Gransnet forums

Chat

Disappearing contributers

(89 Posts)
Galaxy Tue 26-May-26 10:25:28

Me three Magneta and Spinnaker, every hour for me lately grin

petra Tue 26-May-26 10:23:22

kittylester

How do you know that people have been banned rather than having just withdrawn? Xx

If there’s a member that you’ve exchanged several PMS over the years it’s best that you share email addresses because if you’re banned it’s instant, you have no way of contacting that member.

rafichagran Tue 26-May-26 10:23:01

I have to say I don't notice if someone does not contribute. I don't nessasarily think it is because they are banned though. Illness, death, or just being fed up with it are also reasons.

Spinnaker Tue 26-May-26 10:17:51

Magenta8

I teeter on the edge of dropping out of GN nearly every day.

You and me both because the minority spoil it for the majority.

Spinnaker Tue 26-May-26 10:16:33

I agree Nanna8. Yesterday was shaping up to be a proper goad fest and someone's fingers were extremely quick off the mark with, at one point, four deletions within the first 15 posts of a thread. This I believe was because a couple of posters had the temerity to post something other than what the thread was about. So what ? Threads often go off track, but they come back again. It almost felt like someone was just sat waiting to pounce and they did. Childish beyond belief.

Magenta8 Tue 26-May-26 10:15:39

I teeter on the edge of dropping out of GN nearly every day.

PhilipGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 26-May-26 10:15:19

Hello everyone, just a quick note from GNHQ: while we cannot discuss individual posters with other GNers, on this thread or via email, what we can say is that we do not ban posters arbitrarily - there is a process. And unless a poster is an obvious spammer or a troll they are afforded many opportunities to adhere to our guidelines before we would ban.
Pip.

Galaxy Tue 26-May-26 10:13:59

I am afraid that I don't necessarily think that people who have disappeared have necessarily been banned. Sometimes it becomes clear that a particular person has been banned but many will disappear for their own reasons.

M0nica Tue 26-May-26 10:09:54

Given our age group, some people disappear because they have died. Sometimes a family member posts the news, but, I think, mainly they do not.

Maggiemaybe Tue 26-May-26 09:58:38

Surely no one’s going to be banned simply for having a different opinion to someone else, and if anybody reported a poster for that reason alone, it wouldn’t be acted upon? Sometimes posters just drop out of GN for their own reasons.

I agree that posts shouldn’t be deleted though unless they’re very offensive.. They should stand to show exactly what was said. I’ve only ever reported obvious spam.

kittylester Tue 26-May-26 09:58:35

How do you know that people have been banned rather than having just withdrawn? Xx

Primrose53 Tue 26-May-26 09:49:18

Absolutely nanna8.

There have recently been several very goading posts where people are just intent on getting others to respond because the poster knows full well that in the current climate lots of people disagree with them.

You can see they are just squaring up for a scrap so the best thing to do is just ignore them and let them rant away to themselves because they will report you as soon as they spot the slightest word you have written that annoys them. 😉

I miss many people who are no longer on here and another good poster gone this week.

Basgetti Tue 26-May-26 09:43:55

I agree, Nanna.
Read a very strange, hate filled comment on a thread yesterday. I questioned what on earth that poster was talking about but didn’t report. Better that the opinion remained. People can make up their own minds.

nanna8 Tue 26-May-26 09:37:15

Whether they are banned or simply stop contributing it seems this happens reasonably often. It is a shame ,particularly when someone who has been a ‘regular’ is banned and most of us have no idea what caused it. A recent person to be banned never, as far as I am aware, transgressed . Sometimes I think someone with opposing views complains and causes a banning quite unnecessarily and we are the poorer for it. It would be very boring indeed if we all held the same views on everything.