Gransnet forums

Chat

PM accepted £20,000 so his boy could study

(267 Posts)
pably15 Wed 25-Sept-24 10:40:45

Sky news today,,PM has accepted £20.000 so his boy could study for his GCSE exams in peace, without all the journalists at his door, someone offered him accomodation so he could do just that...

Allira Sun 29-Sept-24 10:43:47

I just saw this in the Guardian when I was looking up something else:
Lord Alli, one of Labour’s biggest fundraisers, hosted a party for other donors in the Downing Street garden after the election, prompting accusations he had used government property for party political reasons.

That was from August and Lord Alli no longer has a pass.

I am disappointed at Sir Keir's apparent lack of judgement as to how all of this might be perceived; I did expect better of him, frankly.

NotSpaghetti Sun 29-Sept-24 10:40:38

Tanjamaltija
What are you saying?

Tanjamaltija Sun 29-Sept-24 10:27:17

www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1954666/labour-mp-resign-keir-starmer-freebies?int_source=nba

and
www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/rosie-duffield-resigns-labour-criticises-33775687?int_source=mantis_rec_top&int_medium=web&int_campaign=more_like_this_top

Witzend Sun 29-Sept-24 10:24:47

What a deliberately misleading title. He didn’t ’accept’ £20k, did he? He accepted the use of accommodation, which is not the same.

The son of a Swedish friend ‘accepted’ 3 months’ worth of free accommodation from us, when he first got a job in London. We wouldn’t have considered charging him, but any paid accommodation would have cost him several grand.
He did try to insist on paying us, BTW, in case anyone’s wondering.

theworriedwell Sun 29-Sept-24 09:41:47

4allweknow

Maddyfour Exactly, well said. What kind of home does Sir Keir live in that his son couldn't be in a room awY from the journalists. Didn't they follow the family to the temporary address.

The child isn't going to be in the house all the time, he will go to school, attend exams, see friends. Why should he have to face a barrage to enter or exit his own home? Protestors about the Israel/Gaza situation as well as the press.

I think it is perfectly reasonable to have a temporary move if that is better for his children.

HowVeryDareYou2 Sat 28-Sept-24 08:53:08

The millionaire Starmer needed help with that?

GrannyGravy13 Sat 28-Sept-24 08:35:28

Maybe putting the £16,000 down as office expenses was not the brightest decision?

Sue Gray needs to earn her salary, sort out the PR and coms, as so far the optics are abysmal.

I didn’t vote Labour, but I will say again I want this Government to succeed, because if they do not, we are in trouble!

eazybee Sat 28-Sept-24 08:05:12

The latest reveal of another 'concealed' £16,000 for clothes to the PM has given rise to some appalling comments on social media. This relationship with Waheed Alli needs to stop immediately as it is demeaning the role of Prime Minister, never mind what political persuasion. The money should be paid back immediately by those concerned and no more accepted.

Pantglas2 Fri 27-Sept-24 22:18:10

Jane 21.03

So true. Hasn’t it always been about the optics?

Starmer is not getting the rub of the green at the moment and needs to be more like Caesar’s wife - whiter than white.

Wyllow3 Fri 27-Sept-24 22:17:20

I just don't see the problem is any family discuss with the teenager whats best and teenager wants to go and stay for a period with friend for whatever reasons its not our business and not relevant to costing. Storm in a teacup.

Other issues around gifts generally agree with others - best to stop years of custom and practice.

Allira Fri 27-Sept-24 22:08:42

Oreo

Doodledog

I fully understand the Starmer's desire to keep their family life private, and think they have every right to do so.

I also think that their PR is terrible. People like Cummings, Campbell and Mandelson tend to be disliked and mistrusted, but they stop the opposition from spinning everything in a negative fashion, and ensure that any positives are put forward too. I can't imagine any of those men allowing the WFP withdrawal (a) to happen yet, and (b) to be presented as it was. That was a political disaster. Many people stopped listening to anything else the LP said, and many jumped on the media sloganeering and did their work for them by repeating the name-calling etc.

I can't understand why the LP's Comms team have allowed this to happen. Whoever they are they should be sacked and replaced with people who know what they're doing.

I agree with you there.

Me too.
They're not earning their salaries.

However, perhaps we expected something better from our politicians now, more honesty and integrity, and have had enough of their spin doctors.

4allweknow Fri 27-Sept-24 21:57:57

Maddyfour Exactly, well said. What kind of home does Sir Keir live in that his son couldn't be in a room awY from the journalists. Didn't they follow the family to the temporary address.

Oreo Fri 27-Sept-24 21:39:12

Doodledog

I fully understand the Starmer's desire to keep their family life private, and think they have every right to do so.

