Gransnet forums

News & politics

Some effects of Brexit on unimportant people

(113 Posts)
MaizieD Fri 26-Mar-21 20:37:15

A twitter thread by Financial Times journalist, Peter Foster.

Some people may find it very sad.

We write a lot about the impact of Brexit on business (rightly) but what about the impact on individuals - and it’s not just about the money! As me and @DanielThomasLDN report her for @FinancialTimes Stay with me... /1

Brexit is about building back barriers - economic but also social and cultural with Europe - and these barriers are built back by increment. Just as gravity impacts trade, so it impacts our social and cultural interactions. The bureaucracy created by Brexit does that...EG... /2

Adrian Bagley, a semi-retired architect who buys and sells model trains from collectors in the EU on the Catawiki auction website...he's been doing it for years. It gives him great pleasure interacting with buyers n sellers from Romania or Austria /3

It's a hobby. It's not life and death, and Mr Bagley excepts ultimately his travails are trivial - but new rules on VAT and the 'handling charges' that parcel companies charge have permanently disadvantaged him with EU contacts /4

I feel like a semi-invisible barrier has come down between me and all those countries I had previously been on the same footing with, when we were all following the same rules. Now I feel I’ve been cut off by duties and so-called ‘handling charges’,” he says. /5

The barriers work both ways. An Italian collector who bought a train from Mr Bagley is cross that he suddenly has to pay VAT and charges on receipt - and Mr Bagley pays 25% effective surcharge on what he buys. (£53.56 in 20% VAT+ £12.50 handling fees on a €250.49 train) /6

This means that EU collectors low-ball his sales (coz they know charges are coming) and he can't compete on a level playing field for with EU bidders for an EU product, since they don't have VAT+ handling. Cry me a river, you say. Well, I do. /7

Similarly with José Martín Quesada who was sent some home baked pastries by his mother in Spain after Christmas which arrived rotten after weeks waiting for health certs etc. “My mother sent the most innocent parcel of home-cooked food and it was declared a biohazard.” /8

Cry me another river. Is Mr Quesada going to starve no? Was his Christmas ruined? Probably not. But his mother's attempt to show him some seasonal consideration was made impossible. Multiply these stories out by the thousands, tens of thousands, and it's a sorry tale I think/9

I've wrote about au pairs being blocked for no really good reason (to much mockery) but that's 50k cultural interactions a year - young Europeans meeting brits, learn English, young English kids meeting EU citizens, hearing languages...realising the world is round, not flat. /10

I've written about the outbound travel industry - young brits going to work in campsites and skiing chalets, running canoeing holidays or guiding musical tours...all that is now made measurably more difficult. Gravity will take it's toll./11

This week's Lords EU committee report on #Brexit and Services tells the story... here @SBIT_UK explains.

As I type UK companies are not signing chalet contracts that would create jobs for UK hires this summer./12

Sorry, image missing.

Again. Not the end of the world, things might get a bit pricier etc. But all just part of the incremental losses caused by building barriers that have material impact - if you have an Irish passport, say, you'll find it easier to get hired. Just a fact. /13

It's no good saying "we're out of the EU, not out of Europe" because a lot of European - the wiring under the plasterwork - is driving by EU rules and regulation. Over time, people will bother less, in both directions. /14

Similarly with the decision to drop Erasmus+. The Lords report worth reading on this, but the Turing scheme is nothing like a replacement and - again - ignores the reality that the EU is a our neighbour. It's another rock in the road. /15

Sorry, image missing

twitter.com/pmdfoster/status/1375381463252795395

Ginny42 Fri 26-Mar-21 21:26:51

The other evening during the PM's briefing I heard Laura Kuenssberg point out that it's not just about people missing their two week summer holidays abroad, it's also about those with family living abroad whom they haven't been able to see for over a year now.

I was so moved I could have wept. That's the first time I've felt someone recognised that for people like me there is just an enormous void in our lives. I haven't seen my DD and DGS for 14 months and it's very hard to stay focused and not to give in to feeling defeated by this prolonged absence. If I send a parcel now, they have to pay on it at the other end!

Re: Erasmus. I was employed on the Erasmus scheme and it's not just the young people missing out on the wonderful opportunities who are affected. Tutors have lost their jobs, along with all the income for local organisers, host families, room hire in Universities and catering staff and all the money spent on sightseeing, theatre visits, refreshments and shopping.

