Gransnet forums

Blogs

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 20-Aug-15 15:07:32

The 10,000 step tyranny

Forget 500 miles, it's all about 10,000 steps a day for author Fanny Blake. Are you a slave to the NHS-recommended 10k a day? Or do you prefer to get your exercise by other means? Running around after grandchildren springs to mind...

Fanny Blake

The 10,000 step tyranny

Posted on: Thu 20-Aug-15 15:07:32

(61 comments )

Lead photo

Do you get your 10k a day?

Walking is the new jogging, especially for those of us whose knees are no longer quite the full shilling.

Whenever I can, I drive out of town and find somewhere to walk in the country, but my life has been changed since my new iPhone arrived complete with a mystery app with a heart on it. Once a friend had explained that this would monitor the number of steps I walked everyday (and lots of other things besides), I realised I’d been missing a whole dimension: that of a city walker.

On their website, the NHS explain the health benefits of walking 10,000 steps a day - 10,000 steps is the equivalent of about five miles. For someone like me who spends the day in one place, that’s an ambitious stretch to cover every day. However I decided to stop taking so many buses and start walking instead. But while I got my step level up to an impressive high, other hurdles presented themselves that I hadn’t thought about.

The first time I walked to a meeting, I turned up with blistered feet and in a muck sweat. Not a great look! For some reason, the moment I stop walking, I get incredibly hot. It’s impossible to concentrate or to feel that you’re being taken seriously when you’ve got sweat pouring down your face.

When you're not looking at your surroundings through a bus window but are part of them, you start noticing things you hadn't before.


Apart from requiring a decent pair of trainers and a bag in which to carry my other shoes, I realised the wardrobe required thought. Arriving at a meeting in Lycra or a sweaty tracksuit doesn’t exactly command confidence, so I now have to plan what I wear much more carefully - I need something I can walk and meet in, unless I want to change on arrival and lug around what I’ve worn to walk in all day.

And then there’s the time constraints. How does one fit a walk into a busy schedule? I can’t believe that pottering up and down stairs or the supermarket aisles are as beneficial as a good old brisk walk that gets the heart-rate up. As far as I’m concerned, those steps don’t really count. The solution? I now leave 30 minutes earlier to get wherever I’m going.

Walking has its own community of all types, and I’ve met some obsessives who tuck their phone in their pocket or their Fitbit into their bra all day long counting the number of steps walked that day, and comparing with others. At the moment, I’m keeping the competition limited to myself. Anything more feels too anxiety-inducing.

Are the 10,000 steps a tyranny? On a bad day I’d say so, as I rush to complete them. But despite the extras to take on board, I’m discovering huge pluses that outweigh the minuses.

There are the health benefits laid out by the NHS (above). There’s the feeling of satisfaction and the endorphin rush that comes with exercise. When you’re not looking at your surroundings through a bus window but are part of them, you start noticing things you hadn’t before. Walking costs nothing (apart from the ambidextrous wardrobe!), is easy to do, and you don’t need anyone else.

For me, perhaps the biggest benefit is the thinking time walking gives me. When I’m sitting at home writing, I often get stuck. But a brisk walk clears the cobwebs away so ideas and solutions surface from somewhere in my subconscious. I don’t pretend to understand the process, but for a writer, it’s completely invaluable.

Catching the bus? No thanks, I’d prefer to walk. Only 8,973 steps to go…

Fanny’s new book With a Friend Like You is published by Orion and is available now from Amazon.

By Fanny Blake

Twitter: @FannyBlake1

NonnaW Fri 29-Jan-16 13:34:39

I got a FitbitCharge for Christmas and am so far averaging 10k steps a day. Mind you, I don't believe it is really that much, as it seems to count arm movements as steps too. However, I find it interesting to see how much I do each day, and it's not difficult, given we have 2 dogs that are walked twice a day.

