Gransnet forums


Sick EU meat

(20 Posts)
Urmstongran Sat 02-Feb-19 12:06:14

This today in The Guardian is worrying:

The practice of smuggling sick cows into the meat chain is feared to be more widespread in Poland than previously believed, according to the investigative reporter who captured footage of ill cows being dragged to slaughter with a winch.

After Patryk Szczepaniak’s undercover footage aired, the EU’s rapid alert system for food and feed was triggered, and it has since been confirmed that meat from this particular abattoir was exported to 12 other EU countries (not including the UK).

Glad to read the U.K. wasn’t a direct beneficiary but it puts the concerns about chlorinated chicken from the USA in the shade.
Some evil people will do any amount of harm to make money it seems. Worrying.

NanaMacGeek Sat 02-Feb-19 14:16:37

I would guess that there are illegal, rogue operations going on everywhere including the UK. The USA aren't just trying to get chlorinated chicken into the UK, Urmstongran, they also want to get us to move away from the EU rules on hormone-fed beef, GM crops, meat containing antibiotics etc.:-
If the USA get their way, some food business practices that we currently object to in the UK will become legal or else no trade with them either.

Cold Sat 02-Feb-19 14:58:57

There are rogue operations everywhere - there have been scandals in the UK

What is important is maintaining the rigorous standards that allow such producers to be tracked and prosecuted. I hope that the UK is able to maintain these and not be forced to abandon them as the "price" of doing free trade deals

Davidhs Sat 02-Feb-19 15:03:17

Rouge and negligent operations are possible anywhere, not just with meat, but vegetables, cereals and any other food products, there is a lot of money to be made by cheating. The U.K. has good regulation just buy home produced food and you won’t go far wrong.

lemongrove Sat 02-Feb-19 17:19:26

Always buy British, some countries within the EU have really dodgy practices where anaimal meat is concerned.

Nonnie Sat 02-Feb-19 17:25:01

I heard that chlorinated chicken will be labelled as such in the shops so why can't halal meat be labelled? Surely we should have a choice about whether we eat it or not?

Nonnie Sat 02-Feb-19 17:25:53

Sorry, to be pedantic I wrote 'can be' I meant 'should be'

Baggs Sat 02-Feb-19 17:36:38

I'm not against GM crops. In many cases the genetic modifications mean that less pesticide can be used while crops are growing. That seems like a good thing to me. I'm not convinced EU opposition to GM is scientific.

I also think the 'alarm' about chlorinated chicken has been deliberately hyped. Essentially, as I understand it, it's no different from rinsing a chicken under a running tap in the UK (UK tap water is chlorinated). And if it reduces the risk of things like salmonella, surely that's a good thing?

Baggs Sat 02-Feb-19 17:38:00

I agree, nonnie, that halal meat should be labelled, as should 'chlorinated' meat. That way people can make their own decisions.

Baggs Sat 02-Feb-19 19:56:35

There's an interesting article on the BBC News site about GM chickens that are laying eggs which contain anti cancer drugs. Early days yet but it looks very promising.

Urmstongran Sat 02-Feb-19 21:04:30

Good points Baggs and Nonnie re chlorinated chicken & halal meat.
Perhaps if the consumer is fully informed choices can be made?

crystaltipps Sat 02-Feb-19 22:22:04

Disgusting illegal practices go on in slaughterhouses everywhere, even in the UK. There’s plenty of evidence. Plus a lot of what is legal, everyday practice would horrify many people if they had to witness it.

Urmstongran Sun 03-Feb-19 09:37:24

I’m sure you’re right crystaltips
I wish meat was more expensive and something of a treat if it meant the animals had a better life instead of being crammed together in pens. When I see pigs with their baby piglets (apparently they are very intelligent animals) it upsets me. I’m ashamed to say I switch channels or turn the page.
We are having roast pork and stuffing for dinner today.
I enjoy it because I try not to think about how the meat got to the supermarket. 🙁

Nonnie Sun 03-Feb-19 10:05:29

DH and I were chatting this morning about ready meals. We concluded it won't be long before we can only buy meat and fresh veg in specialist shops in middle class areas. Think of Tesco starting to close fresh meat and fish departments.

Urmstongran Sun 03-Feb-19 10:33:03

And the sadness is Nonnie that those in deprived areas will ping their goddam awful meals in a microwave.
We are so fortunate.
I can’t bear to think what some people have to eat.

Grandma70s Sun 03-Feb-19 10:42:53

I’m turning more and more towards being a vegetarian, like my almost-ten-year-old grandson. His own decision.

Witzend Sun 03-Feb-19 21:42:44

Hadn't seen this, but I can't say I'm surprised.
We don't eat very much meat any more, but what I do buy is only ever British, and only free-range chickens and UK pork and bacon from supermarkets I trust to source from responsible farmers. (Largely M&S and Waitrose). I will never, ever buy Danish or other EU pork or bacon, because of the factory-farming issue.

goodeone Thu 07-Feb-19 07:32:31

I am not suprised about this so glad l am vegan.

Anja Thu 07-Feb-19 08:15:12

Cheap meat is at the root of all this malpractice. Animals are being reared and killed in awful conditions just so humans can eat their flesh as cheaply as possible.

I do eat meat, not a lot, but what I do is locally produced and free range. A chicken will do 3 meals and provide stock for soups and stews.

The west eat too much meat at the expense of our health, the welfare of animals and the planet.

BradfordLass72 Sat 16-Feb-19 21:58:48

I prefer halal meat, especially lamb as it has the old-fashioned taste I remember from childhood before farmers were allowed to pump goodness know what into animals.

I know people say they don't like the method of slaughter but if you have every been to a slaughterhouse, believe me, NO method is humane.