Gransnet forums

Chat

Did they fail me in Dignity, fairness and respect?

(58 Posts)
Dickens Tue 04-Apr-23 14:59:26

Very shoddy treatment, to say the least.

Can Citizens Advice help? I'm sure they have people familiar with this area, or might point you in the right direction

I think you should try to muster your strength, emotionally and physically, and see if you can get some help in appealing the decision. Not easy I'm sure - they appear to make it is difficult as possible.

welbeck Tue 04-Apr-23 14:33:22

OP, have you tried for advice from any support or self-help groups near you.
often those who have been through the system are best placed and more sympathetic to help newbies.

Theexwife Tue 04-Apr-23 14:30:38

I hope that you will feel strong enough to appeal when some time has passed.

MadeInYorkshire Tue 04-Apr-23 14:03:16

... although I expect that they will soon be pestering me 'to go back to work'!

MadeInYorkshire Tue 04-Apr-23 14:02:47

OMG that is awful - I 'suppose' that I am lucky as with my myriad of health complications, meant that I didn't have trouble in getting my DLA (and the car is vital, or I would literally be housebound ... I will send you a message with some potential help xx

nadateturbe Tue 04-Apr-23 13:59:31

The system is rotten and you have my sympathy. Yes.

I would appeal. Nothing to lose.

biglouis Tue 04-Apr-23 13:55:32

Unfortunately its true that if you appeal or report a change of circumstances they can look at the entire claim, and withdraw something you already have.

I am in this position myself (wont go into details) where I could report that my situation has worsened. However I have been advised by two separate benefits advisors that by doing so I am taking a chance that I could be re-assessed on what I now have and lose out. So Ive decided to put up and shut up.

The system is rotten and you have my sympathy.

pooohbear2811 Tue 04-Apr-23 13:43:08

let me just say this is not a "feel sorry for me for what happened post" but more the way in which it happened.

Over the last nearly 3 yrs my health has declined. Declined to the extent I have lost my job of nearly 20 yrs and ended up on disability benefits.

In August 2022 I applied for the new Scottish disability (ADP) which according to their own literature is based on "Dignity, fairness and respect in disability benefits". In November I was awarded the mobility part and became entitled to a car. As I have a lot of hospital appointments in various localish hospitals ( all at least 2 buses away, and medically I can't travel by bus) the car seemed a sensible option over the money. So I picked on my new car on 23rd Dec, giving them a large deposit and trading in my old money pit of a car. The peace of mind this offered me a brilliant feeling.

They did not award me the daily living part, which I felt they should have done and they had not taken into account everything on my form, so I was advised to appeal. I was led to believe by the department itself that this appeal only affected the one part I was appealing on.

Anyway come the end of Feb I received a letter from Motability saying they had been informed my car payments had been stopped and I needed to hand back my car as I was no longer eligible for it. This letter said I would have had a letter from ADP to let me know. To say the least, I was very distraught. Nobody had said anything to me, I had not had a letter from ADP telling me my car was being withdrawn.

I contacted ADP to be told " there would be a letter sent out in the next 7 working days and until you receive that letter we cannot discuss the content of it with you". So on one hand I have a letter telling me I need to hand my car back as not eligible and on the other hand nobody would discuss it with me. To say the least I was inconsolable and terrified of being left with no car at all.

I felt getting the letter from Motability telling me I was losing my car was so wrong. Surely "Dignity, fairness and respect" should have informed ME first that I was going to be losing my car? That I should have received the letter first and only after I had been told should Motability have been informed.

It turns out if you appeal one part they look at both parts again.

Again I was told I could appeal this. But not sure I am strong enough to put myself through the stress of another appeal. right now.

How would other people feel about finding out this way and then not being able to discuss it with the people who made the decision until 2 weeks after another dept had been informed?