Gransnet forums

Chat

The Golliwog

(119 Posts)
dorsetpennt Thu 26-Apr-12 15:46:03

My daughter works at our local university. She has just texted me to say that someone has sent a round-robin email advertising home-made golliwogs. In this day and age!!! I know a lot of people do not feel that there is anything wrong with a golliwog - it's just a toy. However, if you look into the history of the golliwog you will see why it is considered a racist slur. Ask anyone of afro-caribbean descent and they will tell you they wouldn't allow such a toy in their homes. It is included in the various racial epithets as : mammy, pickaninnies, black and white minstrels etc. We may not have realised this as young children and in the past toys of this nature were considered fine. It's like telling Irish jokes, in the US Polish Jokes and so on. We realise nowadays that comments, toys, jokes,etc of this nature are offensive. What do you think ? Offensive toy, ignorance of the facts or is it just silly to make a fuss about nothing.

Bags Sat 28-Apr-12 11:51:55

Oh, by the way, the marriage to the white man was her second marriage. Her family arranged a marriage with a muslim man first. That one lasted all of two months.

Bags Sat 28-Apr-12 11:50:06

Quite. Racism is about political clout and "blacks" are just as likely to be racist as "whites". In fact, the most racist person I've ever known (actually the only racist person I've ever known!) called herself black. Her skin wasn't much darker than mine, though she tanned more easily. Her forebears were from India. She never stopped criticising "white" people. "Whites" could do nothing right. The real problem? A huge great chip on her shoulder, that's what, in spite of Britain taking in her entire family as refugees from Idi Amin's Uganda and she and all of her siblings benefitting from the education system and health care, etc. that Britain gave them.

I pitied her resentment but I also came to the conclusion that what she was really suffering from was constant culture clashes between her muslim family's ideas and the freedom she tasted as a partly integrated British young woman. Last I heard the muslim side was winning but it cost her the custody of her child who was the product of a short marriage to a "white" man.

More than anything such stories are just sad.

goldengirl Sat 28-Apr-12 11:45:30

Well, in that case, why not just change the name from Golliwog to Golly or some other name? The doll itself is lovely I've always thought. I certainly enjoyed playing with my two Gollies / Gollys and like other little ones never thought of any connotations associated with them. It's the adults that are causing the problems!

harrigran Sat 28-Apr-12 11:35:07

I actually tested that theory by asking GD, whilst looking at a picture book. Pointing to the black child I asked her what she saw, her reply was that she had the nicest pair of shoes on smile

imjingl Sat 28-Apr-12 11:20:21

johanna you weren't being racist in either of those situations.

goldengirl they do. Children don't notice. smile

Annobel Sat 28-Apr-12 11:12:15

I thought Viv Richards was best mates with Ian Botham... or have I been misled?

Butternut Sat 28-Apr-12 11:10:58

Harri -grin

harrigran Sat 28-Apr-12 11:05:58

I believe they do. Having watched children in nurseries, they play with dolls, colour is not important. My GD's baby doll is mixed race.
Aren't we all exactly the same, we are human beings whatever colour we are. I think make up might be a bit of a problem though if we were green.

petallus Sat 28-Apr-12 11:03:25

Is Viv Richards being racist though (not being overly keen on white people)?

goldengirl Sat 28-Apr-12 10:52:12

Do black children play with white dolls?

johanna Fri 27-Apr-12 23:47:21

Sometimes it is possible to be inadvertently racist.
Here are my anecdotes .

A good family friend , who lives in Bermuda told me that her best friend is also a best friend with Viv Richards, the famous cricket player.
After I expressed my surprise at this, knowing that Viv Richards was not overly keen on white people, there was a little silence, and then she said:"My best
friend is black".
Imagine what a p.... I felt.

Our local cricket club, which the male side of my family is involved with, has a strong youth policy and one of those guys was a black lad known as Louis.
Whenever I see him I say Hello Louis, thrilled with myself for at least remembering at least some of the names.
Little did I know that Louis is his local nickname after Louis Armstrong.
Fortunately he could not care less.

absentgrana Fri 27-Apr-12 21:04:56

I have read through this thread with some interest - not least because yesterday absentdaughter and I were looking in an arty-farty shop in the local mall (in New Zealand) and I was surprised to see a display of gollywogs. She told me that, on another occasion, she had remarked that it was unusual to see them these days. In response, the manager replied, defensively in absentdaughter's opinion, "We've generally had a very good response". I was surprised to see them as I haven't seen them in the UK since the 1960s and because it seemed that there was a general agreement that they could be regarded as offensive. My own feeling is that they are best consigned to history.

Presumably Gransnet has black as well as white members and, obviously, no one is expected to state their ethnicity before posting. However, it would have been interesting to hear from black grannies whose perspectives would have been different from that of those of us who are white. It would have been especially interesting to hear their comments about the "well-meaning white liberals and racism".

whenim64 Fri 27-Apr-12 19:10:58

Jingle grin

imjingl Fri 27-Apr-12 19:04:14

And they call their stuff "Excalibur"!

I don't think so. angry

imjingl Fri 27-Apr-12 19:02:55

How do you blow up a website?

whenim64 Fri 27-Apr-12 19:00:17

I know the BNP pinched the English flag a few years ago, but football seized it back for the World Cup and it doesn't have the same BNP connotations now. The comments from some of the people at the bottom of that page don't lead one to think that their intentions regarding the golliwog are anywhere near as honourable.

greenmossgiel Fri 27-Apr-12 18:57:01

whenim64 -'politically incorrect' indeed. We understand what they're up to, by selling these things, and it's nothing like the selling of home-made golliwogs as Dorset spoke of (unless, of course, the person selling them belongs to the BNP hmm)

glammanana Fri 27-Apr-12 18:53:05

Stansgran The term wogs came from the shortened version of Working on Govenment Service when Egyptians worked for the British Army and the letters on their armbands where marked with the letters wogs.It is facinating the History to the term golliwog I have learnt a lot over the past few days.

greenmossgiel Fri 27-Apr-12 18:48:47

Bags - that's how I feel too. In our country we now see people of many different races. They marry and have relationships with each other, and have children, who will have their own children. This will go on indefinitely, 'diluting' facial characteristics and possibly culture. Accepting this as how things will be is how it SHOULD be.

whenim64 Fri 27-Apr-12 18:44:47

Please look at this link, and scroll down a little to find the BNP golliwog key rings for sale

www.bnp.org.uk/news/national/new-british-national-party-merchandise-available-excalibur

soop Fri 27-Apr-12 18:41:24

granjura and Bags Quite right. With you all the way. smile

granjura Fri 27-Apr-12 18:39:23

What on earth would the 'intent' be on anyone who wants to bring them back??? I'd seriously question their motives. I never found Gollywogs offensive as a child, of course not. But if some people have been offended and bullied- and Gollywogs were part of this - then that is good enough for me.

Bags, like you I don't believe in being 'colourblind', or 'differenceblind' - those differences make all our lives richer and therefore should not be ignored.

Butternut Fri 27-Apr-12 18:27:22

Hear, hear!

Anagram Fri 27-Apr-12 18:22:17

I agree absolutely, Bags.

imjingl Fri 27-Apr-12 18:22:11

Bags. Stop. It is quite obvious that you would never be racist.