Gransnet forums

Chat

Favourite TV detective?

(158 Posts)
Kandinsky Sun 07-Jul-19 09:12:22

I think mine is inspector Morse.
Although I still love Columbo grin

What about yours?

Itsnew01 Sun 07-Jul-19 10:13:08

Mine would be Maigret,Played by Rowan Atkinson. Also Pie in the Sky.

sodapop Sun 07-Jul-19 10:11:08

I agree Saggi Michael Kitchen is fantastic as Foyle. Also like others
Endeavour
Adrian Dunbar
Idris Elba

Apricity Sun 07-Jul-19 10:10:41

From the Antipodes, yes it's Morse, first and forever. He is so real, so conflicted but so lovely, so socially incompetant, so completely and utterly hopeless with women but honest and true as the day is long.

And I can't imagine anyone but John Thaw ever, ever playing him but I do acknowledge that the prequel series of 'Endeavour' has done a terrific job - and that is saying a lot for someone who generally doesn't like prequels/sequels etc.

I have also greatly enjoyed the Morse follow on 'Lewis'. I think they did a great job of continuing the very real and convoluted themes and conflicts of 'Morse' without it being a copybook sequel.

Vale Morse.

GrauntyHelen Sun 07-Jul-19 10:08:52

Rebus

vickya Sun 07-Jul-19 09:58:56

Brunetti's wife and family are very good too, as are his assistant and the secretary.

Esmerelda Sun 07-Jul-19 09:58:22

James Garner in The Rockford Files ...

vickya Sun 07-Jul-19 09:57:53

Lewis and the newer one in Midsommer, the one with the dog. Not sure how many grans will have seen the Italian Brunetti ones. They are available do download. They are set in Venice and the detective is lovely, there is the German detective Borwoski on Ch 4. And the original Miss Fisher smile

maximka25 Sun 07-Jul-19 09:57:45

Inspector Montalbano (with Luca Zingaretti, not the young Montalbano)
Brother Cadfael
Poirot (David Suchet)
Morse/Endeavour (both are brilliant)

Mossfarr Sun 07-Jul-19 09:54:54

Shaun Evans as Endeavour for me.
I also like Morse, Vera and Frost (although David Jason was far too old for the role for any sense of reality).
In my younger days I loved The Sweeney but watching it now its far too aggressive and unrealistic.
I also like Hearbeat, it has lovely a sense of times past when life was more gentle - even the crime!
Does anyone actually watch Midsomer Murders, Murder She Wrote or the Miss Marple type of programs? To me they are absolute rubbish.

olliebeak Sun 07-Jul-19 09:54:45

DCI Barnaby played by John Nettles - sorry Neil Dudgeon, I quite like you, but not in this :-( / DCI Vera Stanhope (Brenda Blethyn) / Miss Marple (played by Geraldine McEwan or Julia McKenzie) / Hercule Poirot (David Suchet)

Goodbyetoallthat Sun 07-Jul-19 09:53:53

Father Brown played by Mark Williams.

EllanVannin Sun 07-Jul-19 09:53:18

Paddy Considine ( Mr Whicher series)
Colombo.
Vera.

Hahahaha, there seems to be a pattern going on here as they all appeared " down at heel ". I always did favour the underdog !

Coconut Sun 07-Jul-19 09:52:54

Commander Steve McGarrett, the new Hawaii Five-0 ❤️

ninathenana Sun 07-Jul-19 09:51:10

All of the above.

DH and I both love a good detective story. I can't think of one I don't like.

Not strictly detectives but we love all the NCIS programs. Mark Harmon is an added bonus ?

Teetime Sun 07-Jul-19 09:50:49

Morse!!

Saggi Sun 07-Jul-19 09:50:35

Michael Kitchen in anything ...but in Foyles War , he is enigmatic. Casting just right. Love Frost... and adore Lewis , but I think that’s for the dishy Lawrence Fox as have never been big fan of Kevin Whately. Vera is so good as well. In fact detective shows are my go too programmes when I want cheering up.... all that murder and mayhem.... oh on that point I firgot the fabulous Midsommer and it’s glorious ‘body count’. Love em all.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Sun 07-Jul-19 09:49:19

I like Laure in Spiral, and her male assistant who my friend calls 'bull-dog man' - I can't recall his name, he's got that battered about look which can be attractive in a man.
Also Neil Dudgeon in Midsomer Murders.
I also like looking at the beautiful scenery of Paris and what we like to think of as typical British villages.

Theoddbird Sun 07-Jul-19 09:48:22

Miss Marple. Oh and Morse and Vera

merlotgran Sun 07-Jul-19 09:47:22

Endeavour (Morse)
Cormoran Strike
Julien Baptiste
Vera

crazyH Sun 07-Jul-19 09:44:41

Columbo Ofcourse !!

wicklowwinnie Sun 07-Jul-19 09:43:20

Douglas Henshall in Shetland and Taggart. smile

Ellianne Sun 07-Jul-19 09:42:31

George Gently, and Bergerac for the Jersey lifestyle.

123coco Sun 07-Jul-19 09:39:38

Salvo Montalbano just for sexiness. And I don’t even prefer short men but he’s the exception.

Marydoll Sun 07-Jul-19 09:33:23

Oh, so difficult! Montalbano, Morse, Foyle, Ted Hastings, (Adrian Dunbar) and the rest. grin

glammanana Sun 07-Jul-19 09:28:16

George Gently and Vera