Gransnet forums

Blogs

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 15-Dec-16 11:41:07

How to handle an invisible friend?

Is there a right way to handle an imaginary friend? Do you acknowledge them, invite them to tea and treat them like part of the furniture? Or wait until the phase has passed? Author Pip Jones has the answer, courtesy of her experience with an invisible cat...

Pip Jones

How to handle an invisible friend?

Posted on: Thu 15-Dec-16 11:41:07

(58 comments )

Lead photo

Does your grandchild have an imaginary friend?

It can feel like a steep learning curve, becoming a mum. One minute, you know precisely how to 'do life', the next you're in a state of 24/7 perplexity, trying to figure out precisely how this tiny little being you've created, you know, 'works'.

Of course, there are hundreds, if not thousands, of books and websites now to help first-time mums – between them all, they must offer every possible solution to every possible problem, so mums are bound to hit on the right answer sooner or later. One thing I never found any help with in my pile of baby/toddler books, though, was how to solve a problem like Cat.

You see, Cat wasn't your average cat. He was my little girl's invisible kitten, a friend she imagined one day, quite out of the blue, when we were reading a pre-nap story.

Ava was only two and a half at the time. All toddlers, in this burgeoning stage, are prone to crazy leaps of imagination on a minute-to-minute basis – she described what Cat looked like in minute detail. But what I wasn't expecting was for Cat to stay as long as he did. After Ava's nap, he was still there. At the end of the day, he was still there. After a week… yep, he was still there. Cat lived with us for months…though at the time it felt longer.

Ava is now eight years old and Cat left us a long time ago, but I have talked a lot about him in the last few years. Two questions I've often been asked are: 1) What was it like, having an imaginary friend in the house? And 2) Was it weird, how did you cope?

The honest answers are:

Mostly it was funny. It was certainly enchanting, watching a girl so in tune with her own imagination that she'd managed to create a kitten 'real' enough to actually act independently of her. So yes, I'd say it was 90% funny and enchanting. It was also 10% infuriating/maddening. No rushing mother wants to have to unstrap her only-just- strapped-in toddler from the car seat, so she can go back into the house to retrieve a forgotten invisible pet. And no mum wants to haul herself out of a relaxing bubble bath three minutes after she got in, because the invisible Cat had decided to get out of the bath, and was now shivering on the floor and needed a towel 'QUICKLY!'

Even when we're required to step into an imaginary realm, it seems that mums, dads, grandparents and extended family do seem to just get on with it.


2) Yes, it definitely was weird, in many ways. I didn't think twice about holding or talking to Cat when out in public with Ava. I expect I got some 'looks'. But that was the thing – when it came to 'coping', it was really more just a case of adapting. There was no arguing with Ava, you see. My instinct as a mum told me to go with the flow. Me telling my daughter that Cat WAS in the car with us would not, for one second, have convinced her when, in her mind, he was in the house, upstairs, on her bed. The fact that Ava sometimes tried to encourage Cat to do her bidding(extra rice cakes, additional bed time stories and so on), well, I wised up to that pretty quickly.

I never really spoke to my friends at the time, about Cat and his antics. I realise now I should have.

A quickly drafted question on my own Facebook page, about whether any friends' children had imaginary pals, returned approximately 25 'yeses' in the space of an hour or so. I was gobsmacked! All these invisible friends! All these mums, dads and grandparents run ragged not only by their own kids, but by invisible children, dogs, aliens…!

One thing that struck me: what all my parent-friends had in common was that they didn't find the imaginary friends worrying. Just like me, instinct had told them to stay cool, be patient, engage, and learn from the experience. According to the experts, that's precisely the right thing to do.

I asked a clinical psychologist, Dr Genevieve von Lob, about the right way to approach an imaginary friend who's moved in. "It's up to you how much attention you give to imaginary friends," she said. "But the best thing to do is to acknowledge and include them as a legitimate presence in the household.

"Be curious about this invisible visitor — and try not to dismiss them as non-existent, or figments of a child's imagination. You might even ask to speak to the imaginary friend, which may help you gain a greater insight into how your child feels, or reveal their perspective on certain issues."

Like many other (sometimes testing) aspects of parenting, even when we're required to step into an imaginary realm, it seems that mums, dads, grandparents and extended family do seem to just get on with it.

As Dr von Lob said: "Imaginary friends can, understandably, pose challenges – but they are a true expression of the magic of childhood."

There's no arguing with that.

Pip's book, Squishy McFluff: The Invisible Cat, is published by Faber and Faber and is available from Amazon.

