Gransnet forums

Chat

Are we more 'enlightened' now?

(83 Posts)
RichmondPark1 Wed 20-Jul-22 11:06:23

My dream would be that in 100 years time we have equalised society, spread wealth more evenly and provided better education and opportunity for all. Hopefully this would mean that crime is much diminished and that those committing crimes get help to become contributing members of society. Well, I can dream. smile

Chestnut Wed 20-Jul-22 10:32:04

Yes the punishments for minor transgressions in the past were excessive, and especially for children who seem to have had no rights at all. We have moved on and in many ways things are better, but we seem to have gone too far the other way. When you see such lenient sentences for murder and appallingly brutal crimes it is very upsetting. Some of the judges seem to let people off with a slap on the wrist.

vampirequeen Wed 20-Jul-22 08:06:19

We're more enlightened because people fought for change. We have a responsibility to the future to maintain that change and, where necessary, fight for more change.

Juliet27 Wed 20-Jul-22 07:42:13

Some of those petty criminals may well have been sent to your country of course nanna8 and probably ended up doing very well for themselves.

Juliet27 Wed 20-Jul-22 07:38:31

I think I go along with eazybee’s view of 100 years from now. Mind you, I think the world as we know it will have been wiped out by then.

eazybee Wed 20-Jul-22 07:32:47

A hundred years previously, that is 1801, the two boys would have faced the possibility of being beaten, imprisoned, transported or even hanged, for stealing, The items may seem of little value today but may have been of great value to their owners.
A hundred years on, people may look back at our treatment of thieves and wonder at our great leniency.

M0nica Wed 20-Jul-22 07:25:11

That was then this is now. Life was generally harder for everybody then and children were not the cossetted juveniles we have now. Children were out at work at 10 and treated like adults.

100 years from now people will be looking back at our times and thinking how brutal and hard it was.

nanna8 Wed 20-Jul-22 06:46:36

I was researching my husband's family tree and came across a newspaper article from 1901 about 2 of his distant cousins who had been arrested for stealing small items. They were named and no doubt shamed. The issue I have is that they were only 10 and 12 years old and the items were worth practically nothing. What a horrible world it must have been to label young children forever. How nasty were the press in those days. Makes you feel happy we are just slightly more 'enlightened' now. In some ways.