Gransnet forums

AIBU

Gay Pride ad a new 'equality gap'?

(341 Posts)
Imperfect27 Fri 04-Aug-17 19:35:57

Let me explain.
I am NOT homophobic.
I think it is appalling that historically people who are LBGT have been marginalised, discriminated against, made to be fearful - even treated as mentally ill and 'curable.' All of this more than saddens me.
I have gay friends. that I regard as part of my extended family and if a child of mine were to tell me that 'Actually mum, I am gay' it would not make one iota of difference to my love and support of them. If anything, it might bring out the lioness in me as still, I think they face disadvantages in society. Until we reach a point of being gay being a big 'So what!' we will not have reached true equality.
BUT ... I have struggled with the adverts for Gay Britannia on BBC - which seem to swamp the airwaves. I struggle with the news that 10 national trust staff have been 'moved to non customer-facing services' for refusing to wear gay pride landyards - www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-norfolk-40825660 - and I struggle with the societal subtext that if we do not openly accept and rejoice with proclaiming 'gay pride' we must somehow be anti ...

I struggle because I have been hurt. I was married to a man who left me for a man. I learned along the years of our marriage that gay wasn't 'curable', wasn't a 'choice', wasn't an 'aberration' - it was / is just a .n. other way of being.

BUT, I know I would not find it easy to wear any gay pride regalia and I struggle with the strident voices that seem to need to be 'in your face' about their sexuality. I don't introduce myself along the lines of 'Hello , I am .... and I am heterosexual.'

Maybe you will think I am contradicting myself because I do see that being accepted as LGBT in our world is still a struggle for some, and maybe that means that some people do still need to be strident about it, but I find myself in something of a corner. At present I feel marginalised, I feel my opinion doesn't matter, I feel that even though I have been prepared to revisit and revise every value I was brought up with, recognise my own unfounded / ignorant prejudices and move to a point of not just tolerance, but true acceptance of how we can be 'different' , still am somehow 'out of step.'

I am not sure what I want - except I don't want to be bombarded with gay 'rights' to the detriment of any other 'right'. At present I feel 'unequal'. Does that make sense?

Ana Sat 05-Aug-17 16:47:48

That was before dj joined in and ww remembered what a jolly super day out Gay Pride was...grin

rosesarered Sat 05-Aug-17 16:44:42

I thought you said before that it was your last word on the subject ww hmm

whitewave Sat 05-Aug-17 16:39:26

I do find some of this thread a tad prurient. Not sure it matters a jot what goes on behind closed doors, or who is taking part. I never look at anyone and wonder what sort of sexual activities they take part in- that is just plain weird.

illtellhim Sat 05-Aug-17 16:32:20

I thought it was still illegal between a man and a woman? Just as a point of interest

Well, yes it is, but who's going to join a protest or put their name to a petition to get that law changed ? wink

whitewave Sat 05-Aug-17 16:28:02

dj they always do - the police get involved that is. There are of course some gay policemen and women. We haven't gone this year but it is always a super day out for all the family. It is extraordinarily popular and gets heaving with people.

Ana Sat 05-Aug-17 16:23:06

Annie did not say that, Oriel. If you read her post properly, she's saying that while she herself has no problem with homosexuality, some people cannot see beyond the sex aspect, i.e. anal sex.

rosesarered Sat 05-Aug-17 16:21:49

A lot of virtue signalling going on here from some Annieb wink not to mention twisting of posts or wilful misunderstanding.

rosesarered Sat 05-Aug-17 16:19:46

Hardly something I would have done a survey on Oriel...
I have read that it's done a lot in African countries, to stop unwanted pregnancy.
So, are you talking 40% of the UK population, and what percentage of those are British? Or the world as a whole?
I find it staggering that anyone would really want to do it anyway, gay or straight.

Anniebach Sat 05-Aug-17 16:18:18

From what I said ? , homophobics equates homosexuality with buggery , just where did I say I was homophobic ?

Oriel, I find your deliberate twisting of my posts staggering.

durhamjen Sat 05-Aug-17 16:16:17

Good to see the police joining in the fun at Brighton Pride, whitewave.

Oriel Sat 05-Aug-17 15:50:52

Roses recent studies indicate that around 40% of hetrosexuals engage or have engaged in anal sex. So it's very likely to be similar in gay relationships given that many don't wish to have anal sex.

It was Annie who brought, as she calls it, buggery into the conversation. From what she has said she equates homosexuality with buggery - a relationship based on nothing more than sex and, in particular, anal sex... nothing more.

I find this level of misinformation staggering.

durhamjen Sat 05-Aug-17 15:46:41

Just what I was going to say, whitewave.
His family say he wanted to keep his sexuality private; he had to keep it private as it was against the law until two years before he died.

Perhaps if he'd lived longer, he would have been more open about it.

Makes you wonder if his family are ashamed of it.

whitewave Sat 05-Aug-17 15:26:27

If he had "outed" himself he would have been imprisoned.

