Gransnet forums

Chat

Did your parents have a favourite child?

(207 Posts)
songstress60 Sun 17-Jan-21 15:27:18

I am interested in knowing if any of the people on this forum had parents who had a favourite child, and it if affected their life. Were you the favourite child? Were you the unfavourite child?

I come from a family of 3 daughters and the middle daughter was definitely my mum's favourite. In fact my mother told me that after her birth which happened when I was 2 years of age I became a "jealous little bitch". She said that I spoiled everyone's childhood, but I feel that she made a real favourite out of my sister right from the start. My dad actually told her off about it because when my sister was a baby she would put her to bed and nobody was to disturb her while she bonded with her daughter. He said I did not get a look in at all. She was resentful of my youngest sister who was an accident, and always favoured my middle sister who could do no wrong in her eyes. When my sister bought her first home my mother's housewarming present was a vanity unit, a fitted wardrobe, and a dressing table. My housewarming present was a set of cat ornaments from a charity shop which I got rid of after her death. After she had been married 3 years my dad bought her some new rings:- a new eternity ring, wedding ring, and engagement ring. You would think she would divide the 3 old rings between the 3 of us. No! She gave my middle sister her ALL 3 of her old rings. I know I am not the only unfavourite child. A friend and work colleague of mine deliberately only had one child because of all the favouritism her mother bestowed on her sister. My other friend was also the unfavourite child who decided to have no children after having a miserable childhood where she felt second best. I would love to hear of other gransnet readers eperience of this, and if any of them as parents actually have a favourite child themselves?

Esspee Mon 18-Jan-21 14:31:57

My only sibling was a twin and very premature. His brother didn't make it and it was a long time before he was able to come home. My mother's life revolved round him.
When I caught measles I was put outside in the pram so that he was protected. Even as teenagers he received much more pocket money than me. I didn't get the option to go to Uni. He was subsidised through to a PhD.
Strangely enough, although conscious of the bias, I never disliked my mother for it and my brother and I have always got on well.
It probably helped that I was a daddy's girl.?

Buffy Mon 18-Jan-21 14:15:51

My father didn’t show favouritism but my mother always did. We are 3 girls and I am the middle one. The youngest could never, ever do any wrong. I spent my whole life trying to win my mother’s approval and when she died at the age of 100 she finally told me I had turned out the best of all 3. What she meant was that I doted on her until her dying day. I’m not proud of that, rather, sad that I needed her approval so much. Never a hug, a kiss or a cuddle

Helenlouise3 Mon 18-Jan-21 14:14:39

I'm the eldest of 3 girls. There's almost 6 years between the middle sister and myself and then just 18 months between her and the youngest. Growing up I can't say I noticed than any of us was treated differently, except that I was often told "take your sister with you" when I went out. I did get resentful of that in my early teens. The youngest had far more freedom as a teenager and moved away with her boyfriend when she was 17. From then on she was the favourite. Her children would come and stay for the whole of the Summer holidays etc while we were lucky to get a visit 3 times a year. She never took either my or middle sister's children even out for a day. My daughter never spent a night with them until she was 12. It's the same now. they live 10 miles from myself and middle sister yet we never see them unless we visit, yet they go hundreds of miles to visit our youngest several times a year. Even though we moan about it, you won't find 3 sisters closer than what we are,
as adults.

tictacnana Mon 18-Jan-21 14:08:03

My mum was the middle and extremely unfavoured child. A relative told me of the physical and mental abuse my mum suffered at the hands of her mother. As an adult the abuse continued in a different way. She bought presents and helped out with buying school uniforms for her other grandchildren but we didn’t even get birthday cards. My lovely mum must have been very hurt on our behalf. I would have been. For myself, I always felt that I was favourite but I dare say my siblings felt the same because she was such a wonderful amazing mother.

NotANana Mon 18-Jan-21 14:02:53

Yes they did, and it was not me. My younger sibling was the beloved and indulged child.
We are not close even after many decades.