By Pip Jones

Twitter: @FaberBooks

Helenlouise3 Mon 05-Mar-18 15:44:27

Our son had an imaginery friend called "Gwilym" of all names and he was around for around a year. We never knew what form he took and he didn't require a place at the table etc, but our son often spoke to him when playing. We did use him to our advantage on times. Once when our son refused to eat we told him that Gwilym would be here soon and then it would be gone. within minutes the plate was clean. It never bothered us as we knew he'd eventually go away and we often laugh about it now.

Fflaurie Thu 01-Feb-18 09:55:20

How do you know they are invisible friend? they may be invisible to you, but very often children can see spirit. I had an invisible friend when I was a child, he too went away, but to this day I still see and hear spirit. We should not assume that because we can't see something that it isn't there.

Lisalou Sun 28-Jan-18 21:00:33

I had two of my own. Kaichie and Gooey, funny that I still remember their names. My mother, bless her, would open the car door and lift each one of us out of the car - to the delight of our local butcher! I also had a whole string of horses which I had to round up in the garden before bed....I was a very imaginative child, clearly

inishowen Tue 02-Jan-18 16:42:35

My GD had two invisible friends, Tom and Lily. Tom was naughty all the time. Our GD would sometimes get quite distressed saying Tom was hitting her. This went on for about a year. Recently I asked her where Tom and Lily went. She said "we decided to say goodbye because we have busy lives since starting school". To me it was all rather ghostly.

RayL12 Sun 15-Oct-17 20:37:36

My imaginary girlfriend said I was rubbish in bed. :-(

Breda Mon 09-Oct-17 19:55:14

I have only just seen this thread but it brings to mind two imaginary friends. The first belonged to my brother who had a friend called Jimmy who got into so much mischief but who was very real in my brothers mind. The other one was Peter Hazeley who was for a very long time lived with us as my eldest daughters companion. She would tell me quite earnestly about the conversations that she had had with Peter Hazeley and what they had done when they played together. Some years later my husband and I realised that this was a name that she had picked up from a children's t.v programme and it had quite obviously caught her imagination. I think he was around right up until she started school!

palliser65 Mon 14-Aug-17 12:09:56

My youngest daughter had an imaginery friend. We relocated and apparently she went to live in Brussels (my husband worked there sometimes). Unfortunatley we sat down to tea one day and the daughter said 'move up Banna's here'. Anyway she lived with us a while and eventually we heard of her less and less. My daughter is now a very well respected psychiatric nurse.

Maggiemaybe Fri 28-Jul-17 11:13:50

Reported.

jessica881 Fri 28-Jul-17 11:03:31

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Dauntless41 Mon 17-Jul-17 16:03:48

There are such things as angels, you know.

Chewbacca Fri 07-Jul-17 22:17:44

My DS had an imaginary friend when he was about 3 years old. The amount of detail he had for Martha was astonishing. She always wore a pink dress and she had long blonde curly hair. She had no shoes because her mummy and daddy had died in a fire and their house had been destroyed; that's why she lived in our garden. She could only play at certain times of the day because she had to go to work in a factory making cloth. She ate at the table with us but didn't like meat, only bread and vegetables. Funny thing is that when DS was with one of his particular little friends, she used to talk and play with Martha too, in exactly the same way as DS did. I missed Martha when she left!

Nanabilly Fri 07-Jul-17 17:20:13

My great niece had an imaginary frienð when she was around 2 or 3 I think it started . My sister (her gran) was always spooked a little by it for some reason and she was driving along one day with said gd in the backseat when Alyssa said something about Charlie ( the imaginary friend) being in the car. My sister asked where Charlie was and was told " on your knee nana " she almost crashed her car . Charlie was with them for quite a few years and may be even with them now .
Her gd's other grandad was a logical "ghostbuster" so that may be where he came from.

farmgran Fri 07-Jul-17 10:27:32

My eldest DD had an imaginary friend called Diarrohea, she never described her but I had to be very careful where I put my feet so I didn't tread on her, especially at the clothes line. Later on Diarrohea was joined by Donny and Buree and the children.

grandtanteJE65 Tue 30-May-17 16:14:45

I had an imaginary friend I called Rita, after the real friend of my older playmate, Kathleen. I never told my parents anything about Rita. She lived in the wall of my bedroom, where there was a whole flat (strange that, as we lived in a house). I went in there at night in my imagination, while I was lying in bed trying to sleep and spent time with Rita, her younger brother and her parents, but I don't think they had names. I was four at the time. Rita disappeared when I went to school at five. My little sister's imaginary friend was James, she told us all about him. We never had imaginary animals, we didn't need them, as we had two cats, two dogs, hens and cage-birds. I am sure imaginary friends are quite normal up to the age of eight or thereabouts. I talked to my dolls and teddies who were my children until I was at least twelve.

