Gransnet forums

Chat

Am I without humour if I can't see why a lot of 'new' comedy is funny?

(142 Posts)
Rosina Mon 19-Jul-21 11:58:08

Yesterday I watched a programme with Dawn French and Jennifer Saunders, celebrating women in comedy. They showed clips that made me laugh so much - one in particular of Lucille Ball wearing a far too heavy hat and trying to dance; it was hilarious and so well done. So many names, from childhood and up to a few decades ago, with sketches that were nothing short of brilliant both in writing, timing and delivery, but I found that I wasn't laughing much as the comedy from the last few years was shown. It seemed to be relying on 'shock swearing' to make the audience laugh, and I finally gave up and switched off when Sarah Millican, doing a stand up, waved her hand around her knicker area and asked the audience how they were feeling 'down there' - she felt 'claggy', one of the audience yelled 'moist' and they all roared with laughter. Am I dull and without humour because I can't find this amusing?

TiggyW Tue 20-Jul-21 12:09:30

I tried to watch ‘The Spy who Dumped Me’ - absolute rubbish. The usual four letter expletives from the verbally challenged. angry
Best comedians by a mile - Peter Kay, Victoria Wood, Ronnie Barker, Mike Harding, Michael Palin, John Cleese, Bill Bailey.
I’ve been trying to determine why I find them so funny - I think part of it is because they can all raise a laugh without saying a word. It’s their facial expressions. Brilliant!

loopylindy Tue 20-Jul-21 11:59:42

Kathrine Ryan

loopylindy Tue 20-Jul-21 11:58:34

Although appreciation of humour and humourous acts modifies with age, we still find ourselves watching older programmes mainly because they rely on quick wittedness and careful and sophisticated use of language to get the laughs. We still corpse when watching some of the Two Ronnies stuff. R. Barker was a genuine wordsmith. Jasper Carrott used obsevational humour to great effect, as did the great Victoria Wood. Her crafting of her many songs was masterful.
I suppose you can gather from this we're not too keen on 'modern' humour, though having said that we weren't too keen on the Young Ones or Monty Python either.

ExDancer Tue 20-Jul-21 11:57:33

I never liked Ken Dodd until I saw him 'live'. Almost from the start, my sides ached with laughing. He obviously was enjoying himself too as he carried on until after midnight although he was billed to finish at 10pm.
A very clever, funny man.

tictacnana Tue 20-Jul-21 11:57:32

Victoria Wood was a genius. During lockdown Tom Wrigglesworth’s Hang Ups on R4Ex and Alexi Sayers Imaginary Sandwich Shop have kept me going.

Edith81 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:47:35

Hello girl I met Tom O’Connor in Hayling Island and I enjoyed his humour without any swearing. I also liked Freddie Starr and his antics. I don’t watch today’s comedians.

Gabrielle56 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:44:29

Oh and adored French and Saunders movie specials, any more please ladies? There's so many movies you could just tear apart!

Gabrielle56 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:42:53

Delbert Wilkins. Theophilus P.Wilderbeast.....yall know who I'm talking about? The great Lenny Henry! I always thought he wasn't on enough and loved him in just everything he did specially with Tracey Ullman and David Copperfield (where's he?) in 3 of a kind. Loved Tracey Ullman s last series, the separated twins Nicola sturgeon and Angela Merkel! Had us roaring.shes so witty and brilliant writer for others.

sundowngirl Tue 20-Jul-21 11:41:47

So sad about Tom O’Connor. Many years ago we were on a quiz programme with him as the host snd he was a perfect gentleman. Chatting to us before and after the show and ensuring we were relaxed and making us laugh with his quick wit. A few years later we were on another show with Michael Barrymore such a difference. He wouldn’t speak to you unless on the show and sent scriptwriters to us to make sure we said the right thing for him to make a joke of. Rip Tom O’Connor you were a naturally funny man

Jaxjacky Tue 20-Jul-21 11:40:44

Love Billy Connolly live, he was a bit sweaty but it fitted in, Mrs Browns boys too, and now Romesh Ranganathan. He and Rob Beckett’s series vs is very amusing.

