Gransnet forums

Charities

Remembrance Sunday

(131 Posts)
Visgir1 Sun 10-Nov-24 14:37:50

Think a lot of people spotted the disrespect. Many Scots gave their lives in the 20 century for the UK.
If he didn't want to be there get someone else to do it, sure he could lie sighting an issue.
I bet he claimed for expenses.
Disgraceful.

Oreo Sun 10-Nov-24 14:01:51

If a politician or anyone else attends a Remembrance service or parade then no point in being there unless they join in.This is especially important where politicians representing us are concerned.If this man didn’t want to be there for his own reasons then a deputy should have attended in his place.

I watched on tv, it was as lovely and as poignant as ever.

Ilovecheese Sun 10-Nov-24 12:58:34

Chocolatelovinggran I don't think so, the Remembrance service is about honouring and remembering fallen service men and women. I expect some of them were republicans too.

Chocolatelovinggran Sun 10-Nov-24 12:28:40

I have just attended the event of Remembrance at the local war memorial. One of my grandchildren was involved in the wreath laying.
I am a Christian and joined in with the hymns and the prayers, and, as a Republican, stood quietly as others sang the National Anthem.
I cannot speak for the person you are describing, but I wonder- should I have stayed away from this event. Should my not singing the National Anthem have barred me?

madalene Sun 10-Nov-24 12:22:12

I saw him too. He was very noticeable because of the way he stood, almost as if he was proud of making his protest. I agree, if he couldn’t join in fully with the spirit of the occasion, he should have let someone else take his place who would have behaved appropriately.

MoonStone93 Sun 10-Nov-24 12:07:01

In honour of my father I never miss the Remembrance Sunday Service at the cenotaph. Today has been no exception but as I watched I noticed one of our politicians, I believe he was there on behalf of the SNP, without a "programme" and who did not join in with any of the hymns, prayers or the national anthem.
I am a firm believer that how people conduct themselves and what they believe in is their business but this man looked like he didn't want to be there and his behaviour was not in the spirit of the occasion. Today's gathering, as always, is to respect and remember our forebears. This man looked churlish and disrespectful. I wish he'd stayed at home and allowed someone who really did want to pay their respects attend in his place.