I have lived in several villages and loved them all, also in big towns and a couple of cities. We moved here from central Winchester, although I knew several neighbours in my road it was not at all the same and took far longer to get to know them. I had only one really good friend by the time I left after two years, I had half a dozen here after the same time, and that applies to all the villages I have lived in. (OH with itchy feet)
Last night at book club one of my friends said that it was the reason why it is almost impossible to buy a house in our village, no-one wants to leave it and there is a constant shuffle around. Our house was once 'swapped' along with three other houses, the four owners who wanted to move all got together for dinner one night and the family with four children in our house went to the largest, the older couple from the largest went to the house next door to us, the very elderly couple in that one went to one next door to their daughter that was tiny, inhabited by a young couple who were expecting their first and came to ours!
We usually rent in an area before we buy. It does mean that we have to move twice, but we have been able to do lots of research first. A village hall is usually a good sign, as is a school (we have one which means there are always families so that the village doesn't die off) a shop is even better, although we don't have one as such but the garage a couple of miles away has a very good shop and barbers.
Recommendations please, for a stopover on the way to Loch Tay