We’ve recently told my in laws we’ve decided to move abroad and they are furious. They’re close to my toddler DS and I can completely understand their upset, we’re disappointed they’ll see less of him too. We’re moving abroad for my job and my FIL has yelled and yelled that we’re not doing the right thing and putting my work ahead of everything else. He has been extremely rude and even yelled on two separate occasions that he couldn’t care less if I leave the country (just me). Until this all happened I had a good relationship with my in-laws, they’re quite over bearing but nothing I couldn’t handle happily enough. My husband is understandably very angry at his Dad (yhis Mum has been nicer but could have been more supportive too) and I’m just devastated there is such a family strain. We leave in seven weeks and I know things won’t get better unless they’re fixed before our move (we told them four months before our move, as soon as we knew). I can barely look at my FIL given his behaviour and know he won’t apologise. My husband doesn’t want to discuss the situation with them again but I suspect he’d regret that in years to come, I’ve tried to convince my husband to speak to his parents but he’ll only do so if they apologise. I think this is a lost cause but any advice? Thank you!!!

maximka25 Thu 06-Dec-18 16:38:58

Your FIL's behaviour is rude but easily explained - he's upset. Telling from my own experience. Over 22 years ago I married a foreigner. My late Dad was upset that I've chosen to live thousands of miles away from my parents, though he wasn't rude about it.
Though I was very much in love with my husband, there are many things I regret about leaving home. I wasn't there, when my Dad died. My Mum didn't see my firstborn until he was a year and a half old. I missed sharing all the milestones with her.
My elder son has severe autism, so I haven't been travelling with him back home for over 14 years. My Mum comes to visit us once a year, and stays with us for a month, and every time she has to leave, we don't know if we'll see each other again. It's hard on both of us, as we have a very strong bond. Yes, there is a daily phone call, and Skype, but it isn't the same.
Yes, it is ultimately your decision, but you're changing not only your own life but their lives irrevocably.

FlexibleFriend Thu 06-Dec-18 16:32:32

Is the move permanent? Sorry if I've missed that. I think he's being very unreasonable especially if you're from Australia and your parents live there. So it's ok for your parents not to have regular contact with your kids but not him. Tbh in his shoes I'd always be expecting you to move to Australia from the minute you and your husband got serious.
Sorry is just a word, no more or less important than any other, so does it really matter whether he says it or not. try to persuade your husband to be the bigger man.
I'd tell the father in law "it is what it is" he can accept it with good grace and be happy for you or can yell some more and kick up a fuss but whatever he does it's happening and you'd prefer to part on good terms and maintain as much contact as possible but it's his choice.

I hope it goes well.

Confuseddil Thu 06-Dec-18 16:21:33

‘Thanks to all’ vs the typo above smile

Confuseddil Thu 06-Dec-18 16:20:31

Wow, I wasn’t expecting so many replies, thaoto all for making the time. I really appreciate all of the considerations put forward and will do my best to put them to use for a positive outcome x

GabriellaG Thu 06-Dec-18 16:02:55

Arrange to come home one or twice a year...12,000 miles?

Newatthis Thu 06-Dec-18 16:00:04

It sounds as if your FiL is being selfish. i'm not sure where you're going but maybe they will eventually look upon your adventure as their adventure also. My DD lives in San Francisco (11 hour flight) with our beautiful GD and I miss them everyday but I really love going to see them and having lovely holidays there. I am fortunate as I am in the position of being able to do so but maybe they too might come round to visiting, even if only once a year? The important thing is, is to keep the communication channels open and I'm sure eventually it will be OK.

David1968 Thu 06-Dec-18 15:51:11

I've quoted this before on GN- "if you love someone, set them free...:" (song by Sting.) Our only child & family are 5000 miles away, so we understand what this can feel like. But we have never ever made a fuss about this because we love them & want them to have the best possible life which they choose. I agree with Scribbles. Don't let your FiL get to you: go forward and have a wonderful life.

blue60 Thu 06-Dec-18 15:19:24

You really must follow your heart if this is right for you and your family.

Many people dislike change, but gradually change is accepted. It has to be.

