Gransnet forums

Chat

Tales about "stingy" guests and hosts.

(178 Posts)
biglouis Fri 29-Mar-24 12:48:35

Just read a hilarious thread on Mumsnet about “stingy” hosts. Tales of guests being invited for “lunch” or “dinner” and given something like one baked potato or a quarter of a pizza unheated. Others invited for a meal and then asked for money afterwards! Or guests who bring a bottle or desert and take it home with them.

Have any of you encountered any examples of extreme stinginess as a guest or host?

Here is my contribution.

Many years ago in uni I became friendly with a woman of similar age on an extra curricular course. We decided to meet later that week but she did not want to travel across Manchester to the rough council estate where I lived. Fair enough.

She invited me to her house for the evening. It was a long cold bus journey in December so I was pretty chilled on arrival. When she went to take my coat I told her I would keep it on as the room seemed very cold. She confessed to not having the heating on “when her lodgers were not there”. Large double fronted house in a naice part of the city.

After about 30 minutes when she still hadn’t offered me as much as a cup of tea or coffee I asked for one, mentioning the long cold journey. She brought me some watery coffee in a mug and told me she “hadn’t got so much as a biscuit” in the house.

“Did I come on the wrong night? We did say Wednesday did we not?”
“Yes why do you ask?”
“Well I may only live in Hulme but I would never invite someone round to sit for hours in an unheated room and I would at least offer them a hot drink when they arrived. Probably nibbles too.”
“Oh I can see where you came from. That’s quite a working class custom isn’t it, feeling obliged to offer people food and drink!
“Well I think its more about basic politeness than social class.”
I didn’t mention that I had brought a bottle of wine. I just left it in my bag.

After an hour and a half I asked if she could call me a cab.
“Oh you can afford taxis on a student grant”
“Well I wont be standing at a bus stop again and travelling across Manchester after freezing my ass of for two hours.”

We never met up again. I don’t think she believed she was being rude or inhospitable. I felt sorry for her lodgers.

The course on which we met was assertiveness training!

Marmight Thu 04-Apr-24 13:26:55

A neighbour, a well heeled Dr, invited us and around 20 other locals, to the evening reception for his daughter’s wedding in a magnificent marquee in the garden. The speeches had over run so we were herded into the hallway of the house to wait. Once allowed into the marquee we were directed to the bar where we were expected to pay bar rates. Oops. No cash. DH popped home for ££. The rain started, it was freezing, nothing happened as it was obviously an interlude in the proceedings. After an hour of thumb twiddling, we looked at each other and made our escape under the flap of the marquee scurrying down the drive & over the fence home like a couple of 2nd class absconders to warmth, feet up, food and the telly. Quickest wedding do ever.

Diplomat Thu 04-Apr-24 13:16:57

When I first met my husband I found it very strange that I would sit for hours at his parents house without being offered a drink (I was too shy and thought it impolite to ask). It was after some time that I mentioned it to my then boyfriend who explained that they made drinks at certain times - after lunch, after dinner etc!! Hard luck if you missed the slot!!

jenpax Thu 04-Apr-24 13:16:52

biglouis

I can understand some reluctance to host nowadays with so many fussy eaters about - vegetarians, vegans and so on. It can be very expensive catering for everyone and I would not want to do it.

I very rarely host now. However if someone calls in without invitation or notice and I I dont want them to stay I dont offer them anything. Usually I just talk to them through the gate and dont ask them in.

Not sure I like my dietary choice of veganism bring described as being a “fussy eater”!!!

Esmay Thu 04-Apr-24 13:05:21

Witzend - biglouis did a precis of the mumsnet post on bill splitting .
I think that the sponger's evening came to £83 and some people had run up £25 .
I had a highly intelligent and amusing Turkish Cypriot friend , who was the most enormous fun and the times that I spent with her were always highly enjoyable .
But -
everytime we went out she always grabbed the bill and split it in her favour .
At other times , she also used to plead poverty about going out and felt no qualms about getting me to pay the bill .
Not only does she own a mansion in Northern Cyprus , a shop , which she rents out she also has a lucrative career .

