Gransnet forums

Blogs

LauraGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 13-Oct-16 10:50:43

Should illegal drugs be decriminalised and regulated?

In the wake of her son's imprisonment for buying illegal drugs, Hope Humphreys, who campaigns with the organisation Anyone's Child, speaks out about UK drug laws and why she thinks they should be changed once and for all.

Hope Humphreys

Should illegal drugs be decriminalised and regulated?

Posted on: Thu 13-Oct-16 10:50:43

(59 comments )

Lead photo

"These 'statistics' are people we know, people you may know. It has to stop."

Things happen. Our student son was sentenced to two and a half years in prison for taking his turn to get ecstasy and cannabis for his adult friends. Nick's son, who has mental problems, is unable to get the help he needs because he self-medicates with cannabis. Ami's husband was refused the prescription drugs he was addicted to and died of a heroin overdose. Anne-Marie's fifteen-year-old daughter died after taking very pure ecstasy. Rose and Jeremy's two sons died of heroin overdoses, and Ray's two sons died, together, after drinking after a football match and taking something they thought was ecstasy. These things happened. We are part of a group of people who want to stop them happening.

There's nothing particularly special about any of us. We were all getting on with our lives when we each had our personal bombs explode, changing us forever. We were brought together by Transform and are a campaigning group within it, called Anyone's Child: Families for Safer Drug Control. The name is especially apt. What happened to us could easily happen to you or your friends or relatives.

We were all getting on with our lives when we each had our personal bombs explode, changing us forever.


The main reason for these harrowing, tragic events are our drug laws. These laws aren't "fit for purpose". They were enacted because it was thought that they would end drug use and protect us all. These thoughts have been mistaken for decades now, yet they continue to be enforced.

Successive governments have chosen to treat drugs differently from other dangerous things. Their decision is that drugs are bad - end of story. If you use, share, produce or sell them, and get caught, you are in big trouble. Your punishment will be more damaging, more dangerous than the drugs themselves.

And it's getting worse. Last year, according to the Office of National Statistics, there were 2,248 deaths from illegal drugs in the UK, the highest ever recorded. Over 70,000 people were given criminal records for minor drug offences, and our prisons are overflowing with non-violent drug offenders. These 'statistics' are people we know, people you may know. It has to stop.

The Government must be forced to accept the fact that their drug laws have failed. Not only have they ruined lives with prison and criminal records, they kill our young for experimenting with illegal substances that they themselves have refused to control. Parents know children will be disobedient but the punishment should not be death.

We cannot let the Government get away with this carnage any longer. All drugs must be taken out of the hands of criminals, and controlled and regulated like every other dangerous substance and activity. It is not good enough just to sit back and hope. You may think your loved ones are okay and that you'd be very unlucky for them to get caught or die. You could be right, but these things did happen to us. We don't want them to happen to you.

Read more about Hope's story and learn about the network of families campaigning for safer drug control on the Anyone's Child website.

By Hope Humphreys

Twitter: @anyoneschild

Luckylegs9 Mon 17-Oct-16 07:37:57

If someone is imprisoned for drug offences, it beggars belief that those drugs that put them inside are freely available inside. That is a crime in itself. How can that not be tackled. Anyone that thinks cannabis is harmless is deluded, it is mind altering, that is why it is taken. How much it disturbs the brain is to a large extent dependant on the individual, what ruins one person almost straight away could take years for someone else. I think these drug barons that get people and children onto drugs not fit to live, they are committing mass murder, there is no excuse. Seized their assets, expose them. There is no deterrent now, people with loads of money frighten their victims into silence and if they are caught get clever lawyers to get them off on a technicality. Victims of crime do not get the justice they deserve.

Wobblybits Mon 17-Oct-16 08:24:08

Cannabis should be legalised and available just as alcohol and cigarettes are. Ok it has it#s dangers and problems as do alcohol and cigarettes, but better that the quality be controlled.

The police do not have the resources to control the current situation, they need to concentrate on the suppliers of hard drugs.

Drug users need help not prison, it's the suppliers that want locking up.

