Gransnet forums

Chat

Am I without humour if I can't see why a lot of 'new' comedy is funny?

(142 Posts)
Rosina Mon 19-Jul-21 11:58:08

Yesterday I watched a programme with Dawn French and Jennifer Saunders, celebrating women in comedy. They showed clips that made me laugh so much - one in particular of Lucille Ball wearing a far too heavy hat and trying to dance; it was hilarious and so well done. So many names, from childhood and up to a few decades ago, with sketches that were nothing short of brilliant both in writing, timing and delivery, but I found that I wasn't laughing much as the comedy from the last few years was shown. It seemed to be relying on 'shock swearing' to make the audience laugh, and I finally gave up and switched off when Sarah Millican, doing a stand up, waved her hand around her knicker area and asked the audience how they were feeling 'down there' - she felt 'claggy', one of the audience yelled 'moist' and they all roared with laughter. Am I dull and without humour because I can't find this amusing?

soop Sat 24-Jul-21 16:29:14

I enjoy 'Yes Minister' type of humour. It's very clever and I wish that there were more such programmes.

Allsorts Sat 24-Jul-21 16:03:02

Not 29 yr old, a 10 year old it should have been.

Allsorts Sat 24-Jul-21 16:02:17

I wouldn’t let a 29;year old watch Sarah Millican? Joe Lycet is embarrassingly pathetic, switched off Sewing Bee because of him
also that loud Canadian woman, she is dreadful. I like a quick wit that doesn’t rely on a steady stream of expletives.

MissAdventure Sat 24-Jul-21 15:44:01

smile
I've an inkling I may have seen it, but I didn't know it was Ronnie's daughter.

FannyCornforth Sat 24-Jul-21 15:41:28

MissA
Ronnie Corbett’s daughter has an antique-y boutique-y type shop in Brighton.
It’s called Four Candles.
I think that’s wonderful, I can imagine that he was a lovely dad.

MissAdventure Sat 24-Jul-21 14:58:01

I love most comedy.
Not Mrs. Brown's boys, though.
Not dad's army.
Not cannon and ball.
No problem with swearing.
I like father Ted.
The two Ronnies (four candles)
Peep show.
The inbetweeners.
Loved Les Dawson; there is going to be some unseen footage released soon, as it would have been his 90th soon.

Daisend1 Sat 24-Jul-21 14:18:02

Morecambe &Wise /Ken Dodd /Les Dawson.
No F needed to have me in stitches.

nanna8 Sat 24-Jul-21 14:04:47

Fleabag isn’t funny at all. Only watched a few minutes, that was enough.

foxie48 Sat 24-Jul-21 13:45:43

I'm enjoying listening to Conversations from a long marriage on BBC Sounds. OH downloaded them for me as he thought they would make me smile and they do. Joanna Lumley and Roger Allam play the couple.

Franco Thu 22-Jul-21 21:07:40

I recall seeing Chic Murray on TV decades ago & enjoyed his surreal material. Then in the 1990's an American stand-up came on UK television with clever material in a similar vein to Chic's & I became hooked - his name is Steven Wright.

Steven's material is clean & swearing-free. I don't know if he still performs but there is loads of it on YouTube going back to his very first performance.

Dinahmo Thu 22-Jul-21 17:00:35

If you like Jewish humour there are lots of good clips on You tube - just google Jewish Folks telling Jewish Jokes. They often make me laugh out loud.

Dinahmo Thu 22-Jul-21 16:54:00

I've rarely found French and Saunders funny although I did enjoy Ab Fab. We saw them in a tent in Battersea Park when they had just started out and they were not funny at all. Rik Mayall was there, in his Kevin Turvey role reciting "Fish that I like" and he was very funny.

Dave Allen (I'm sure he would be censored now). Black Books. Billy Connolly and Victoria Wood. I used to like Sarah Millican but there's too much talk about bodily functions. Joan Rivers also very funny.

I suppose some of the subject matter of the older commedians would upset some people hence so much dependence upon bodily functions.

