Gransnet forums

Chat

A good reasoned argument

(14 Posts)
jeni Wed 16-Jan-13 20:56:51

Any body got a a topic for a good,friendly, well reasoned debate?
I suggest we stay off religion.
Something on the line of the great debates?
Eg My country right or wrong!
Not that one but on those sort of lines?

Stansgran Wed 16-Jan-13 21:14:57

Why is Switzerland out of the common market but its citizens allowed the privileges of EU citizens through our airports?

jeni Wed 16-Jan-13 21:20:07

Are they?

glassortwo Wed 16-Jan-13 21:20:25

Ireland will the issues ever be put to bed?

Ana Wed 16-Jan-13 21:21:07

Which ones?

Ariadne Wed 16-Jan-13 21:21:29

I think this is a great idea! Trouble is, jeni that most of the great philosophical debates seem to end up, or even start, with discussions of free will, fate and so on, which would inevitably lead us back into the usual two sided arguments. But no doubt someone will have a good idea. Just not me right now; maybe tomorrow..

Ariadne Wed 16-Jan-13 21:23:38

Religion again. The Irish issue is ostensibly based on religious conflict, although it goes much deeper than that. (I taught in Londonderry in the 80s and learned a lot, very fast!)

jeni Wed 16-Jan-13 21:32:01

Sleep on it folks.
I'm at work tomorrow, but should be back by five!
There is always the old one of
'Is there such a thing as a just war' particularly in view of hindsight and the last few years.
I can't imagine we could do it like the old Oxbridge debates, but!
Come on folks, a little academic debate could be good for our aged brains!grin

MiceElf Wed 16-Jan-13 21:35:45

Do you agree that if there was a world wide ban on arms trading and manufacture, many of the evils manifest in society would diminish greatly?

If so, how could it be enforced?

MiceElf Wed 16-Jan-13 21:40:46

Alternatively:

Should prison be a punishment reserved for only the most heinous offences in a civilised society? If so, what other punishments should the state impose to indicate its displeasure and rehabilitate the offender?

jeni Wed 16-Jan-13 21:41:06

Good one!
I'm to bed!moon

jeni Wed 16-Jan-13 21:42:48

Could open threads on both those!
Over to you Mice
Open them and wait!
Goodnightmoon

Ariadne Wed 16-Jan-13 21:55:01

With you, mice! Tomorrow. moon

MiceElf Wed 16-Jan-13 21:56:31

I've done as Jeni said