We often go to an all year round dog freindly beach, looks like mostly locals use it as it's not particularly pretty or commercialized, and all the ones I've chatted to say they very much want it to stay dog friendly. There are other nearby beaches which are no dogs. I think it's a fair compromise. I have never seen dog poo left on this particular beach, everyone is very careful to clear up. If it was a busy family beach I guess restrictions like a limit to part of the beach is fair enough, or time of day restrictions, but poo could still remain on the beach above the tide line if it's not cleared away. Unfortunately there are always a few people who will spoil a reasonable arrangement though, not train or supervise their dogs properly. I'd support large fines for not clearing up after dogs and other antisocial behaviour. I worry that many people have purchased dogs and little puppies during lockdown and will now have to think about how to manage them once back to their jobs and long hours out of the house. Perhaps owning dogs could be made more difficult, not by banning them but by making more effort to ensure they are cared for responsibly and dog licencing.