Gransnet forums

AIBU

To think too much is expected of teachers these days

(183 Posts)
Galaxy Mon 26-Apr-21 12:21:23

The situation for children with special needs in previous times was awful. The idea that there was some Golden age of education is not true. My children received a much better education than I did, and certainly much broader in terms of experiences.

Hithere Mon 26-Apr-21 12:20:26

Part of the challenge of teaching is recognizing the strengths and weaknesses of the students so they learn better.
The bond between student and teacher should facilitate identifying red flags.

The items in the original post are reasonable.
Now, if a child has a condition that the teacher recognizes and she/he is not trained to deal with, different arrangements are needed.

Bodily autonomy should the the rule everywhere, not just at home.
Sex education is just biology class, not all kids get this info at home, or the proper one.

eazybee Mon 26-Apr-21 12:18:26

The lack of Special schools and units has contributed to many more classroom problems; mainstream schools are not suitable for the needs of all pupils.

trisher Mon 26-Apr-21 12:14:55

EllanVannin

There was none of this in the 40's/ 50's what's happened, what's gone wrong with the world ?
In the " leaner " years I had a brilliant education in both primary and secondary school which I'm sure many others will vouch for and the majority left school with jobs to go to.

In the40s &50s if you had a problem child you shipped them off elsewhere. Special needs schools for children who were different. Grammar schools sent children to secondary moderns, sec mods sent children to special or approved schools(if they were really bad). Now I am 100% for inclusion, the problem is it's been done on the cheap and instead of the expertise and services found in special schools being moved into mainstream they've just disappeared.

Sarnia Mon 26-Apr-21 11:27:01

Not to mention toilet training and knowing how to use a knife and fork.

Lucca Mon 26-Apr-21 10:47:31

Yes yes and yes. As long as the non teaching people are properly trained and spend time in classrooms to see how teachers interact with students and the difficulties they face .

EllanVannin Mon 26-Apr-21 10:47:07

There was none of this in the 40's/ 50's what's happened, what's gone wrong with the world ?
In the " leaner " years I had a brilliant education in both primary and secondary school which I'm sure many others will vouch for and the majority left school with jobs to go to.

trisher Mon 26-Apr-21 10:22:05

Teachers now are expected to be knowledgeable about special needs, recognise and help with mental health problems, teach about sex and consent, provide counselling and fulfill heaps of other little requirements when they pop up. Wouldn't schools function far better if properly qualified non-teaching staff were available to deal with these problems and teachers were left to teach?