I discovered that she'd invited one of my friends on holiday to her mansion and expected him to pay her air fares and for every meal out - in fact to finance the entire holiday .

AnD1 Thu 04-Apr-24 13:04:46

We were newly married, a cousin of my Husband and her husband asked if they could arrive the evening before they were due and to stay the night. We were going out but yes they could as I had prepared beds etc ready for their stay the next day. and although I only had the food I had made in readiness for the meal the following day, a huge beef in beer casserole. Would they mind reheating it with the potatoes etc. I expected them to just have the usual portion as I had used about 3lbs of beef steak but when we arrived back we hoped to find most of it left that I could rehash for the meal the next day but the huge casserole was empty, we weren’t that well off but I think we all went to pub the next day instead, we paid as we were hosting! We didn’t try that again!

She777 Thu 04-Apr-24 12:52:13

My husband was working for a company that hired a man from Australia who would be staying in a local B&B. My husband a Kiwi said that the Australian was having a horrible time in the B&B and before I could stop myself he was invited to stay with us. He stayed for 7 weeks and was the biggest pain in the rear you can think of. He would steal food from the cupboards and put the empty packet back in the cupboard. We had a beautiful dog and when I made dinner for us all I usually put a bit aside for her and he would eat it even though he knew it was for the dog. He would sit in the lounge and at about 11pm he would tell me he had no clean towels!!
In the end I told my husband that if he didn’t go I would leave myself. He was then swiftly deployed to a different branch down south.
The night before he left he got himself a take-away curry delivered and didn’t ask if we had wanted anything. As he was sitting at the dining table he mentioned that he had left some chocolates for us in the kitchen. I thanked him profusely and thought how awful I had been about him being ungrateful. When I went into the kitchen there were 3 chocolate eclair sweets on the side that the take-away put into the bag!!!

montymops Thu 04-Apr-24 12:52:07

I think that comment about offering tea/coffee etc when someone drops in, as being working class, is absolute nonsense. It is nothing to do with social class, it is, as someone said, simple kind manners and welcoming politeness. I wonder which class the writer thinks she belongs to?😂😂

NannySue45 Thu 04-Apr-24 12:30:28

We had some relations staying with us for a week and their parents stayed with another cousin. During the week they arranged for trips out/meals out etc to include all of them (including other cousin) but they never once asked us to join them! The male guest came back drunk every day too. By the end of the week we really felt we'd been used just for a convenient b and b. It's now going to be very hard if/when they ask to stay again as we don't want to go through the same situation 😬😬

RosesAreRed21 Thu 04-Apr-24 12:11:13

I got very friendly with someone from Amersham

Lesley60 Thu 04-Apr-24 12:01:43

My sister in law who has always been tight with money came down one New Year’s Eve with her husband I supplied all the food and drinks, they both drank cocktails all night and when they were going home next morning they took the small bottle of vodka they had brought home with them unopened
And also asked for loads of leftovers to go

mlynne239 Thu 04-Apr-24 11:51:04

The stingiest time I have had was renting an annex. The woman owner controlled the heating. We had 9 degrees with the heating on! It was on for 2 hrs a day and we had to go to bed in several layers of thermals and fleece jackets. Condensation on our breath. She complained about the cists and how difficult it was to make ends meet. The house was in Surrey Hills! But this poor Christian widow had my husband completely sucked in and as newbies to the UK we had no idea of legal requirements to provide adequate heat. Ehen the rent was raised 5 ,% I questioned it ad inflation was running at 2%. Oh she said I raise the rent 5% a year on all if my properties. It eas revealed she had 2 houses in Peaslake Surrey and 3 in Scotland!.
Her daughters engagement party was a garden party. The lawn was all set out with tables and chairs tablecloths etc so I eas expecting a NZ style spread with wine and food. The old darling provided huge pots of very weak tea, a guest brought a plate of pikelets but no jam or butter and another guest brought a horrible cake bought from a corner store type of outlet.
It really was beyond belief.