Go forward and take this opportunity to embrace a new phase in your lives.

sarahellenwhitney Thu 06-Dec-18 15:10:29

Confuseddil .We were in a similair position when many years ago my now late DH and self discussed a new life for ourselves and our, yet to start school, children. Before taking it further we informed both parents of our plans. My parents wished us well, not so the in laws.
It was not going to be as easy making the move as we thought with DH having to take a lower grade in his line of work. I believe however that the 'opposition' was the deciding factor and out weighed any pioneering spirit we had.
Go with it. Its your life.

Nanna58 Thu 06-Dec-18 14:21:32

Live love laugh , what a shame that your strident nature doesn’t reflect your name

PECS Thu 06-Dec-18 14:20:31

I would be devastated if either of my DDs moved away but if it was right for them and their family I would have to support the decision. They do not 'owe' me anything and I have been hugely lucky to have such a close and loving relationship with DGCs so far. We cannot tether our children and need to support them,

mabon1 Thu 06-Dec-18 14:18:38

It's your life, live it the way you wish, in-laws will come round in the end I bet.

Nanna58 Thu 06-Dec-18 14:18:25

Of course you have to do what you think is best. However, do be as understanding as possible, as has been said before it is so hard for grandparents in this situation, who love their grandchildren with all their hearts but have no way of ensure they will always be close to them.I suspect no one appreciates this until they are themselves grandparents.

maddyone Thu 06-Dec-18 14:15:37

Luckygirl makes a good suggestion, to write to your PiL telling them why you are going, but acknowledging their feelings, and giving suggestions as to how you can keep in touch after you move.
Some posters sound quite high handed in their indignation, and they’re right of course that’s it’s your life to live as you choose, but you are showing that you are a lovely DiL in that you want to fix this before you go, and you say you’re also disappointed that they won’t have such a close relationship with your little boy yourself. But work comes first of course, and we all have to go where our jobs take us.
It is very probable that MiL is terribly upset but hiding it, and that FiL is angry that he can’t protect his wife from this pain. Your husband should certainly speak to his parents, to part on bad terms would be terrible. And thinking to the future, he would be guilt ridden if anything should happen to one of his parents before he manages to see them again, if he parted on bad terms. Asking for an apology is futile, an apology should be made really, but often pride gets in the way, and the only way to view this unfortunate situation is with compassion. FiL will calm down and you will move abroad, but try your best to get everyone to part on good termsif you can.

willa45 Thu 06-Dec-18 14:11:01

I would arm myself with a lot of patience, listen quietly and allow them to vent. Understandably, they are upset ....whether you realize it or not, they feel that their entire world will be turned upside down by your absence. Depending on their age, they may also feel they're being robbed of what little time they have left to enjoy their grandson.

The holidays is also not the best time for bad news. Obviously their grief is so great, they have forgotten or no longer care how they express it. They may even ignore that it's your life and that the decision is yours and your H's to make, not theirs.

Perhaps your H could have a quiet talk with them. Right now what they need most of all is sympathy, understanding and a lot of reassurance. Finances permitting, you and H might offer them the plane tickets so they can come and visit you once you're settled. You could also arrange to come home once or twice a year. If they have that to look forward to, it may ease the transition. Time heals and they will get over it one way or another. Handle this with sensitivity and compassion and there shouldn't be any lasting scars.

I do wish you all the best.

Bekind Thu 06-Dec-18 14:02:21

I'm sorry you are experiencing this! I have a daughter and grandchild who live far away and we still talk on the phone all the time, so it seems like she's still here with me. In fact, I talk to her more than I do my other 2 children who live close by!

Billybob4491 Thu 06-Dec-18 12:55:28

You only have your children on loan, and all any parents wants is for them to be happy and settled in whatever path they choose to take. However, I would be heartbroken if your g/daughters removed to another country, job or no job, I can understand your FIL reaction, but feel he could have handled the situation more politely.

Jane43 Thu 06-Dec-18 12:47:22

If you were my daughter in law I would be very proud that you are doing so well in your career that you have been offered a wonderful opportunity like this. Grandchildren are a privilege not a right and your FIL is behaving very badly, in fact if he is not careful it could lead to estrangement from his grandson, his son and you. He is lucky you are even considering putting things right before you leave. Distance is not the barrier it used to be with modern technology and the opportunity to travel for regular visits. He should read some of the posts on here about estrangement and think very carefully about his behavioural which IMHO is completely unacceptable.