Anniebach Mon 17-Oct-16 09:51:49

Alcohol is mind altering too

Granny3Rose Mon 17-Oct-16 22:44:17

grannypiper Nobody is suggesting that legally regulated heroin should be freely available to just anybody. The model suggested by Transform Drug Policy Foundation is of medical prescriptions and supervised consumption venues for registered dependent users of the highest-risk drugs such as heroin. People who become dependent on heroin don’t set out to become that way. There are a multitude of reasons why it happens. If they did not have to rely on illegal dealers and supplies most would be able to get on with reasonably normal or even successful lives. You probably wouldn’t be able to tell that such a person was a heroin user. I think that is a far preferable outcome to the chaotic lifestyles they end up in at the moment, which too often tragically end in an early death because of the unknown nature of their illicit drug.

JessM Tue 18-Oct-16 10:19:07

Yup I remember a long time ago someone telling me that an office in Cardiff was awash with cocaine, and I believe it is cheaper now. Go back 20-30 years and it was £60 a go.
We should be grateful that we do not have the problem with crack cocaine that they do in the states and the US. Really nasty drug that makes people high and aggressively so, for prolonged periods (according to my source).
There's a lot of dodgy money going through the drugs industry, none of it taxed. It then, presumably has to be laundered one way or another, leading to more crime.

Iam64 Tue 18-Oct-16 18:22:03

When I was working, amphetamine combined with alcohol as drugs of choice seemed to create the more unstable, often very aggressive individuals. It may, of course, have been the people in the drugs, rather than the drugs in the people that caused this. Something about drugs of choice I suspect. I would not oppose the legalisation of cannabis though smoking is always to be avoided where possible. Countries that have taken a health rather than criminal approach to drugs seem to have better outcomes, less drug use, than we do.
I often wonder about national characteristics/culture etc - look at those Hogarth cartoons of gin lane and remember that Britain seems always to have been excessive where mind altering substances are concerned.

Penstemmon Tue 18-Oct-16 19:43:25

Drugs = big money for those that control the supply. The local / street dealers are often users too. If you take away the monopoly on supply there may be a chance to prevent an increase in use and reduce the numbers that take the journey from 'soft' to 'hard' drugs. Whatever is happening now is not very effective!

grannypiper Fri 21-Oct-16 08:09:19

What about the children of addicts ? alcohol is not addictive from the first drink and it causes enough problems in households, Heroin is addictive form the outset so would cause suffering from the start.

grannypiper Fri 21-Oct-16 08:15:47

Please dont tell me the children dont suffer, i know they do, i worked with the children of drug addicts and their lives are awful.Babies are born addicted to the mothers drug of choice and have to be weaned off the drug, this heartbreaking to see and hear. How do we justify that ?

Iam64 Fri 21-Oct-16 11:17:49

Has anyone told you that the children don't suffer granny piper? I must have missed it if that has been said.
There are many gransnetters who have personal or professional, or sometimes experience of both on the impact on children of having parents who are dependent on substances, whether that be alcohol or drugs.

Iam64 Fri 21-Oct-16 11:19:56

This is one of those occasions where an edit button would be good. We could add food to the list of addictions couldn't we. Parents who are preoccupied with their own needs are simply not emotionally available to their children. They are often unable to provide for their children's basic needs. Legalising drugs may in fact help reduce the problems children with parents who are addicted to illegal drugs face. Countries where drug dependence is seen as a health, rather than criminal problem, seem to have better outcomes than we do in the UK.

SueDonim Fri 21-Oct-16 12:59:32

Grannypiper, legalising drugs would bring them under the control of authorities, which they patently are not at the moment. No one would be selling heroin in the corner shop but it would mean children could be monitored and actions taken to help and support them.

I too have worked with drug addicts and their families. Some of the parents care deeply about their children and would do anything for them not to end up in the same position as the parents have found themselves in. At the end of the day, they're all human beings.

GillT57 Fri 21-Oct-16 13:55:01

Legalising drugs and making them available, legally, to those who need them will not turn the rest of society into a drug addicted mess. Just because something is there, it doesn't mean every one is going to use it. I have a drinks cupboard full of gin, vodka, brandy etc and it sits there month after month with nobody touching it; I don't feel drawn to drink it all just because it is there, and if I have a Gin and Tonic I don't empty the bottle. People take drugs for a variety of reasons, just as some people drink too much, or smoke or eat too much, and of these it is only drugs which have to be obtained illegally.

grannypiper Fri 21-Oct-16 14:45:07

Of course they are human beings, i didnt say otherwise, my concern is for the babies born addicted.