Philippa111 Thu 04-Apr-24 11:50:36

We have a very unusual family name. Once when I was young some unknown-to-us relatives from New Zealand had located us and asked to come and meet us whilst they were in Europe.
My parents pulled out all the stops. Lots of lovely food, drinks etc. They stayed for a very long time. More coffees cakes etc. Eventually they left having been extremely well fed and welcomed. They didn’t even bring a packet of biscuits, no thank you and no further communication. They were called free loaders.

absam1 Thu 04-Apr-24 11:46:16

After the reception she received, I think she was very restrained!

hollysteers Wed 03-Apr-24 16:24:07

Newly married, we were invited round for a meal by one of my MILs friends. After a long wait and sounds of clanging about in the kitchen, she appeared, saying ‘I’ve been saving these specially” and placed two Fray Bentos puff pastry pies on the table.
A working colleague who became a friend, had regular meals here before I gave her a lift to the drama society 20 miles away.
She moved into a new flat and invited me round. Handed a gin and tonic, she proudly showed me her new dining table in the bow window, but no thought of ever using it…

Not stinginess, but misunderstanding when I invited friends for supper and they confessed they had already had their meal, not thinking I meant a full meal…

Funnygran Wed 03-Apr-24 15:07:44

Towards the end of his life my Dad had severe chest problems and felt the cold. He came down to stay with us in Surrey for Christmas and a colleague of DH’s invited us for Sunday lunchtime drinks. They were a Scottish couple who had moved south with the job and were very friendly and with children the same age as ours. When we arrived the house was freezing with the windows wide open in the lounge. We were offered a drink - there was no sign of any nibbles or snacks. My Dad had a glass of whiskey, I had a small glass of wine and my husband declined as he was driving. He wasn’t even offered a cup of tea. And that was it! It seemed rude to leave after such a short time but we were so cold I made an excuse about needing to call somewhere else and we left with the heating turned up full in the car and then the radiators on as soon as we got home. Poor Dad needed another tot of whiskey.

Primrose53 Wed 03-Apr-24 14:26:30

I have a neighbour who is always pleading poverty but she has a mortgage free house of her own, another mortgage free house that she rents out and a half share with her sister in a third mortgage free house which they also rent out.

She goes all over the country staying with friends and acquaintances for weeks at a time. Funny thing is she never invites them back here to stay at hers! So several months of the year she takes advantage of warm houses, good food and TV as she is too mean to buy a licence.

She used to hate putting her heat on in the winter so would come round mine about 4pm when she knew my heating was on and then hope that I would invite her for evening meal.

Many times I did so and only once did she invite us to hers to eat. It was rabbit stew which had stuck to the bottom of the pan, was black and stunk to high heaven! The house was also freezing cold. I suddenly developed a bad head and we went home.😉

Witzend Wed 03-Apr-24 13:40:12

There’s a v good post on MN at the mo about stingy freeloader bill-splitters - Bill-splitter karma IIRC, a great read!

annsixty Wed 03-Apr-24 13:31:51

This isn’t really about stingy but perhaps about the way others live.
We were invited for dinner with a colleague of my H and his wife in their very beautiful new home.
We hadn’t been able to attend the housewarming so they really wanted to show it off.
It was some distance away and as we expected we would be having a drink we had our son take us and would get a taxi home.
We were shown around the lovely house and then sat down for a drink.
We had a thimble full of sherry and then had dinner.
We stared with consommé, obviously out of a tin.
I thought my bowl would never be empty, it seemed as full after every spoonful as it had been before.
This was followed by a grey casserole, any attempt to identify the meat was a Nono
With this we drank the red wine we had taken, no more was offered.
I cannot remember any more.
We then sat down to films of their holidays.
No more drinks were offered.
We then had an expensive taxi home.
We have never been invited since . I don’t think any other colleagues were.

biglouis Wed 03-Apr-24 13:04:52

Here is a paraphrase of an account I found on Mumsnet of how a stingy greedy person got paid back for expecting others to subsidise his meal. Love it

There is a person who works for the company but not on my team who often hears about meals out and adds himself on. No one ever stops him. He does go for the steak, wine, sides etc and insists on splitting and folks are too scared to challenge him for some reason. Now as he’s not on my team he’s not on my team WhatsApp group so I put it out there on the chat I wouldn’t be splitting, just paying for my own. A few added that they’d much prefer to do that (and a few of the newer staff are on a lower wage). No one updated the other man (why would they?) so out we went, all ordered.

