Gransnet forums

Chat

Has a GN discussion/thread ever swayed your opinion?

(68 Posts)
M0nica Sat 08-Feb-25 11:00:51

I am sure i have, if not changed, moderated my opinions on some subjects after reading threads on GN, although none immediately springs to mind.

For me the biggest benefit from GN is the wide variety of people it brings togethe with wider range of backgrounds lives and experiences than I could ever possibly meet in my ordinary life.

Gran32 Sat 08-Feb-25 10:59:12

Yes, sometimes especially if I'm agonising over something or over thinking

PoliticsNerd Sat 08-Feb-25 10:59:01

It's shown me how loud minorities can seem.

Others have often extended my knowledge.

I've always believed in facts and compromise but it seems many on here don't. Perhaps that's particular to the demographic?

Grannybags Sat 08-Feb-25 10:58:28

I think maybe helped me form an opinion rather than change it if I hadn’t made up my mind about something.

Even the politics thread has helped me occasionally!

It’s certainly made me realise what a diverse group of people we are!

Iam64 Sat 08-Feb-25 10:56:59

I’ve found it helpful to see comments from people with different views.

Boz Sat 08-Feb-25 10:52:43

No

Skydancer Sat 08-Feb-25 10:39:40

Not so much changed my opinion. But I have received some excellent advice on various subjects.

dragonfly46 Sat 08-Feb-25 10:38:31

I like to think I can be swayed by reasoned argument but will never agree with some of the extreme views stated on here.

Ilovecheese Sat 08-Feb-25 10:36:20

One I remember that changed my mind was about the titles we give to certain professions and whether they are different for the different sexes. E.g waitress, actress. What changed my mind was someone pointing out that we don't say doctoress or professoress, and I had a complete change of opinion.

Georgesgran Sat 08-Feb-25 10:34:05

No, not really, but it is interesting to read other points of view and to know that opinions can be so deeply divided.

Galaxy Sat 08-Feb-25 10:29:49

I would say MN in particular influenced some of my views on womens rights issues such as same sex care, prostitution, etc. I dont know if they changed my mind as such, but I thought about those subjects more.

Cossy Sat 08-Feb-25 10:25:18

I have learnt much, and yes, knowledge does sometimes sway my opinions.

What I have learnt is provide links and evidence and expect just a few people not to take what I might consider the “compassionate and empathetic line”.

Lots of very decent, open and honest lovely people on here.

Have a good weekend flowers

nanna8 Sat 08-Feb-25 10:23:54

Sometimes - it makes you see another point of view. Not so much on the political threads but on other topics. The politics here are different in many ways, we have different issues and sometimes diametrically opposing views. I think Christianity is more widespread here.

Sago Sat 08-Feb-25 10:23:06

GrannyGravy13

Yes, I was adamant that Shamima Bagin (sp) should stay in the camp in Syria. She had chosen to leave the UK. she was educated and should have known what she was doing.

After reading various comments on multiple threads regarding her fate, I totally changed my opinion, she is the UK’s problem and should be dealt with here.

It is rather hypocritical of a country to deport foreign nationals for various crimes and then not take responsibility for its own citizens abroad.

(I am blaming, spelling and grammar mistakes on the heavy duty painkillers I am taking, sorry)

That’s interesting GG I remember the thread!

I was of the opinion she should not enter the UK from the start.

I hope your pain killers work!

Chocolatelovinggran Sat 08-Feb-25 10:21:41

Yes, I have modified my opposition to the Assisted Dying Bill since reading posts on this.

fancythat Sat 08-Feb-25 10:16:59

A few.
Not that many.

I tend to write it on the thread if it has happened.
If I start reading a thread about something, and change my mind by the end of it.

GrannyGravy13 Sat 08-Feb-25 10:15:45

Yes, I was adamant that Shamima Bagin (sp) should stay in the camp in Syria. She had chosen to leave the UK. she was educated and should have known what she was doing.

After reading various comments on multiple threads regarding her fate, I totally changed my opinion, she is the UK’s problem and should be dealt with here.

It is rather hypocritical of a country to deport foreign nationals for various crimes and then not take responsibility for its own citizens abroad.

(I am blaming, spelling and grammar mistakes on the heavy duty painkillers I am taking, sorry)

Sago Sat 08-Feb-25 10:10:36

Over the years I have been on GN I have learned a lot.

I love most of the topics and tend to read the whole thread, particularly if I have started it!

A comment Galaxy made on another thread got me thinking of others opinions had ever swayed my thoughts on a matter.

As I crack on with my day I’m going to give it more thought, I would love to hear from you if a thread has changed your mind.