I also use it to track my sleep (again, not entirely accurate, but interesting nevertheless). Am now logging food on it, just for a while, to see how the calories mount up!

Nannanoo Wed 30-Dec-15 13:22:53

My feet have worn out, and are terminally arthritic after a life of ballet, marathon running, professional nursing and generally walking from A to B, as I don't drive. A foot surgeon has said he doesn't think they can do anything for me, as foot replacements are not yet available.
I love walking, and still manage to take a turn around the block most days, having invested in some very expensive shoes, which really do help, but I would love to do '12 milers' through the forest as I used to.
10,000 steps would be impossible for me, it would be too painful, so I'm waiting for our new local sports centre to open so that I can swim every day - I guess that counts as exercise!

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 23-Sep-15 14:34:00

My Fitbit is the little green one. I wear it on my bra. I keep getting annoying messages in my email from it. My son bought it and set it up.

hmm

LottieSweetpea Wed 23-Sep-15 14:09:28

Do the Fitbits work with any I phone please?
I have a 4s
Thanks

Happy4me Wed 23-Sep-15 13:57:11

that should have been 10,000 steps not miles ... I have walked many miles per week

Ana Wed 23-Sep-15 13:21:53

10,000 miles a week, Happy4me? shock

You must be the bionic woman!

Happy4me Wed 23-Sep-15 13:16:18

I appreciate the concept but I don't drive so have walked everywhere all my life and have often walked 10,000 miles every week over the years but never thought to count the steps.

I have sat on buses and trains and seen things I have not see before ... the car has lot to answer for as it robbed us of our natural exercise..

In my case I am probably wearing out gradually having broken ribs on the pathway and often get corns and hard skin on my feet sadly.

Oh that I had another life .... smile

durhamjen Tue 01-Sep-15 19:57:55

You can also do that with a Vivofit, but I'd rather not. If you just want to get fit, competing with others can be bad for your bloodpressure.
You are still put in a group with others and can update if you want and see how you compare at so many steps, but just doing more steps on my own is enough.

yogagran Tue 01-Sep-15 18:29:34

Rowantree I have a Fitbit Zip. It's easy peasy to set up with a smartphone, almost does it itself. I wear mine clipped to the front of my bra, it's never fallen off in the two years that I've had it. With Fitbit you can join various challenges and see how you measure up to others! I love it

I also have the Aria scales which sync with your smartphone everytime you weight yourself so you can see all the statistics (steps, miles, weight, calories if you feel the need to count them too although I'll admit that I can't be bothered with counting calories)

Nandalot Mon 31-Aug-15 16:47:33

Let the Tyranny begin! My Vivofit. (typed carefully this time) is on my wrist. Quite traumatic. I couldn't get my ant in!!! I was being too gentle! The mind boggles. Then I couldn't remember my password for my garmin account... didn't know I had one, then it asked me all sorts of embarrassing questions like my weight and birthdate, and then I had to get DH to help me fit it on my wrist. Then I read Durhamjen's post and found out I could have got it £5 cheaper!
All set now. I am aiming for 5,000 to start as I have no idea how far that is.

Rowantree Mon 31-Aug-15 15:32:37

Thanks. I'm going to find out from my SIL whether it would be suitable for my (not very) smartphone. I don't really understand these things, but I will ask his advice as he's very reliable.

I've spent almost two hours this morning, from 6.30am, working out in the gym, which included over 30 mins very fast walking on the treadmill, and I clocked up over 250 calories and over 3 km. I have no idea how that translates into steps but I certainly don't do anywhere near 10,000 a day!

durhamjen Mon 31-Aug-15 15:08:03

I do not think there is anything on the others that I would miss. It does enough for me. I do more steps than the nurse at the GP surgery, anyway. She was thinking of getting one instead of the pedometer that she wears at the moment.

durhamjen Mon 31-Aug-15 15:05:55

Yes, mine's the cheapest one, £45 from Argos.

durhamjen Mon 31-Aug-15 15:03:39

I'm sure mine is the cheapest. My son bought it for me before the other one came out, I think. Anyway, he knows I'm not one for gadgets.

