Gransnet forums

AIBU

To think we should let scientific advisers advise?

(181 Posts)
EllanVannin Fri 17-Dec-21 07:51:48

If Chris Whitty wants the country to shutdown then so be it. It would save an awful lot of deaths and suffering. What's more important ? The man himself isn't going to be partying etc. !

Riverwalk Fri 17-Dec-21 07:39:26

I've just heard Oliver Dowden on Times Radio, twice evading to answer what he would say to those MPs bad-mouthing Prof Whitty - it seems like an orchestrated campaign to me.

Hetty58 Fri 17-Dec-21 07:24:53

Chris Whitty, the voice of reason, just reminding us to think before we take any risks. We all know he's right, of course, but Tory MPs have one eye on the economy too.

mumofmadboys Fri 17-Dec-21 07:23:19

Wouldn't it be wonderful to have someone as sensible and balanced as Chris Whitty for prime minister? Actually I think Nicola Sturgeon gives very clear directives too

nanna8 Fri 17-Dec-21 07:20:01

Sounds like commonsense to me but then Tory MPs wouldn’t know a lot about this. Never have.

MayBeMaw Fri 17-Dec-21 07:11:36

Well, well, well. Apparently Professor Chris Whitty has come under fire from Tory MPs after urging the public to scale back their plans before Christmas, with claims that medical advisers are “running the show” on Covid policy.
Tory MPs are said to have questioned the level of influence wielded by Prof Whitty
(I might question the level of competence by the same MPs, but there you go. )
Conservative backbenchers hit out at England’s Chief Medical Officer after he told the public to prioritise events that “really matter”, signalling that less important gatherings should be skipped to curb the spread of omicron.
Critics claimed Prof Whitty’s comments at the No 10 news conference on Wednesday evening were markedly stronger than the Prime Minister’s message.
It seems to me that “prioritising” is exactly what sensible people are or should be doing. Do we want to be with our families at Christmas or do we chance the pub quiz night? Office drinks party or seeing the children/grandchildren? Train to London to see the Christmas lights or give it a miss this year?
There is risk in everything, but it’s obvious to me that the alternatives to making sensible choices could be either a massive surge in infection and/or total lockdown.