Giving us "--not so-- oldies " a bad name

If people don't move bags from seats when the train is busy, I just sit on the bags.

I don't allow it, the taking up of two seats, I just move their bags onto their laps and sit down.

Re the first class, I do know that sometimes people will buy up a whole compartment and have 'reserved' stickers on the windows, so that they can travel in peace.

I too hate the legs invading my space, but I do sympathise with them. Wouldn't we all like to be able to spread ourselves out - but we can't. However, the seats are at the right height for my legs, not for those men with much longer legs. It's like me sitting on a child's tricycle.

The worst example of manspreading was when we booked a whole table for us so that we could travel back from Newcastle to London with a 5 year old and an eight year old at 6pm. Two businessmen were on our table, clearly marked with our names and they were removing them! They refused to give us our table and seats. As we had just passed the guard as we moved down the train in search of our carriage, I stood there with the children, glaring at them and repeatedly asking them to give us back our seats while DBH went to fetch the guard, who took one look at the tired children and forced the men to go elsewhere. It made me wonder how many other people suffer from such rudeness. Why on earth hadn't they booked?

On some journeys it's cheaper to travel First class. Our station master always works out the best option, which is great. I travelled First by default last year on a journey from Edinburgh to Cheltenham. I was in a carriage full of happy, singing, dancing teenagers on a school trip, so asked if there was a seat in the 'quiet' carriage. There wasn't one on that service, but the Train Manager took pity on me, picked up my luggage and trotted me down to First for free! It was bliss - free wifi and cups of tea and biccies.
I object to sitting opposite, usually a man, who has his legs stretched out under the table and under my seat. I take great delight in accidentally kicking their ankles.....

I typed easy? Where did the easyjet come from? Ipad! I'm the one travelling, not you!

This trip to York is 4 hours! I couldn't do it in a standard seat. I have reserved one that is close to the WC as with my balance, walking on a moving train is not easyjet!

I travel 1st class if I can get a deal. I used to be able to go to Scotland on Trans Pennine for very little more than the standard fare, but last time, it had almost doubled.

The last time I caught a train I travelled first class. It's a four hour trip and I wanted to know where I was going to sit and I was travelling late at night on my own. It was very pleasant, no one sitting next to me and hardly anyone on that carriage. Plus it didn't cost much more.

I found travelling on trains when I lived in the UK and worked in London extremely expensive. I could not believe it.

There is no way I would stand while someone occupied two seats. The cheek of some people!

Me too Riverwalk

The New York subway authorities are launching a campaign to stop 'manspreading' - blokes sitting in a Y shape taking up more than their fair share of space www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/new-york-metros-campaign-to-stop-manspreading-9938025.html

I have no qualms about asking someone to budge over/move their luggage and so on but I'm not sure that I'd have the temerity to ask a large man to close his legs

Apparently, a related bit of slang is 'manslamming' whereby blokes who are walking just cannon into you if you are in their way.

I'm surprised that any adult would be so timid and not 'be brave' enough to ask someone to remove luggage from a seat so she could sit down, especially if the alternative is to stand if there are no other seats!

(Aside from drunks, yobs, etc. being the culprits.)

The French have no qualms and will happily ask people to move luggage so that they can sit down!

Actually someone once got the ticket inspector on a London Midland train I was on to tell someone to remove their suitcase so that the seat could be used. He was very polite but firm - probably wasn't the first time he'd been asked to do it! Don't think I'd be quite that brave.

I think you need to be careful what you wish for, Eloethan.
Abolishing First Class wouldn't necessarily increase the numbers of passengers using the trains, and could even reduce them if first class passengers chose to fly instead, so if the train companies lose revenue by not providing First class accommodation, they will have to increase the fares in standard class to make up the deficit.
As for empty carriages, and overcrowding, it's up to the train companies to manage their rolling stock effectively.
I was once travelling back to Newcastle from Harrogate and for some reason, I think it was at the time that all planes were unable to fly because of the volcanic ash cloud, the train from York was horrendously overcrowded and the guards let people with standard tickets use first class, so they do have discretion.

What annoys me about train pricing is this business of if you want a return ticket from A to C via B, it is sometimes a lot cheaper to get two single tickets, or even buy separate tickets from A to B and from B to C, but you only find that out after three quarters of an hour's headache-inducing searching on the Internet. That really shouldn't be necessary, the most cost effective way of making the journey should be clear and obvious.

I don't use first class in order to be elitist but more for the peace and quiet it affords. We tend to travel at weekends and I don't want to spend a 2 hour journey in a carriage with either football supporters or hen/stag parties. The wine/beer is out before we've left the station and we're then regaled with tales of sexual conquest or fights I have had. I'm no party pooper and if that's what people want to do then fine, I just don't want to be an unwilling participant in their party!! Not every train has a quiet carriage so first class is the only option. Some providers don't actually have a separate first class compartment but just a few seats at the end of a carriage and I wouldn't pay extra for those. I have seen conductors on busy trains telling passengers they can sit anywhere. Just rechecked cost of train journey to Shrewsbury and it's anywhere between £250-800 - and that's with a rail card! I could be in America/Australia for that. Should the railways be nationalised again?

I use trains a lot long distance but very often will not know which train I will be getting for the return journey so it would be impossible to reserve a seat. Travelling first class means I know I have a seat without a reservation. My commuter trains to and from London don't have first class but I have never had to ask someone to give me their seat as I am unfailing offered one immediately. When I'm travelling with luggage I hate not being able to keep an eye on it and that's often impossible in a crowded train. I do agree about how wrong it is for people to have to stand whilst there are empty seats in first class because no one who has bought a ticket should be standing.

I'm surprised 1st Class hasn't been abolished already, on the grounds of elitism!

Don't you think that in this day and age it would be better to get rid of 1st Class?

When I go on the train from Liverpool Street to Colchester to visit my mum, the First Class section is almost always virtually empty. At the time I travel that isn't much of an issue but at busy times it seems ridiculous that some people might be standing for an hour when there are carriages with lots of empty seats.

I understand that if a person is elderly, pregnant or disabled, it is essential that they have a seat, but can't this be guaranteed by paying a small charge to reserve a seat? Or, better still, that people who are young, fit and able, are actually considerate enough to give up their seats when they can see there is a genuine need (some do, but many more could).

Just make sure you don't get screwed in a corner,uncomfortably or otherwise

I'm travelling first class to York and back. But with my crutches, bag, papers size etc, I probably need a whole coach

I must admit I like travelling first class on the train. Scotrail do an offer in less popular months called Club 55. You can get a standard return anywhere in Scotland for £19 and first class for £26 so that's when we treat ourselves. I did try and price taking the train to Shrewsbury to visit my brother and it was hundreds of pounds even standard fare. We could have got a week in the sun for the price they were charging. Back to Flybe!

I always ask ninathenana. It wouldnt occur to me not to ask!

Oh I have the nerve and usually manage to crush a toe en route. What I would like to do is ask innocently"does your briefcase have a full price ticket and a seat reservation of its own?"

Or those that sit in an isle seat with a table in front so if you want to sit by the window you have to ask them to get up or would they mind moving over.
I've never had the nerve.

Pardon???

Would you like to rephrase that, *absent?

It's the same with those men who sit with their legs spread widely apart so that even if you have the temerity to squeeze past to sit down, you are uncomfortably screwed up in a corner.