Judy54 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:57:41

No. There was only a year between myself and my late Brother and were were more like twins. Our Parents loved us equally and my Brother (my only sibling) and I loved each other very much throughout our lives. So sad to hear many of the stories about feeling less favoured than a Brother or Sister and the impact that it has had on lives into Adulthood.

icanhandthemback Mon 18-Jan-21 13:57:31

My sister thought I was the favourite and vice versa. My younger sister got all the affection, got away with murder and my Mum was always nice about her to me but horrible about me to my face. I still think she was the favourite but I do think that my Mum can never pay a compliment to us personally but will sing our praises to others.

Petalpop Mon 18-Jan-21 13:48:33

Yes my brother was the favourite with my mother. There where three of us. Brothers number one and two and me the baby. As far as my mother was concerned brother number one could do no wrong. He was highly intelligent which she raved about yet when he left his grammar school he dropped out of going to university but still could do no wrong. He liked a drink but she would accept that he was an alcoholic even when told by her sisters. He was disdainful to her until the day she died. Unfortunately since she has passed he has died of malnutrition due to his alcoholism, brother number two has a good life and all the trappings and I gained a 2.1 degree at the age of 63 (the only one in our family at that time - she had written me off well before she died). I have two DC and although they are not perfect with one in particular causing us a lot of pain in the past I could never put one above the other. Love them to bits.

Happysexagenarian Mon 18-Jan-21 13:44:49

I can't really relate favouritism to my own upbringing as I was brought up separately from my siblings, though perhaps that was a sort of favouritism in itself as, being an 'only' child, I had a more indulgent childhood than they did.

But although we never favoured any of our three sons my mother most certainly favoured our eldest from the moment he was born. She thought we should be content with just one child so when our 2nd son arrived two years later she was very critical of him, saying he was too chubby and why was he blond and he was nothing like his lovely brother! You can imagine her reaction when we had a third son three years later. Shock and horror, what were we thinking of! Whenever she visited she made a huge fuss of our eldest, bringing him gifts and giving him money and openly saying he was her favourite, but treating his brothers as an afterthought. Our youngest didn't seem to notice this, but our middle son did. He was polite and friendly to my mother but avoided her by going to his room. He asked why Nanny didn't like him. He became rather introvert, which sadly stayed with him till recent years. I didn't try to compensate for this unfairness in material ways, but I was always more protective of him. I, of course, challenged my mother about her behaviour and asked her to treat all the boys the same. Her opinion was the eldest child should be the most important in the family as they would be the one to care for you when you got old. How selfish is that! And I knew that was how she saw my role in her life, it didn't happen.

My mother's attitude was probably the result of her own upbringing. She was the eldest of two sisters, a bit plain, shortsighted and not very academic or creative. Her sister was the opposite and their mother's favourite. And, yes, my mother lived with and cared for her parents until they died.

We don't have any favourites amongst our grandchildren (natural or stepGC) and I hope we treat them all the same and love them equally.

Alioop Mon 18-Jan-21 13:40:29

I always been told it was me. The youngest child, youngest grandchild on both sides and the only red head lol. To me, I got all the hand me downs, clothes, toys, etc and I only got a brand new bike when I was 14 and fashionable clothes when my sisters got married and left home so there was more money for things for me and then I was told constantly I was spoilt and my parents favourite.

Cabbie21 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:31:24

Whilst I can’t say that either of us was the favourite, my parents certainly favoured my sister in many ways because she had health problems. She got away with things.
When I was about 9 I remember my Gran asking my Mum ‘why don’t you ask J to do that? ‘ Mum replied that she refuses, or that I do it more reliably or more promptly. So I got given more tasks to do.
Later, my parents always had my sister at Christmas, and only after she went into a Home did I get them to come to my house.
I can’t say I was jealous, as my life has been so much more rewarding than my sister’s and I have worked hard and fought my own battles.

Lettice Mon 18-Jan-21 13:24:03

I am the eldest, having two brothers and a sister. We all had a phase of being the favourite as there were almost four years between each of us. At 7, I went to live in the country for a few months with an aunt, after I had been ill. On my return it was blatantly obvious that both parents were weak individuals who should never have married and over the next few years I really took over the reins making decisions not just for myself, but for the others. At 18 I managed to get a house and moved us (the children). Meantime mum and dad split. She re-married and had a little girl. I was 25 by this time and my mother then came into her own. My half sister is a delight still and was a joy to our mother. Amongst my two brothers and full sister, it is that first sister who is the favourite of us all. For my mother, she admired me, but had no love in her life at that time to give.