The bill came, he said “usual is it?”, I said what do you mean, he said well spilt like always. I took so much delight in telling him that we had all decided to pay for our own, times are hard and we have junior members etc.

Oh the face, the face!!

He said he would never have ordered what he did if he knew we weren’t splitting and I took great delight in saying “you wouldn’t have ordered what you did if you knew you’d have to pay for it all yourself? Didn’t you see some had one meal and a glass of water?”

He was so red, he paid and left without saying a word.

lixy Wed 03-Apr-24 08:49:30

My G'ma used to mutter 'FHB' whenever guests, expected or not, arrived.
'Family Hold Back' is a standing instruction in all our family now.

My aunt, on the other hand, was married to an antiques dealer. He was instructed to keep an eye open for some tiny sherry glasses for use when it was her turn to host bridge nights. He did find some beautiful ones, about the size of a large thimble. It was odd because she was a generous woman most of the time.

nanna8 Wed 03-Apr-24 08:33:18

Another one I thought of. We had a family visitor from the UK who stayed with us for a couple of weeks. We footed the bill of course and on their last night we all went out to a local restaurant. We paid for them and their two young sons and they didn’t even buy us a drink ! Not a ‘poor’ family, either. They then went on to Sydney, hoping to stay with someone who used to attend their church in the UK ( they hadn’t been invited ) Now this person had recently had a baby and only had a small house. I’m pleased to say they didn’t oblige so our relatives had to find accomodation in a hostel. What a shame.🤗

Primrose53 Wed 03-Apr-24 08:27:20

Gwyllt really mean! Imagine all the fuel your son used.

Some people rang my husband on a bank holiday once. They were in dire straits and needed an urgent repair as they had their huge house full of family and friends.

He went out, did the job, left the bill (and he charged no extra for Bank Hol) and the man of the house said “wait there, I have something for you” and returned with his hands behind his back and then produced, with a flourish, the smallest bottle of beer you can buy. 🤣

Gwyllt Tue 02-Apr-24 23:22:24

Not quite like most of the other posts. we had visitors to one of our cottages, and on the first day, they returned home in a police car having crashed their own the next day, my son took them to the garage where their car had been taken to see what the damage was The following day, he took them to the supermarket to do their shopping and brought them home The following day he took him to the train station, so that they could take a day trip, followed by a further visit to the supermarket I suppose we were lucky that they said thank you, but they never even offered my son a bottle of beer to show their appreciation

GrannyIvy Tue 02-Apr-24 17:48:22

We stayed with some friends for a weekend and it amused me when they asked in the morning. Will you want dessert at dinner tonight as I’ll only get it out of the freezer if you will eat it😂 We of course said no don’t worry as felt they didn’t really want to do dessert and then if they defrosted it and we couldn’t manage it we would feel awkward . They also only produce a slice of toast at breakfast but no marmalade or jam as they don’t eat it. Always very welcoming to us tho.

NanaTuesday Tue 02-Apr-24 17:20:22

Calipso

I know the feeling , as per my previous post of today ( now deleted ) When we had guests this weekend , everyone arrived with cooked dishes, Chilli , Lasagna & lots of cakes .Plus all the usual roasties, salads ,baked ham etc . The last to arrive came with food only enough for the one vegan person with them ,which of course is fine .
One of these guests proceeded to be the first to dig in to the food as soon as it was laid out helping themselves to seconds and thirds .While not bringing anything to the table apart from the one vegan dish .
NB Apologies for any grammatical errors in the making of this posting .