No surprises therefore that he was a private person.

I realise that I am swimming against the tide here so probably time to shut up, but find this whole sorry affair intensly uncomfortable. My last word on the subject.

M0nica Sat 05-Aug-17 15:24:47

Criminal attacks are something else entirely Eglantine. I do hope your brother makes a good recovery and the assailant is caught and punished.

I was thinking about the stupid things people say. When I was a child (in the 1950s/early 60s,) if we met anyone who said anything to suggest women were not capable of doing any particular endeavour, my mother would, if possible, express surprise at their attitude at the time and laugh about their old fashioned, set in stone attitudes after they left.

trisher Sat 05-Aug-17 15:22:19

If you gift your home to the NT you must be aware that there will be people going round it and arguably therefore you have opened what was your private life to the general public. I don't know if he would have wanted people to know he was gay or not, I suspect that things have changed so much since he died 48 years ago that his views would be very different now. If I disagreed with something the NT had done I wouldn't choose to show my disagreement by not wearing a symbol that is important to a section of the community that have been historically victimised.

Anniebach Sat 05-Aug-17 15:22:16

Thank you Roses, I now believe they know what I mean they are just taking the oppertunity to mock.

paddyann Sat 05-Aug-17 14:44:09

In Scotland 4 out of 6 party leaders are gay or Lesbian,its not something people really bother about ,as one guy I know said Why the hell should I worry about what they do behind closed doors ,they give me enough to worry about when the open their mouths .I do think that there has been a vast improvement in attitudes over the past couple of decades here.I worked in an industry where gay people were quite the norm ,in our office of 14 people at least 5 were openly gay or lesbian ..and this was the seventies .I just never thought about it and I still dont .I dont remember anyone being worried about sharing a darkroom with a gay photographer ....lets face it just because they were gay didn't mean they would jump anyone available ,in fact most of them were far more fussy about who thay saw than the straight guys or girls .

Eglantine19 Sat 05-Aug-17 14:36:00

It's a bit hard to laugh when your brother is in a hospital bed having his face put back together, Monica.

Smileless2012 Sat 05-Aug-17 14:35:18

IMO the Trust's desire for volunteers to wear gay pride badges is secondary and less important than the fact that Ketton-Cremer's personal life has been made very public.

A NT spokesman is reported as having said "The people we interviewed were clear we weren't "outing" him, as among those who knew him it was widely accepted". Well, making details of his personal life known to those who didn't know him is IMO "outing" him.

Three of his god children have spoken out against the NT's decision who I think at the very least should have been consulted. He gifted his home to the NT not details of his private life.

M0nica Sat 05-Aug-17 14:26:29

Imperfect the mere fact that you felt a need to be transparent about your views, says it all. If we took sexuality, of whatever kind for granted, you would not feel the need to be transparent.

Penstemmon I disagree with almost everything you say in your post except the first sentence. How can you, with a straight face address a mainly female audience and talk about ^People who have not been marginalised....... cannot understand. We are women, for heaven's sake, of course we understand marginalisation.

Personally, I get fed up with the constant song and dance every time a women reaches a senior level and the same for other minorities. Real equality arises when no one thinks twice about having a female/gay/transsexual Prime Minister. The Irish have managed to do it with out too much fuss, as have we with our second female Prime Minister.

Let us assume all people take other people as being equal and just make a fuss and laugh at them when they don't.

rosesarered Sat 05-Aug-17 14:22:26

This is all about the NT and imposing views on workers, which I hear that they have now backed down on.Good!

rosesarered Sat 05-Aug-17 14:21:12

just as likely Oriel..... I don't think so.
Some posters are totalling misunderstanding ab's posts in any case, she is one of the least judgmental people on GN on , where kindness is an issue.

Oriel Sat 05-Aug-17 14:15:01

Annie anal sex is just as likely to be enjoyed in the hetrosexual community as it is in the gay community.

Why do you think that homosexuality is defined by the act of sex? Would you hold the same views of hetrosexual couples engaging in anal sex?

I remember watching a documentary where Stephen Fry was discussing homosexuality with some African leader (can't recall his name). The African guy kept going on at length about anal sex - he called an anus 'anoos' confused . Stephen Fry was really patient and measured in his tone, despite the ranting of the African. Stephen said that he had never had anal sex and would be horrified by the idea.

Eglantine19 Sat 05-Aug-17 13:44:02

I just like to keep talking about it eh Annie? It reminds me of someone I used to work with back in the sixties who would read the News of the World from cover to cover and then come into work and need to talk about it all week saying disgusting, disgusting. But the need was hers, not ours.

Anniebach Sat 05-Aug-17 13:39:35

Trisher, try this - I DO NOT CARE what happens between consenting adults, I AM NOT hung up on buggery or sex in any way or position, GOT IT?

I am just saying how people who have a problem with homosexuality think .

You compare marching to support gay rights with marching against apartheid .

Everyone seems to ignore the fact that it is SEX which is the major issue in homophobia .