A Netflix series that we've enjoyed is The Kominsky Method with Michael Douglas and Alan Arkin - what I would call wise cracking Jewish humour. The first series was funnier than the second because Alan Arkin left at the end of hte first.

Nannabumble70 Wed 21-Jul-21 23:48:30

Peter Kay for me!

Rufus2 Wed 21-Jul-21 16:16:19

Sir Ken Dodd. grin
When he did his afternoon matinee shows he'd check hi s audience and then announce he was changing the name ,of the show to 'Fifty Shades of Beige!"

PaperMonster Wed 21-Jul-21 15:35:11

GrowingOldDisgracefully I really couldn’t get into Fleabag either, but funnily enough I don’t recall the swearing!!

Somebody mentioned Jonathan Pie and I really do like his videos. But I also found myself turning into him in my last job as I was so frustrated with our education system!

Rosina Wed 21-Jul-21 15:12:57

Well - a great variety of responses and thanks to those who have made me feel that perhaps I'm not a Victorian prude. As several posters have said, humour that has been thought out and has a clever puch line seems so much funnier than listening to someone being told to 'f**k off' . I don't get Mrs. Brown's Boys either, and Mrs Brown makes me feel uneasy!

annodomini Wed 21-Jul-21 11:37:32

Growing0ldDisgracefully Oh, me too. I think it's a generational thing. I watched the firstfew minutes of the first episode of Fleabag and immediately realised that it wasn't for me. I'm not normally a prude, but the 'f' word in just about every sentence wasn't funny and wasn't necessary - in fact, it becomes just plain boring.

Growing0ldDisgracefully Wed 21-Jul-21 10:35:26

I am considered strange in my household because I just didn't find Fleabag funny. Load of rubbish I thought.

Cossy Wed 21-Jul-21 08:33:30

No, you’re definitely not without humour. Different things make different people laugh, visual humour, slapstick, sit cons, stand up, sketch comedy, all different - I like lots of modern comedy, many do not swear

PaperMonster Wed 21-Jul-21 08:32:47

I absolutely love Sarah Millican and my ten year old also does, swear words and all!! I absolutely love Joe Lycett - I was completely unaware of him until Sewing Bee and now I watch lots of clips of his shows. Also I’m watching lots of Peter Kay and Michael McIntyre clips. I went to watch Tom O’Connor somewhere as a child, Cilla was on too.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Wed 21-Jul-21 08:14:11

Remember when Derek Nimmo passed away? I'd watched a modern comedy which was ok but not hilarious, then during the news a short burst of "All Gas and Gaiters" was shown - which was funnier than the previous programme. I laughed more during that three minutes than in the previous half-hour. It just shows that comedy has moved with the times but isn't necessarily funnier.

Naninka Wed 21-Jul-21 00:01:52

I absolutely hate comedians banging on about their sexual orientation. I do not care what they do in the privacy of their own home... but why spell it out. I don't care - just get to the f...ing punchline!! And an f bomb is sometimes effective but not if it's every second word! Gross!

Jzpap Tue 20-Jul-21 23:47:47

I’ve never liked Sarah Millican’s style of comedy. Stand up wise I love observational comedy like Peter Kay, Michael Macintyre and Ed Byrne. Would I lie to you is very funny and Lee Mack seems much better in an Ad Lib situation rather than a script.
Recently I’ve been following some new comedians on Tic Tok, definitely worth looking on there.

Sawsage2 Tue 20-Jul-21 23:44:10

I remember Al Read. Laughing my head off Sunday lunchtimes about 60 years ago. I have his cd from about 6 years ago. The driving test, the daughter in law, getting home after the pub etc.

Sara1954 Tue 20-Jul-21 20:35:39

I’m not a fan of comedy, I often just don’t seem to get it, or just find it too insulting and sweary.
Lemongrove mentioned The Detectorists, that I did enjoy, it was lovely.
My youngest daughter and I can never have enough of One Foot in the Grave, her children think it’s awful.