All I have to do is sit in front of the computer and press a button until the letters sync come up on the screen on the Vivofit. Then the screen comes up on your computer to embarrass you about how few steps you have done, like I've done just now!

It can also sync to your phone or ipad or whatever device you use, but I do not have a mobile to put it on.

Rowantree Mon 31-Aug-15 14:57:20

Which model is yours, durhamjen? I'm keen to know whether the cheapest one would be OK. It says it doesn't automatically sync to the computer, whereas the more expensive ones do, but I don't know whether it's worth paying nearly double the price.

Rowantree Mon 31-Aug-15 14:47:57

My legs are short and very fat and wobbly, durhamjen. Not a pretty sight. Would it be otherwise! I'm so embarrased by them that I haven't worn a skirt or a dress for years sad
I understand what you're saying, though! smile

durhamjen Mon 31-Aug-15 14:41:33

What I mean is that my ten thousand steps will be different from your ten thousand steps, depending on who has the longer legs.

durhamjen Mon 31-Aug-15 14:40:35

If you get one you can wear on your wrist and use it as a watch, it will not languish, although I must admit I wear a watch as well, as it's the one my husband bought me. You have to wear a Fitbit or Vivofit on the wrist you do not use to brush your teeth. Otherwise you could add hundreds!
When we were walking on the North York Moors last month, my Vivofit was as accurate as my son's Garmin that he uses for timing his runs of 8-10 miles.
Does accuracy matter when all you are doing is testing against yourself?

Rowantree Mon 31-Aug-15 14:33:50

To those who use Fitbit Zip: Is there a risk of it getting lost?

And to all who use similar devices - which is better and more accurate, a wrist-device or one you clip onto clothing?

I'm an idiot who needs simple devices. DH isn't keen on me getting one: he thinks it's a waste of money which will languish unused in my underwear drawer. I'd like to prove him wrong and tell him it's worth the money I'm spending on it, but I'm reluctant to spend £90+ on one unless the features are worth the money - so which are the must-have features?

Anya Mon 31-Aug-15 09:01:25

Are you saying pooohbear you look more like your user name then? grin

pooohbear2811 Mon 31-Aug-15 08:42:19

I am one of life's fortunate people ( if you want to use that expression) I have a very active job as a housekeeper in a hospital and walk on average in the 8.5 hrs I work 19 miles...yes you read it right....up and down corridors making beds, hoovering, washing floors, pushing trolleys, cleaning sinks etc etc. Constant on the go and have done for 12 years now.
Cant say as I look like Twiggy but feel that side of life is grossly unfair.

Nandalot Sun 30-Aug-15 19:46:34

Of course I mean Vivovfit ..must be the gremlin autocorrect . Isn't Vicodin the painkiller House was addicted too?

durhamjen Sun 30-Aug-15 18:14:07

Do you mean Vivofit, Nandalot?
Never touch Vicodin.

pauline42 Sun 30-Aug-15 18:08:59

Just bought a Fitbit Surge and managed to sync it to my iphone - so I am at the first stage of committing to my goals and watching my progress. I don't shy away from daily workouts or spin classes, but have never had the ability to monitor my output, heart rate, steps etc., till now. I find it fascinating and at the same time it is teaching me how to live with technology - which I have resisted for the longest time! But this technology age is never going away so I decided to jump on the bandwagon and get to grips with it using fitness as my main motivator. I have splurged on both the iphone and the Fitbit watch to celebrate my seventy third birthday!

Nandalot Sun 30-Aug-15 14:43:09

I'me really pleased to hear that you get on with your Vicodin because I have ordered one and it is waiting for me as I write to 'click and collect'! ( but I felt too lazy to do it today....bodes well doesn't it!