Gransnet forums

Food

Scone it’s official

(165 Posts)
Galen Tue 20-Nov-18 15:34:01

It’s official, I’ve just heard it on radio 4.
It’s scone, to rhyme with moan and
Its jam first!

Maggiemaybe Tue 20-Nov-18 19:43:37

At least, he'd try to.

Maggiemaybe Tue 20-Nov-18 19:43:20

Scone rhymes with gone here. Though DH would disagree.

Grammaretto Tue 20-Nov-18 19:34:47

Scone gone for me too. I've never heard scone to rhyme with bone in Scotland. Isn't it here they were invented!wink

Elegran Tue 20-Nov-18 19:26:51

"One theory holds that is derives from Dutch schoonbrood (literally, pure/clean bread), another that it comes from sgonn, Scots Gaelic for a large mouthful." from bigthink.com/strange-maps/the-great-scone-map-of-the-uk-and-ireland

Recording of pronunciation of schoonbrood - www.howtopronounce.com/dutch/schoonbrood/

Pronunciation of scone by social climbers. philologicon.wordpress.com/2012/01/13/scone/

Done and dusted. I rest my case.

varian Tue 20-Nov-18 19:08:14

Don't be ridiculous

Scone (the eatable one not the place with a palace) rhymes with gone.

Cherrytree59 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:48:54

Galen it's a con!! Rhymes with scone shockgrin

Jalima1108 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:13:17

Anja you could try putting currants in one half and not the other
grin

Jalima1108 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:12:04

I've seen people put the cream on first then just blob the jam on top.

Jane10 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:11:11

As in 'Sconservative' perhaps!

1974cookie Tue 20-Nov-18 18:09:31

Re; the debate about cream or jam first ?
Almost impossible to spread the jam over the cream as it causes the cream to slide off the scone.??.
Scone has always rhymed with 'Con' for me.

Jane10 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:09:07

Lynne59- add 'gone' to your list!!

Daddima Tue 20-Nov-18 18:07:14

Scone ( to rhyme with ‘gone’) for me, and Esspee beat me to it with Scone!

Jalima1108 Tue 20-Nov-18 18:00:22

Just because radio 4 said it doesn't make it right!
Scone to rhyme with gone - a scone, there one minute and gone the next grin

But definitely jam first Galen - that's the Cornish way
and proper clotted cream next
and no fruit in the scone unless you want to just have it buttered.

LGH Tue 20-Nov-18 17:55:41

Definitely scone rhyming with cone and jam first

Lynne59 Tue 20-Nov-18 17:55:16

Bone
Cone
Lone
Tone
Scone

joot Tue 20-Nov-18 17:37:04

Scone same as gone here in Warrington and always jam first if served with cream. Lovely toasted the day after with lots of butter . Mmmm

Lupatria Tue 20-Nov-18 17:32:01

scone to rhyme with stone here.
and definately jam first followed by cream - the devonshire way.
over the years it's been found to be the best way as you can get lots more cream on jam.
but no butter is needed.

Jane10 Tue 20-Nov-18 17:28:20

Day6 try using gone as a guide if you come up here! See Elegran's map of scone pronunciation.

Day6 Tue 20-Nov-18 16:57:51

Thank you Galen for passing that on.

I am a scone to rhyme with stone woman. The 'cone' bit is the guide.

Jam definitely goes on first when having cream with them.

Elegran Tue 20-Nov-18 16:54:43

It's that North-South divide again.
bigthink.com/strange-maps/the-great-scone-map-of-the-uk-and-ireland

For me, scone rhymes with gone. Butter first, then jam, then a dod of cream.

The village and palace of Scone/scoon is a red herring.

Greyduster Tue 20-Nov-18 16:41:16

For me it is scone to rhyme with “gone”, but hereabouts they say scone to rhyme with “stone” (which is what mine resemble, mostly!). I was heard to say to the waitress, in a cafe last week, “really nice scones, thanks”. DH remarked that it was the first time he had heard me use the ‘local’ pronunciation! Perhaps I am being absorbed by some local linguistic amoeba! No jam, or cream, just butter for me!

Baggs Tue 20-Nov-18 16:39:32

scone, gone

Butter first every time, then jam, then cream

Whole hog! ?

MissAdventure Tue 20-Nov-18 16:38:34

Oh I love the cheese ones, with cream cheese and tomato chutney.

Anja Tue 20-Nov-18 16:38:21

Cut them in half. One side rhymes with gone and the other with moan. Cream on gone side, jam on t’other, butter under both.

Not that I’m sitting on the fence.....

Jane10 Tue 20-Nov-18 16:36:56

Scone to rhyme with gone every time!! No jam or cream for me as I prefer cheese scones.