I also think that their PR is terrible. People like Cummings, Campbell and Mandelson tend to be disliked and mistrusted, but they stop the opposition from spinning everything in a negative fashion, and ensure that any positives are put forward too. I can't imagine any of those men allowing the WFP withdrawal (a) to happen yet, and (b) to be presented as it was. That was a political disaster. Many people stopped listening to anything else the LP said, and many jumped on the media sloganeering and did their work for them by repeating the name-calling etc.

I can't understand why the LP's Comms team have allowed this to happen. Whoever they are they should be sacked and replaced with people who know what they're doing.

I agree with you there.

Anniebach Fri 27-Sept-24 21:36:05

Jeffrey Archer, speaker of truth !

Jane43 Fri 27-Sept-24 21:03:43

Doodledog

I fully understand the Starmer's desire to keep their family life private, and think they have every right to do so.

I also think that their PR is terrible. People like Cummings, Campbell and Mandelson tend to be disliked and mistrusted, but they stop the opposition from spinning everything in a negative fashion, and ensure that any positives are put forward too. I can't imagine any of those men allowing the WFP withdrawal (a) to happen yet, and (b) to be presented as it was. That was a political disaster. Many people stopped listening to anything else the LP said, and many jumped on the media sloganeering and did their work for them by repeating the name-calling etc.

I can't understand why the LP's Comms team have allowed this to happen. Whoever they are they should be sacked and replaced with people who know what they're doing.

I have to agree that they are being very badly advised. I happened to have The Jeremy Vine show on this morning while I was getting ready to go out and Jeffrey Archer was on, he had verbal diarrhoea as usual but he gave an anecdote about when he was in Margaret Thatcher’s cabinet. He said that she was visiting Russia, they were making sure she looked the part and Aquascutum provided some clothing. Archer said no matter what happens make sure they invoice us for the clothing and make sure the bill is paid. Basically you don’t compromise yourself if you don’t give anybody ammunition. With the amount of flak they are getting they need people with a great deal of experience to advise them. IMO they really need to tweak the decision about the WFA to make it fairer even it means losing face by not sticking to their initial decision.

Iam64 Fri 27-Sept-24 20:45:09

I wasn’t a big fan of Campbell but my word, he protected Blair. Recently, I’ve found myself saying to that spaniel and her lab companion ‘where’s Alistair Campbell when yiu need him”. This is what happens when you/I live alone other than with fairly clever dogs. Sadly they’re too young to remember the last Labour govt or I’m sure they’d answer

Iam64 Fri 27-Sept-24 20:42:06

Allira

Lisaangel10

My son barely revised at home at all but still got double A* awards in Science, A in Maths and English, Design Tech. And B’s in all others. That was the first year they did A* awards too, when only the very highest marks were awarded them.

Not everyone is blessed with that kind of brain.

And most of us recognise that. I’m not sure the point of the comment

Allira Fri 27-Sept-24 10:55:55

Lisaangel10

My son barely revised at home at all but still got double A* awards in Science, A in Maths and English, Design Tech. And B’s in all others. That was the first year they did A* awards too, when only the very highest marks were awarded them.

Not everyone is blessed with that kind of brain.

Doodledog Fri 27-Sept-24 10:07:18

I fully understand the Starmer's desire to keep their family life private, and think they have every right to do so.

I also think that their PR is terrible. People like Cummings, Campbell and Mandelson tend to be disliked and mistrusted, but they stop the opposition from spinning everything in a negative fashion, and ensure that any positives are put forward too. I can't imagine any of those men allowing the WFP withdrawal (a) to happen yet, and (b) to be presented as it was. That was a political disaster. Many people stopped listening to anything else the LP said, and many jumped on the media sloganeering and did their work for them by repeating the name-calling etc.

I can't understand why the LP's Comms team have allowed this to happen. Whoever they are they should be sacked and replaced with people who know what they're doing.

Lisaangel10 Fri 27-Sept-24 09:35:54

My son barely revised at home at all but still got double A* awards in Science, A in Maths and English, Design Tech. And B’s in all others. That was the first year they did A* awards too, when only the very highest marks were awarded them.

escaped Fri 27-Sept-24 09:30:54

eww!

NotSpaghetti Fri 27-Sept-24 09:28:07

...nice place for a wee?
grin

MissAdventure Fri 27-Sept-24 09:23:49

My cat once did a wee wee IN my friends handbag.

I don't know what he was thinking!

escaped Fri 27-Sept-24 09:21:51

Sensible man. Good choice. 🐈
A dog would only pee on an aide's handbag or in the posh fireplace!

Iam64 Fri 27-Sept-24 09:15:08

I admire the attempts their parents are making to protect their children from the media spotlight. I’m in no doubt the criticism being levelled at the Keir and Victoria Starmer for anything and everything would be repeated if their teenage children were found to have behaved badly - like most teenagers do.
The pressure on the family is intense. I heard Starmer speak at the hustings when he stood as leader. The way he spoke of his own parents and his family was with great warmth and humour. Today, the DMail has a piece by Joan Smith alleging he lacks emotional intelligence or empathy. Give us a break