Gransnet forums

Chat

Do you know English geography?

(102 Posts)
vampirequeen Tue 12-Jan-21 16:30:41

voxpoliticalonline.com/2021/01/11/bbc-geography-fail-puts-bristol-and-birmingham-in-wales-and-if-you-think-thats-bad/

Apparently someone at the BBC has problems grin

Ilovecheese Tue 12-Jan-21 16:32:04

Actually vampirequeen that could be me! My geography is appalling.

Riverwalk Tue 12-Jan-21 16:37:12

Is that picture genuine?

welbeck Tue 12-Jan-21 16:41:56

there was a funny thread on MN a month ago, about things people didn't know.
like not knowing that yellow dandelions were the same plant as dandelion clocks.
and so many thought Pontefract was in Wales.
some were really funny, wish i could remember. it began with a professional woman, capable mother, wondering how rice was manufactured, and why they only made it in those little bits.
it was welcome light relief. will try to find it.

AGAA4 Tue 12-Jan-21 16:42:45

We have enough problems in Wales without Birmingham and Bristol entering. I thought my Geography was bad.

Callistemon Tue 12-Jan-21 16:48:58

Wales is in England - or so I am told often.
Although I don't think Bristolians would be too happy about being sent across to Wales.

I think the cities stayed put but the country slipped sideways. grin

Nortsat Tue 12-Jan-21 16:51:25

God help us ... it’s a map of the Vaccine Roll Out.
Manchester is in the sea, Newcastle has moved to Cumbria, Birmingham and Bristol are in Wales.

I dread to think what this means for the roll out...

grumppa Tue 12-Jan-21 16:54:54

It looks as if two layers have been put together out of alignment; everywhere on the map is north-west of where it should be.

The most worrying error I ever came across was the last time I flew. I was following our progress on the electronic map, and noticed that Stansted Airport had been placed in north Kent. Fortunately we were heading for Heathrow, which the Lufthansa pilot found successfully.

And I had a work colleague who thought Norfolk was in North Wales, and vice versa.

Callistemon Tue 12-Jan-21 16:59:48

I hope Mancunians have got their wetsuits and snorkels.

welbeck Tue 12-Jan-21 17:19:11

Nortsat

God help us ... it’s a map of the Vaccine Roll Out.
Manchester is in the sea, Newcastle has moved to Cumbria, Birmingham and Bristol are in Wales.

I dread to think what this means for the roll out...

wonder if they will be able to locate our upper arm...

GrannySomerset Tue 12-Jan-21 17:24:50

When we moved to Bristol from Yorkshire almost forty years ago DS was appalled that his (highly selected) classmates regarded Birmingham as being in the north. Leeds and Newcastle were definitely beyond the pale and quite unimaginable. Not sure how different things are today.

kittylester Tue 12-Jan-21 17:44:46

DGD2 was told by her teacher that her Mummy said bath rather than barth because she came from up North- Leicestershire!

JackyB Tue 12-Jan-21 17:52:06

Even corrected the map is weird. Why is Surrey a dot?

welbeck Tue 12-Jan-21 17:59:24

Surrey has become a hub.

Franbern Tue 12-Jan-21 18:17:36

Surely this is some sort of hoax!!! Or as someone has said, an overlay gone wrong. Of course, with Manchester where this shows it, there was never any need for the Manchester ship canal to be built!!!

BlueBelle Tue 12-Jan-21 18:26:46

I love geography
I was appalled when a young lady asked me where my son was living, I told her NZ and she said oh that’s near Canada isn’t it? The worst part is she was not a child or an unintelligent lady
What’s !!!
I can still draw a reasonably world map without looking a ‘skill’ I never have used in life haha

Lexisgranny Tue 12-Jan-21 18:28:47

I was appalled to read ‘no such word’ beside the word Mancunian, which was in an essay written by one of my children - the teacher came from London!

midgey Tue 12-Jan-21 19:34:56

My offspring are intelligent, but they know very little British geography. It shows how the curriculum has changed over time. I learnt counties and towns at school.

Smileless2012 Tue 12-Jan-21 19:41:17

My knowledge of geography is pretty poor TBH, but even I know Bristol and Birmingham aren't in Wales.

Blinko Tue 12-Jan-21 20:06:05

I can remember those jig saw puzzles made up of all the counties in England, showing the county towns too. Good for learning elementary geography. I've never forgotten it, even though some counties are now subsumed into others - Rutland and Huntingdonshire spring to mind.

FarNorth Tue 12-Jan-21 20:08:57

Surely the actual names of the places are in the correct locations, and thus the blobs at the left hand end are all too far west, of course.

(too dull an explanation, probably)

crazyH Tue 12-Jan-21 20:15:21

Is it April 1st already.?

Mamardoit Tue 12-Jan-21 20:26:21

Blinko

I can remember those jig saw puzzles made up of all the counties in England, showing the county towns too. Good for learning elementary geography. I've never forgotten it, even though some counties are now subsumed into others - Rutland and Huntingdonshire spring to mind.

Little Rutland is independent again now. Multum in Parvo.

Blinko Tue 12-Jan-21 20:27:27

Mamardoit

Blinko

I can remember those jig saw puzzles made up of all the counties in England, showing the county towns too. Good for learning elementary geography. I've never forgotten it, even though some counties are now subsumed into others - Rutland and Huntingdonshire spring to mind.

Little Rutland is independent again now. Multum in Parvo.

Thanks for the update, Marmardoit.

kircubbin2000 Tue 12-Jan-21 21:10:32

kittylester

DGD2 was told by her teacher that her Mummy said bath rather than barth because she came from up North- Leicestershire!

Don't tell me it's pronounced Barth? How can it be, theres no R.