Youngatheart51 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:40:44

I find observational humour funny, Michael Macintire, Jason Manford to name a couple. "Comedians" like Frankie Boyle I find totally offensive.
WILTY is a must watch in our house, even more so when Bob Mortimer is on it!

NannyG123 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:34:41

Fav sitcoms. Only fools and horses. Porridge. Fav comedians. Jason Manford. Michael Mcintyre. Peter Kay. Mickley Flanagan. He does swear but very funny.

EmilyHarburn Tue 20-Jul-21 11:33:29

I still enjoy Victoria Wood. I am not a fan of Sarah Millican. I do not think her female genitalia jokes are funny whatsoever.

Infinity2 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:33:01

Ken Dodd was the best. ❤️❤️❤️

FannyCornforth Tue 20-Jul-21 11:29:38

I saw Ken Dodd at the Birmingham Hippodrome with my family circa 1982. We didn’t leave the theatre until getting on 1am.

Aepgirl Tue 20-Jul-21 11:25:02

I really don’t ‘get’ modern humour. It’s unpleasant, full of expletives, and just makes me feel uncomfortable. I enjoy programmes like ‘Would I lie to you’ and am amazed that the ‘comedians’ on there are much more restrained in their language (or perhaps it’s all done by editing).

Bring back Ken Dodd - he was sometimes a bit naughty, but never rude or unkind.

PinkCosmos Tue 20-Jul-21 11:23:41

I can't understand why Mrs Brown's Boys is so popular.

schnackie Tue 20-Jul-21 11:23:00

I think Michael McIntyre (sp?) is brilliant. Very much observational comedy and not much swearing. Also David Mitchell is such a great writer and actor - particularly Upstart Crow (Shakespeare) and Back on Channel 4.

Rosycheeks Tue 20-Jul-21 11:21:17

I liked Dick Emery "Honky Tonk" and his frustrated lady with dark hair and glasses trying to get into a prison, that is so funny its on you tube. I never liked Norman Wisdom he just left me cold.
There isnt any new comedians that I like really. I did like Eddie Izzard but he/she has become very political. I liked French and Saunders when they took the rise out of films and plays.
Anyway I make myself laugh most of the time. Oh and Victoria Wood when she did Brief Encounters everyone was good in that even Michael Parkinson.

FannyCornforth Tue 20-Jul-21 11:20:31

Infinity2

I absolutely loved the comedy series The Windsors. I’m going to buy it on dvd when I can.
I thought it was hilarious.

It’s amazing isn’t it? So funny and so clever too smile

JaneJudge Jo Brand also did an outstanding ‘sitcom’ about geriatric care called ‘Getting On’
But I must admit that she was the worst stand up I have ever seen, my mate and I walked out.
I’ve seen hundreds of stand ups live.
Izzard (in his early 90s pomp) and Dara O’Brien were probably the best; but I wouldn’t cross the road to see Eddie now!

Nannymarg53 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:16:48

Joan Rivers - brilliant ?

DaisyL Tue 20-Jul-21 11:16:13

I used to love the News Quiz on Radio 4 - find it so unfunny now - can't listen to it. Of modern comedy I love I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue and WILTY. Don't mind a bit of smut but canned laughter when anyone says anything rude about any celebrity is just IMO but what do I know - I'm just an old woman!

Cp43 Tue 20-Jul-21 11:15:16

Im very much in your camp.
Todays comediennes are quite vulgar.

Antonia Tue 20-Jul-21 11:12:26

I never found Monty Python even remotely amusing. For me it was just silliness.
I did enjoy (with everyone else, surely?) the 'four candles' sketch, and lots of other Two Ronnie sketches.
I'm not a fan of modern comedy, except for perhaps 'Not going out,' which has some really funny episodes, although some are just too contrived.
Swearing isn't necessary in humour, but it may be be just my old fashioned views.

polnan Tue 20-Jul-21 11:12:19

as I have got older, my sense of humour is now "dry" takes a lot to make me lol.... but inside, I smile a lot at people, and the use of language.. in everyday life..