SueDonim Fri 21-Oct-16 17:36:55

It's dreadful for a baby to start off life addicted to drugs, no one denies that. But legalising drugs won't make that any worse. In fact, it could improve their chances because the mothers would be on the radar of the health services and perhaps supported to come off drugs while pregnant or at the very least have the right services available when the baby arrives.

nightowl Fri 21-Oct-16 17:46:28

I beg to differ grannypiper, heroin is most definitely not addictive from the very first use. There are many 'functioning' heroin users who can control their habit, very much like alcohol users.

As for alcohol, foetal alcohol syndrome causes terrible disabilities in children and these can occur at very low levels of parental use. In fact it could be argued that alcohol is far more harmful to unborn babies than other drugs but no one is suggesting it should be made illegal. I think the whole question of legalisation of other drugs needs to be considered carefully to break this horrible connection with crime, poverty, prostitution and needless deaths.

Iam64 Fri 21-Oct-16 18:27:38

Yes night owl is right in saying heroin isn't addictive from the first use. I have a friend, now in her 50's who used heroin regularly at the weekends during her teens and twenties. She was a poly drug user. She gave up the drug use without the involvement of any statutory agencies by the time she was in her mid 30's. She always worked in a professional career and continues to do so now, as well as being a loving mother and grandmother.
This is anecdotal of course, but it's consistent with so many other stories of ordinary folk who live amongst us. 30 years ago I'd have been opposed to the legalisation of drugs, including cannabis. Life and work experience has led to me forming the view that criminalisation isn't effective. I agree with night owl's suggestion that the whole question of legalisation needs to be considered carefully to break the connection with crime, poverty, prostitution and needless deaths. As I typed that, I could see a number of young men but mostly, young women I knew when working, all of whom are now dead.

mumofmadboys Fri 21-Oct-16 18:45:26

I have worked with drug addicts for years until two years ago. I agree with decriminalisation of drugs. It is noteworthy that countries who have decriminalised drugs have far better outcomes for drug addicts eg Portugal. The police also waste a lot of time running around after bits of cannabis etc and it does little good. If alcohol was new today it would probably be illegal.

f77ms Thu 03-Nov-16 09:09:01

I am blown away by the majority of enlightened , intelligent posts on this thread .
I also agree that the most harmful , health and family destroying drug is alcohol.

Blinko Thu 03-Nov-16 12:06:06

Agree with both sentences, f77ms

BlueBelle Thu 03-Nov-16 17:51:45

I m not at all sure why people are under the impression that legalising drugs will stamp out all the illegal use do you really think an addict will queue up at the pharmacy when the next door neighbour is offering them some under the counter stuff

GillT57 Thu 03-Nov-16 18:06:02

Bluebelle just read through the carefully considered posts on here, many from people with experience, either personally or professionally. Criminalisation of drug use does not work. Drugs being legal does not mean everyone will start using them anymore than the legal availability of alcohol and tobacco mean that I am smoking or drinking myself to death.

Grannyknot Thu 03-Nov-16 20:24:28

This is a very complex issue, and it's not black or white.

I do agree with decriminalisation in principle.

But, why is there a big street market for licit prescription drugs like benzodiazepines? Because there is. So whatever the legal status of a drug is, it seems there will always be a "black (or street) market".

BlueBelle Fri 04-Nov-16 06:47:42

I have GillT57 that's why I commented

SueDonim Fri 04-Nov-16 11:52:07

If people know they can get 'clean' drugs legally from a centre/GP/pharmacy most will likely choose to do that rather than run the risk of using drugs that have been cut with other substances. Someone who worked in the emergency services told me that he'd had to treat an addict whose heroin had been cut with one of those Harpic toilet block things. Imagine injecting Harpic into your veins!

Illegal prescription drugs are an issue but if there is less of a market for illegal drugs the drug gangs are less likely to bother trading in the U.K.altogether.