Happyme Mon 18-Jan-21 13:23:40

So sad for all those who felt "second best" to siblings, some genuinely sorry stories here of parental bias. I do wonder though if sometimes our perceptions of favouritism reflect notions we carry from a childs point of view rather than an adults. I could cite a number of occassions when my brother received 'preferential' treatment.....private education being one.....but have always recognised that we are different characters with different needs and the parenting we received reflected that. I never felt less loved. My own daughter would say her brother is the favourite but I can assure you both are loved equally and we are proud of the adults both have become.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:21:07

Naming no names, MIL appeared to prefer F, he was indulged and got more help, financial and practical, nicer and more expensive presents, U was largely independent. It was often felt that if F were drowning she'd jump in to save him - but would shrug her shoulders if it was U, "he'll be all right." Years later we found out that U was her favourite - she'd bent over backwards to hide her dislike of F. This apparent favouritism did him no favours - he never seemed happy or content with his lot.

She and F were domineering, bossy and 'always right' and both wanted to be top dog. You can't have two egos sharing the spotlight peacefully, can you? Years later when U died too young MIL had to rely on F to get about, shopping etc and it was impossible for them to share a car journey without a disagreement. A psychiatrist would have had a field day.

barbiann57 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:20:12

My older sister was my mothers favourite. My mother placed great importance on looks. My sister had curly hair, whereas mine was straight, with a fringe. God, how I hated that fringe. I grew up listening to her singing my sister's praises all my life. It then included my sisters children. My mother could not see how hurtful she was being.

Bankhurst Mon 18-Jan-21 13:16:20

My sister was the favourite. I was born unwanted in June 1945 exactly 9 months after my parents were married, and when my mother was just 22. She said she didn’t enjoy any teenage years because of the war- she was 16 when it started- and when it was over she was a mum. Not my fault, I think. Among other things, she forgot she had me and left me outside a bakers shop in my pram and let me fall off a table at 6 weeks old. I could never do anything right for her.
My sister, born 3 years later, was wanted and was treated very differently.
Apart from the hurt, it affected my life practically. For example my sister received coaching to get into the ‘right’ school and so got a better education than me.
At least she acknowledges she was treated differently which is some consolation

19Maria61 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:09:50

I am the eldest of 6 girls the one after me was mums favourite and sadly became a right nasty pasty when she wanted my next sister was born with spina bifida and her life has been spent in and out of hospital it’s not until quite recently I’ve learned that no2 was really jealous of the fuss made of 3 I ask you the poor thing has had more surgeries and procedures than anyone I know and has been at deaths door more times than I dare to count no4 and 5 where largely brought up by our grandparents because of no3s health but didn’t have any issues then along came no6 there was quite an age gap between her and 5 and she was a bit put out by this new arrival ? it turns out I was dads favourite although I didn’t know until he died my sisters all told me that he thought the sun shone out of me. I’m glad I didn’t know I might not be the person I am today if I had.

Gillyanne Mon 18-Jan-21 13:08:24

My elder sister Jenny was definitely Mum's favourite as she was always refered to by Mum as 'My Jeniffer', my poor Dad spent his life trying to making me feel wanted and loved . It was years later when they had all died that I discovered that Jenny was only my half sister and my Mum and Dad had marred when she was 5. No one thought I was important enough to be told the truth!! I think my Dad though I had a very unhappy childhood and I think I would agree with that sadly .

