Gransnet forums

Chat

Help With a Puzzle Please.

(10 Posts)
midgey Mon 04-Aug-25 11:51:39

My daughter and me are struggling with a puzzle from the Guardian.

The question with no question
a) All of the following.
b) None of the following.
c) Some of the following.
d) All of the above.
e) None of the above.
[Just to reassure you, nothing has been omitted here.]

Is the answer really simple and obvious?
Thanks for any help.

silverlining48 Mon 04-Aug-25 11:57:38

Some of the above ?

Babs03 Mon 04-Aug-25 12:16:03

silverlining48

Some of the above ?

Yes, I would say this seeing as ‘some of the following’ has been mentioned but not ‘some of the above’.

Ziplok Mon 04-Aug-25 12:18:37

I agree, “some of the above” follows the pattern.

Lathyrus3 Mon 04-Aug-25 12:36:14

Surely the question is “How many of these statements are true?”

OldFrill Mon 04-Aug-25 13:09:41

It states "nothing has been omitted here" so the answer isn't an omission, it's one of the answers a) - e)

Babs03 Mon 04-Aug-25 16:27:14

OldFrill

It states "nothing has been omitted here" so the answer isn't an omission, it's one of the answers a) - e)

Oh I thought the OP was the one stating nothing has been omitted.

OldFrill Mon 04-Aug-25 16:32:49

Babs03

OldFrill

It states "nothing has been omitted here" so the answer isn't an omission, it's one of the answers a) - e)

Oh I thought the OP was the one stating nothing has been omitted.

It would mean the same.

ddraig123 Tue 05-Aug-25 14:10:44

From The Guardian - Mon 22 Jul 2024:
Solution

This is a multiple choice question with no information given. Nevertheless it is possible to deduce the answer. If (d) is true then (b) is true and so (d) is false after all. Since (d) is false, (a) is false. If (c) is true, then (e) is true since we know that (d) is not, and hence (c) is actually false. Since (c) is false, all those following are false: that is, (e) is false. Hence, (b) is true.

Now we have to check that all the true and false specifications are consistent; otherwise, there will be no solution to the problem. This is easily done, and so the answer is (b).

fancythat Tue 05-Aug-25 18:52:11

I would say a.
after that it says none of the following.

But what do I know.