Gransnet forums


Top of cake lifts off. Any ideas?

(12 Posts)
Penygirl Fri 26-Mar-21 16:46:35

I’m hoping someone can help with my baking problem.

When I make a Victoria sandwich cake it looks great when I take it out of the oven but as it cools it collapses and the top of the cake becomes detached from the rest of the cake around the edges so that it looks frilly. Is there a way to avoid this? Am I doing something wrong?

The cakes always taste nice but look messy and are hard to ice.

Thanks in advance.

Chestnut Fri 26-Mar-21 17:30:38

I have a brilliant little book called 'The Awful Cook's Book' bought in 1965 for 3/6. It tells you what you've done wrong and how to remedy it!
It says: Cake sunk in centre - reasons:
1/Too much baking powder or other raising agent used.
2/Mixture was over-wet
3/Oven too cool
4/Oven door was opened and slammed shut
Let cake cool completely. Turn upside down and ice or decorate in the usual way. When once it's on a plate the sunken part will be out of sight and out of mind!

Penygirl Sat 27-Mar-21 13:13:32

Thank you Chestnut I will have to try to eliminate these one by one. That book sounds great!

SpringyChicken Sat 27-Mar-21 14:01:26

Another reason why a sponge will collapse is that the mixture is beaten too much and starting to curdle. It's a fine line between thoroughly beating and overdoing it.

Esspee Sat 27-Mar-21 14:05:56

A wee tip - turn it upside down.

GagaJo Sat 27-Mar-21 14:08:54

I watched a You Tube clip once about cake strips. A padded foil strip, lined with something. You soak them in water before baking and wrap them around the edges of the tin. Stops the sides cooking more than the inside. Also keeps the top nice and flat.

Chestnut Sat 27-Mar-21 14:53:15


Thank you Chestnut I will have to try to eliminate these one by one. That book sounds great!

This is the book (it's a booklet really but has LOADS of information) which may turn up on E-Bay or a rare book site I suppose.
Click image to enlarge.

Magnolia62 Sat 10-Apr-21 17:43:26

I always use an all in one recipe. 150g of sr flour, 1 level tsp baking powder, 150g soft margarine straight from fridge and the same of caster sugar, 3 eggs.
Combine roughly, then whisk with electric mixer for just 45 seconds.
Bake in two lined sandwich tins for approx 25 mins at 160 Celsius fan oven.
I think you are maybe over mixing your mixture.

Ellianne Sat 19-Jun-21 18:08:35

Who just took a bite out of the side of the cake?
They say butter wouldn't melt! Grrrr!

Fleur20 Sat 19-Jun-21 18:14:36

Oh Ellianne!!

2 x irresistable!!

Feelingmyage55 Sat 19-Jun-21 18:16:06

On Amazon 1968 version for £295 pounds - yes nearly £300 pounds - ? - no I haven’t missed a decimal point.

Nonogran Sat 19-Jun-21 18:45:31

Ellianne what a lovely beautiful adorable dog. How could anyone not love such a cake stealing sweetie? Cake looks great. Hope you ate the rest.