I only pinponted working class abuse because it was what I heard of from my GM ,she didn't work with women from any other backgrounds and it was women whose hubands worked in factories and shipyards who hit their wives that my GP helped.I know it happened and still happens in other walks of life .even now .
The women they worked with were in the main uneducated and didn't expect anything else ,they had no say in any part of their lives and chastisement for overstepping their "place" was the norm .I'm sure there are well documented cases of this and I know there were very basic refuges for women in Glasgow.In fact I remember seeing photographs of the poor sould in one refuge which was little more than a hovel .
I have never excused wife beating ,just explianed it was learned behaviour .
Surely Jane 10 there are millions of Scots living in other countries who still love Scotland ,even some on here .They may have left because they had no choice for work or relationships or because their parents took them when they went.Doens't diminish their feelings about being a Scot one little bit.There are many IN Scotland who are happy to be ruled by English based parties are we to imagine their feelings are more relevant ?