As you can tell I feel very strongly about this as we have been estranged from our eldest two granddaughters for 10 years now over something very trivial after years of support for our ex daughter-in-law. We have been excluded from their lives - from two weddings and the birth of our great-grandson and it hurts more than words can ever describe. I woukdn’t wish it on anybody, not even you FIL.

I wish you, your husband and your son all the very best for the future.

sodapop Thu 06-Dec-18 12:22:31

Your father in law may well be devastated by your move confuseddil but that does not give him the right to behave this way to you. Supposedly he is an adult and should be able to deal appropriately with his emotions. My daughter moved to USA with her husband and baby, this was before the days of e-mail and Skype, of course I was upset but I brought her up to be independent so wished them God Speed to their new life.

Don't stress any more over this, let your husband deal with it if he can. Do try to mend fences with your mother in law if possible but move forward and embrace your new life whole heartedly. Good luck.

evianers Thu 06-Dec-18 12:08:12

We left to emigrate in 1975 taking the only GC at that time to the southern Hemisphere. Neither sets of parents were particularly enamoured with the idea of not seeing their children/grandchildren, but they became used to the idea and in fact came to visit us both in South Africa and Oz eventually. Your FIL needs time to become used to the idea.

Willow10 Thu 06-Dec-18 11:34:17

I've always thought that if my children thought there were better prospects abroad, I would never stand in their way. I wish I had emigrated years ago. After all, what prospects are there for youngsters in this country now? Of course it would absolutely break my heart and I honestly don't know how I would cope, but it is their lives to live as they choose, not mine. I think your father in law was extremely rude and you must be a lovely person to even forgive his shouting such nasty comments at you. Of course they are upset, but that gives them no right to behave that way. I hope they realise eventually that it is their support you need, not childish sulking. None of us have the right to dictate how our children live their lives. Good luck to you on your new adventure.

knspol Thu 06-Dec-18 11:14:29

I'm sure you and DH didn't go into such a major move lightly. It's your lives and you must do whatever is best for you. I thoroughly understand from experience what it's like when family move abroad as it happened with my own son. I was devastated BUT wished them well from the beginning, told them it would be a marvellous new start for them and that they were doing the very best thing. I think your inlaws are just being incredibly selfish not to mention rude and unpleasant. I'd just keep my distance until hopefully they realise how dreadfully they've acted and come to their senses. Good luck with your new adventure!

grannytotwins Thu 06-Dec-18 11:13:20

Your in laws must be utterly broken hearted. I didn’t understand, until I had a grandchild, that I would love him as much as if he were my own. You won’t understand that until you are fortunate enough to be a grandparent. He is hurt and grieving for his grandchild and a future where he can’t hug him or have a close relationship with him. Skype doesn’t give anything like a normal relationship. It’s silly to think that any modern technology can be a substitute for a cuddle with grandad. I’m incredibly sad for this man whose only crime is to love his grandson and want to be a part of his life. Did you honestly think that he would be happy that you are taking a job abroad? I expect that your in laws are sobbing themselves to sleep every night. You need to build some bridges fast instead of complaining about him here.

moggie57 Thu 06-Dec-18 10:48:07

you go its your life, your decision. dont let them control how you think or do things let things calm down and in a few months maybe they could come visit.they sound selfish .i can see there reasons as they are very close to gc...but they can still see them if they wanted to. and theres skype and video calls.yes i would feel devastated if my gc went abroad, but they are your children not theres. go .let things ride, call them to reassure them all is well. let gc speak to them..i think things will pan out over time. at moment they having panic attack.good lick..

Razzy Thu 06-Dec-18 10:47:29

It is a bit unfair of them, I mean you’ve been living on their doorstep to the detriment of your parents, now you are moving you’ll be equidistant no doubt. I understand they are upset because they won’t see their son and grandchild so much, but if they are retired I am sure they could visit you regularly? I am sure if you were having to move because your husband got a job abroad they wouldn’t be so annoyed.