It was so inspirational to go into European schools and organise exchanges between English teachers and pupils. All gone. Our young people will be the losers, because those countries will continue to benefit from the wider educational and cultural experiences.

Polarbear2 Fri 26-Mar-21 22:45:00

No idea what to say but didn’t want to just bypass your post. It’s criminal is what it is.

MaizieD Fri 26-Mar-21 22:54:54

Polarbear2

No idea what to say but didn’t want to just bypass your post. It’s criminal is what it is.

Thanks. No need to say anything.

I'm still in admiration of your masterly analysis of our Glorious Leader on another thread yesterday. grin

It's the indifference to the adverse effects on ordinary people's lives which really upsets me.

Urmstongran Fri 26-Mar-21 23:02:44

A referendum is held on divisive topics with polarised opinions. I think some of the fall out here is from the pandemic, not Brexit only. A Scottish referendum if it happens again soon will be equally divisive. The result will suit some and not others.

MaizieD Fri 26-Mar-21 23:21:43

^ I think some of the fall out here is from the pandemic, not Brexit only^

Oh really? Re a lly...

So it's the pandemic that is to blame for all the non tariff barriers that are increasing the paperwork and costs for both exporting to and importing from the EU. The barriers that are talked about in the thread I posted.

Perhaps you'd like to explain how the pandemic is imposing all the paperwork and extra costs. And the long delays in customs so that a present of cake to a son is rotten when it arrives.

This has nothing at all to do with the divisiveness of referendums. This is about damaging people's lives and livelihoods.

Urmstongran Fri 26-Mar-21 23:26:21

No, I meant this ...

The other evening during the PM's briefing I heard Laura Kuenssberg point out that it's not just about people missing their two week summer holidays abroad, it's also about those with family living abroad whom they haven't been able to see for over a year now.

Brexit hasn’t caused this situation.
It’s the pandemic and restrictions due to it.

growstuff Fri 26-Mar-21 23:59:32

No pandemic stopped the Erasmus scheme. When will you just accept that the government has reneged on some of the promises it made? It lied - there's no other word for it.

growstuff Sat 27-Mar-21 00:00:46

The pandemic hasn't made it more difficult and expensive for people to live and work in the EU. Brexit has. Stop telling porkies!

vegansrock Sat 27-Mar-21 08:01:35

I’ve had to order a component that comes from Sweden it cost £135. - it would have been £100 before January. It clearly stars on the checkout - rise in price due to Brexit and then itemises the taxes etc. No I can’t buy it in the u.k. or I would have done so.

growstuff Sat 27-Mar-21 08:34:28

A friend of mine is a professional gardener. He ordered 80 bare rooted fruit trees last autumn for planting this month in a new orchard. Unfortunately, the Dutch supplier will no longer deliver because the red tape and shipping would be prohibitively expensive. He's just spent the last week trying to source the trees from a UK supplier, but hasn't been able to find 80. That's absolutely nothing to do with Covid, but Brexit.

NannyJan53 Sat 27-Mar-21 08:45:04

It is so upsetting isn't it? Why oh why have so many voted for causing all this extra paperwork and costs? All these barriers now to be overcome. We have definitely regressed, but then I suppose that is what some wanted, back to the 19th Century

But, we do have Blue Passports! hmm so thats ok then.

Froglady Sat 27-Mar-21 08:52:54

NannyJan53

It is so upsetting isn't it? Why oh why have so many voted for causing all this extra paperwork and costs? All these barriers now to be overcome. We have definitely regressed, but then I suppose that is what some wanted, back to the 19th Century

But, we do have Blue Passports! hmm so thats ok then.

People weren't given this sort of information when they voted.

sodapop Sat 27-Mar-21 08:54:25

Several things have become difficult for us living in France. I have used the Next international site but because unwanted goods have to be returned to UK this is now complicated and expensive. The lady in the Post Office was quite apologetic about the amount of paperwork required. It's hard to judge at the moment which things are a problem due to the pandemic or Brexit. Of course others face much more serious problems but the small things are frustrating.

