Gransnet forums

Chat

Are the corona virus idiots doing us a favour?

(59 Posts)
growstuff Thu 31-Dec-20 13:36:00

The Black Death killed 30-50% of Europe's population.

Even though, there was little understanding of infection, people did quarantine themselves. They stayed at home when possible and the wealthy went to live in the country.

It depends what kind of outcome you want. I don't think a few million deaths is doing anybody any favours.

Smileless2012 Thu 31-Dec-20 13:29:43

But there was no vaccine at the time Sweden tried this; surely now we have one that would make a difference to the outcome.

Lucretzia Thu 31-Dec-20 13:23:39

I think Sweden tried this.

It's gone terribly wrong

LauraNorder Thu 31-Dec-20 13:21:15

I, like you Bluebellwould, don’t condone the mass gathering and selfishness of the ‘idiots’, but you have a point. Rolling out the vaccine as quickly as we can, coupled with the inevitable herd immunity caused by the selfish party goers, may help to get this over with.

Spangler Thu 31-Dec-20 13:19:31

What you have described, Bluebellwould, is the way previous pandemics have been conquered. Even plagues like The Black Death were overcome in such a way.

I got the gist of what you meant but doing us a favour is a tad insensitive.

Shinamae Thu 31-Dec-20 13:16:44

Good point Bluebell....

EllanVannin Thu 31-Dec-20 13:14:56

Herd immunity do you mean ?

Missingmoominmama Thu 31-Dec-20 13:14:52

You can’t discount those things though.

Bluebellwould Thu 31-Dec-20 13:11:50

It’s a bit hard to phrase this but have the stupid people done us a favour, to put it bluntly. If you discount, just for the sake of argument, the damage to the nhs and its staff, the suffering of the innocent who’ve caught COVID through no fault of their own, is this mass infection all at once doing us a favour in the long run?
Surely if more people have got it and the 98% that survive it can’t get it again, then the virus has less victims waiting to get it. If you add that to those who get vaccinated are we not reaching a point of the virus dying out?
Please don’t point out the horrors caused by catching it, I have all my family in frontline roles and am only very well aware of what happens and the possible long term affects.