Gransnet forums

AIBU

To wish she would be the same with us?

(133 Posts)
TopsyAndTim Thu 14-Oct-21 17:55:36

Our housekeeper has been with us for 7 months. We have always had a good relationship with our cleaners and helpers who we employ in our home. They become like family and we socialise with them etc.
Our current housekeeper left her last job not by choice. The lady whose house she looked after died and she was very young. Very sad all round. She still sees the family and seems close to all the relatives etc. Yet with us, there seems to be a barrier and although we have offered to take her out with us, come to dinner etc, she always turns us down. Aibu to wish she would have the same relationship with us as she does with them?

Blossoming Fri 15-Oct-21 18:11:26

No she didn’t *YellowMelow, she expressed a view that she would like a closer, more personal, relationship with an employee. It seems that the employee doesn’t reciprocate.

Yellowmellow Fri 15-Oct-21 18:13:02

That is beside the point. If you read some of the comments they are just plain nasty and unnecessary and that is my point.

welbeck Fri 15-Oct-21 18:13:13

so you are taking it as a serious query then ?
those who are not are replying in a jocular vein.
which is not rude but for entertainment value.

Hithere Fri 15-Oct-21 18:17:39

Imagine being friend with your employer and you do something your employer doesnt like or agree with - totally unrelated to your work

Does the employee have to be scared to lose her job for that?

Secondwind Fri 15-Oct-21 18:26:16

Perhaps she’s strong on professional boundaries. Makes life easier in the long run in my experience (not with personal staff - never had any), especially if something goes awry.

Blossoming Fri 15-Oct-21 18:45:35

Yellowmellow

Why is it people have to make snide and nasty comments? I never quite get it. The lady expressed a view that she would like a better relationship with an employee. No need for these snidey comments

The lady, or possibly gentleman, expressed a wish for a closer, more personal relationship with an employee. The employee did not reciprocate. Yes, they are being unreasonable.

BabyLayla Fri 15-Oct-21 18:46:02

As a young mum I worked as a cleaner/ ironer five mornings a week 9-12 , I was fortunate to be able to take my children with me ( they were very good, would nap or sit and colour for the 3 hours)
Most of my clients came via a local estate agent, two ladies in particular stand out, one an Italian lady with no children ( I’m in the UK) moved to my small town with her husband who traveled for work a lot. The other was a French lady again with a husband away for days at a time. Both of these ladies were open about feeling lonely and isolated at times.
Anyway, when my children started school I was invited to go for a meal out, I declined at first as felt very uncomfortable but over time did agree and it developed into a mutual friendship. One lady returned to London after a few years but the other was a friend until her husband passed away and she moved to live with her grandson.
I remember with much affection these ladies who were so kind and gave so generously. So my advice is don’t push a relationship, one will develop if it’s meant to be.

Blossoming Fri 15-Oct-21 18:47:58

Yellowmellow

That is beside the point. If you read some of the comments they are just plain nasty and unnecessary and that is my point.

That is very much the point. I have read all the comments. Some people are having a joke. Nobody has been rude or nasty.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 15-Oct-21 18:49:14

There speaks the voice of experience BabyLayla.

Sago Fri 15-Oct-21 18:52:29

YellowMellow I agree with Blossoming to use a social media platform to ask such a question is always going to raise a few eyebrows!

The responses are tongue in cheek not nasty.

Sago Fri 15-Oct-21 18:54:45

What I really think is the OP is trying to show off and our way of dealing with it is take the

Lauren59 Fri 15-Oct-21 22:53:57

So where have you gone, TopsyandTim? Nothing to say?

MissAdventure Fri 15-Oct-21 22:56:00

You think she'd have the decency to come back and have the piss taken a bit more.
What a liberty!

Elvis58 Sat 16-Oct-21 00:05:22

Ha! Ha! Is this post a joke?

welbeck Sat 16-Oct-21 03:22:32

whatever gave you that idea !

MayBeMaw Sat 16-Oct-21 08:18:20

MissAdventure

You think she'd have the decency to come back and have the piss taken a bit more.
What a liberty!

gringrin

Yellowmellow Sat 16-Oct-21 17:02:33

Thats your view Blossom. Let someone else express their views. Doesn't mean you have to be right

Blossoming Sat 16-Oct-21 17:08:24

Yellowmellow

Thats your view Blossom. Let someone else express their views. Doesn't mean you have to be right

Yes that is my view, and I see others agree with me. You have expressed your view as have many others, doesn’t mean I have to be wrong. Expressing views is what people do in forums.

MerylStreep Sat 16-Oct-21 17:22:20

MissAdventure

You think she'd have the decency to come back and have the piss taken a bit more.
What a liberty!

Is that said in a Kathrine Tate voice ? I can hear her saying it. ?

Yellowmellow Sat 16-Oct-21 18:31:08

Blossoming l think you also need to take on board your own comment

Ethelwashere1 Sat 16-Oct-21 18:42:48

I was hired to housekeep for a lovely family but never socialised and would not have wanted to. I did my job and took my pay. No more no less

RVK1CR Sun 17-Oct-21 03:14:36

Sago

This is exactly why our butler got the heave ho!

@Sago
I had the same trouble!! Butlers, housekeepers, gardeners - just can't get the staff, ha ha

harrigran Sun 17-Oct-21 07:50:40

It is not that unusual to have staff, a neighbour employed a housekeeper, nanny, cleaner and gardner because she had four children quite close together. This is just a street of semi detached houses not country piles.

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 17-Oct-21 10:16:09

What did the housekeeper do harrigran, given there was also a cleaner?

Magrithea Sun 17-Oct-21 18:37:07

I have had a live in domestic helper (overseas) and now have a cleaner who comes weekly. I've had a good relationship with both but even with our live in the relationship never extended to a personal friendship.