MaizieD Sat 27-Mar-21 09:14:26

NannyJan53

It is so upsetting isn't it? Why oh why have so many voted for causing all this extra paperwork and costs? All these barriers now to be overcome. We have definitely regressed, but then I suppose that is what some wanted, back to the 19th Century

But, we do have Blue Passports! hmm so thats ok then.

To be fair, I don't think that people who voted Leave really understood the difficulties that leaving the Single Market would cause. We have got so accustomed to very easy trade within the EU; as easy as trading within the UK itself.
It wasn't even necessary to leave the Single Market & the Customs Union; more rational Leave voters didn't advocate that at all. Leave campaign leaders and influencers casually brushed aside any talk of difficulties, good old Project Fear, and I think that many of them didn't really understand what becoming a third country really involved.

But it would be less infuriating if leave voters had the grace to show a modicum of concern for those who have been adversely (and against their wills) affected by the results of their vote. (A bit of contrition would be lovely, too, though probably asking a bit too much of them.) Completely ignoring other's distress caused by their vote just perpetuates division and bad feeling.

NannyJan53 Sat 27-Mar-21 09:30:40

You are right MaizieD I have been saying often to my OH that we were not given enough information at the very start Just stark headlines about money to the NHS etc. I have heard a few people say over the past year, 'If I knew that I would have voted to remain'!

To me it makes sense that we are all stronger together. Even my 90 year old Mum thought that.

Polarbear2 Sat 27-Mar-21 11:12:38

Absolutely agree that there wasn’t enough info. I think I pay attention to such things but I hadn’t ever considered the Irish border issue for example. I don’t think any of us, including possibly many in government, had any idea what the real impact of leaving would be. I stand by that it was never meant to end up with us leaving. Cameron did it to shut his right wing party members up. They were completely unprepared, complacent, and left the field wide open for the Leave campaign to road roller its way to success. Several leave voters I know voted as a protest vote regards immigration. They had absolutely no intention of causing what then followed.

Smileless2012 Sat 27-Mar-21 11:14:35

It's the constant complaining IMO that "perpetuates division and bad feeling". Had the vote gone the other way, there'd have been people forced to remain in the EU "against their wills".

Well I've heard more than a few people who voted remain say if there'd been another referendum they'd have voted leave NannyJan. People change their minds but regardless of how one voted, it's happened.

JaneJudge Sat 27-Mar-21 11:21:34

The dismantling of Erasmus is a disgrace, it directly affects students that are less likely to be able to afford to have options open to them due to lack of privilege

MaizieD Sat 27-Mar-21 11:22:49

It's the constant complaining IMO that "perpetuates division and bad feeling".

I don't think you even bothered to read the OP, did you 'Smileless*? Where is the moaning and complaining?

More relevant is, where is your sympathy for the people whose lives have been disrupted by your vote?

Had the vote gone the other way, there'd have been people forced to remain in the EU "against their wills

But there would have been absolutely no effect on their businesses, their hobbies, their exchanges of presents with relatives in other EU countries or on their daily lives. A remain vote wouldn't have caused any difficulties apart from the moaning...

simtib Sat 27-Mar-21 11:41:55

The whole leave campaign was a disgrace. It's main focus was on keeping the immigrants out and the vote showed this country up for what we are. It completely ignored the disastrous effect it is was going to have on many peoples lives keeping the immigrants was what mattered.

Smileless2012 Sat 27-Mar-21 11:48:24

I don't think you bothered to read my post did you Maizie.

Where did I say that the OP was moaning and complaining?

You assume incorrectly, that I have no sympathy for the disruption that leaving the EU has caused.

I was not naive enough to assume there wouldn't be disruption and like every other person who voted, whether it was to leave or remain, exercised my democratic right to do so.

Unlike so many though, I have neither the need nor the desire to keep fuelling the division and bad feeling.

Dinahmo Sat 27-Mar-21 17:48:14

Smileless2012 Please explain why I, as someone who lives in France would have been forced to stay here? First I've heard of it.

Smileless2012 Sat 27-Mar-21 20:04:04

I've no idea why someone would say you've been forced to stay living in France Dinahmo or where you've got that from.

Dinahmo Sat 27-Mar-21 22:07:50

Smileless2012

"Had the vote gone the other way, there'd have been people forced to remain in the EU "against their wills"

Quote from your post. I've just substituted France for EU