Caroline64 Thu 25-May-17 11:17:23

What a delightful post! It occurs to me that my son and daughter - now grown up - may not have had imaginary friends as such because, living on a farm, there were hand-reared chicks/hens, ponies, sheep, dogs a cat all to hand. However they both had two dozen soft toys each for all of whom they had names and 'stories' so the capacity of the bright young mind for this sort of thing is phenomenal!
My greatest fear had always been that my child might turn out to be a psychopath (now estimated at 1% of the population but very much to the fore in my childhood because of the Moors murders...) and probably genetic and 'incurable'. Nurturing behaviour like this totally rules that out and hence is a delight and bodes well for their ability to be kind.

HillyN Fri 14-Apr-17 15:39:11

I had an 'imaginary' (he still feels real to me!) friend called Pixie. I can remember him quite clearly now, dressed just like a pixie should be. One day, not long after my sister was born, he went on holiday. I helped him pack his case and off he went. He never came back.

notoveryet Wed 25-Jan-17 14:18:55

I am an only child, I hated it and desperately wanted a sibling. I had an imaginary friend and his entire family. His brothers were very naughty and were forever being sent to prison, I wouldn't dare to be badly behaved so I think we can see where that came from.

frankie74 Wed 25-Jan-17 10:59:06

One of our children, aged about 3, had an imaginary friend in Robin. Robin was there, everywhere we went. There was Robin's chair, Robin's field, Robin's stream, Robin's house and so on. These things existed in their own right, but it was ages before we found out who Robin actually was. One day, while walking in our little town, crossing the river bridge, our son shouted from his buggie, pointing at the sky..."There's Robin. He's flying home!" And there was Robin....a duck! After that, Robin was never mentioned again. Our son is in his 30's now, but we still ask him about Robin, poor man!

Sillynanny65 Fri 20-Jan-17 17:07:46

My daughter had an imaginary friend who we would have to make a place at the tea table for her. In the car she had to have the middle seat belt, we had to talk to her and ask questions like what would she like for tea, and then my daughter would answer for her. This o lay lasted for a few months, and the 'friend' went away as quickly as she came. She was never spoken about again.

GannyRowe Sat 07-Jan-17 10:25:01

Oh yes, overthehill, she remembers it now. She seems to have inherited the family trait from my side of the family of being a 'sensitive' and has both seen and felt unexplained presences.

overthehill Wed 04-Jan-17 17:17:00

Gannyrowe that sounds spooky.
Does she remember it now?

judypark Wed 04-Jan-17 16:17:48

George sounds very similar to my "friend" Gilbert, he had wavy shoulder length blonde hair GannyRowe. Interesting on this thread that it is only or first born children that this seems to be mostly prevailent.

GannyRowe Wed 04-Jan-17 11:39:15

My daughter's invisible friend was George. He hung around for a couple of years! Trouble was when we asked her to describe him, .......he had short trousers that gathered at the knee, long socks, shoes with big silver buckles on the top, long hair a bit like Mummy's (at the time a long pageboy)! He had frilly shirt cuffs, and a big collar etc etc, so much detail, and all from a three year old! The list went on and on and on, and never changed between times we asked either. Sometimes when her sat close beside her it made her feel cold, and sometimes she said she could see through him!!

overthehill Fri 30-Dec-16 17:16:35

I to was an only child, I had an imaginery friend call Jacqueline Joyce. I didn't have the best of childhoods so this 'friend' was kept well away from my mother and father, I don't believe they knew she existed, or if they did she was never mentioned.

My own daughter had a couple of 'friends' but they were introduced to the family. When her younger brother was old enough to join in games they were forgotten.

Falconbird Thu 29-Dec-16 19:22:05

I was an only child and my parents moved about a lot during my early years. I had five pretend children and I was responsible for them and as I was only 5 this was hard work smile My parents were very worried about my pretend children but when I was six they were replaced by a pretend dog and cat which were far less hard work. By the time I was seven the pretend dog and cat had gone as well. Some children have invisible friends and some don't. My eldest son had a pretend dragon on a chain but the other two didn't have any invisible friends.