Gransnet forums

AIBU

Christian Family face possible legal action

(482 Posts)
NfkDumpling Thu 10-Jul-14 06:36:24

It's a set up.

NfkDumpling Thu 10-Jul-14 06:35:59

Would a Kosher butcher be sued for not providing a pig for a hog roast?

janeainsworth Thu 10-Jul-14 03:47:37

Businesses can pick and choose who they serve. A restaurant, for example, could reasonably ask a group to leave if they were making a lot of noise and disturbing other customers, or if they were violating a dress code, eg men not wearing a shirt.
What they cannot do is discriminate on the grounds of race, disability, age or sexual orientation.

rosequartz Thu 10-Jul-14 00:15:17

According to a news report the cake was ordered for an event at the town hall in support of gay rights, hosted by the mayor.

He allegedly said that 'he fully supports the action taken against the bakery. Businesses should not be able to pick and choose who they serve.'

Two thoughts on this: how much did a jolly like this cost (regardless of its purpose) when there are stringent cutbacks in essential services?

Is it true that a business has to supply goods - I understood that the supply of goods is a contract and that each party has to agree to the contract, eg if a shop does not wish to sell you an item they do not have to.

I agree that this may have been purposeful mischief-making and the bakery was 'set up' by the mayor or one of his cronies.

gillybob Wed 09-Jul-14 23:17:07

Sometimes I wonder if these things are not a great big set up and the bakery was deliberately approached knowing they would refuse the order. hmm

gillybob Wed 09-Jul-14 23:16:06

I respect anyone's views although I may disagree with some of them. I don't think this family run bakery did anything wrong. They obviously have strong Christian values and could not bring themselves to go against their personal beliefs. It's a pity they just didn't say they were too busy and did not have the time or capacity to fulfill the order. Why would anyone (gay or not) contact the national press and make an issue out of it? confused

NanKate Wed 09-Jul-14 22:55:32

I have just read in the paper that a Christian family who run a bakery have been threatened with legal action as they refused to bake a cake supporting gay rights.

The cake would have featured Sesame Street characters Bert and Ernie and the slogan would have been 'Support Gay Marriage'.

What are your thoughts?