Kimrus Mon 18-Jan-21 12:57:26

I was the eldest of 3 girls. The youngest was my parents favourite right up to their dying days. The middle sister was the one who always took what she could get. When my parents had to go into care, it was me called home to fire the bullets and get them into care. What happened then, both younger sisters sat back and no help whatsoever to sort and clean their house. I live on the other side of Australia to them. The day the house was sold, my sisters couldn’t be bothered to fill me in on what was happening with the parents. I had to read about my fathers death on fb and then when mum died I was told 2 days after the fact that she had died and they would let me know of funeral details. That never happened either, I had to ask an auntie to be told the funeral had already been held. The parents wills, had both sisters as executors and I could have a say if I lived within the same state as my parents. Well that wasn’t going to happen. My mother was the absolute b...ch and my 2 sisters have become her. I haven’t spoken to them from the day I was told mum had died. When I did get my inheritance, with no offer of anything that my parents had kept, I split it between my own 4 daughters. Their grandparents hadn’t given them anything ever but doted on their other grandchildren, so I told my daughters to spend it and have lots of fun. I don’t have a favourite daughter because of the way I was treated by my parents.

JGran Mon 18-Jan-21 12:53:23

I love this question. Yes! I was the favorite, but I didn't know until I read my mother's journals after her death. Sadly, my elder sister also read the journals and was really hurt by it. The reason that we didn't know is that you'd have never known by my mother's actions. Our parents were always helping my sister and often it seemed had very little time for me. I actually made a habit of getting up at 3 am in order to have time with Dad. Mom always made me redo my sister's chores saying she didn't do it as well as I did, etc. But, I am glad they didn't do for me and I was made to do things on my own. Fast forward to today, my sister is borderline homeless almost her entire life and has in fact been homeless three times in her life. Drugs and alcohol have ravaged her body and I even bought a house for her to live in or she would be homeless today with her child. So, while it warmed my heart to find out that my mother really did love me, it breaks my heart that they handicapped her by helping too much.

kathw12 Mon 18-Jan-21 12:38:54

It makes me so sad to read the comments. My mother certainly has a favourite child-my brother who is the youngest of 3. She was desperate to have a boy after my sister and I and made it so obvious. There are many stories I could tell. I was my fathers favourite my poor sister (rip) didn’t get a look in from either of them. Consequently I vowed not to have 3 children due to seeing how awful life was for her growing up. I’ve two lovely adult children a son and daughter and two grandchildren again one of each who I love dearly. I’ve had counselling to try to deal with the stuff my mother did both as a child and an adult but still live with the effects x

rozina Mon 18-Jan-21 12:37:00

I was definitely the UNfavourite child. I don’t remember any hugs, or kisses from my Mother. My brother was allowed to go to College but I wasn’t. For his 21st birthday he had all the relations there at a plush restaurant, for mine I had just my parents in a sub-standard restaurant with penny slot machines on the walls. My Mother liked boys ad they brought more money into the house!!!

CSizzle Mon 18-Jan-21 12:36:12

I am the middle one of 3 girls. All three of us feel that the others were more favoured.
I once met a woman doing her Christmas shopping. She had several grandchildren to buy for. They each got £20 spent on them except for the eldest. He got £100, 'because he's the firstborn'. I asked why that made any difference, and she just kept saying 'because he's the firstborn'.
You'd think she was landed gentry, where the rules of primogeniture applied. But she lived in a council house.
Very strange.
Poor lad, besides being spoilt rotten is going to have some very jealous siblings and cousins, growing up to dislike him.

lizzypopbottle Mon 18-Jan-21 12:31:34

I'm not surprised that there's been so many responses to this thread. My older sister was definitely my mother's favourite. She emerged as a clone of my mother, was pretty, loving and well behaved. I came along and was a different prospect! I think, given hindsight, (and modern contraception) my mother might've stopped at one golden child.

Throughout our childhood, she tried to convince us that I was my father's favourite. There was no favouritism on his part. He was scrupulously fair but imaginary slights are still remembered to this day, especially by my younger sister.

This inevitably shaped who we are today but I grew up my own person and I don't resent anything my mother did. She was a human being, with human faults, shaped by her own upbringing, as we all are. My younger sister has come off worst. She struggled between rebellion and bending over backwards to please.

mrsgreenfingers56 Mon 18-Jan-21 12:26:53

This is a sad thread in many ways. No child should be a favourite, all children should be treated the same. I was one of three girls and my mother always said she treated us all the same (which she did and so did my father) and never had a favourite. She said she had always smacked us the same! Well this was the 1950's!