Gransnet forums

Food

Root vegetables

(70 Posts)
dogsmother Tue 01-Oct-24 14:08:55

Just that really.
Why oh why can’t people see the difference between a swede and a turnip? I get so irritated, irrational but there it is.

lizzypopbottle Thu 03-Oct-24 10:42:00

JackyB I love sauerkraut and make it regularly myself. I'm just coming to the end of my latest batch and have bought the cabbages for the next batch. Fermented foods are so good for you.

Witzend Thu 03-Oct-24 10:06:37

JackyB, admittedly ages ago now, but I still recall any sort of vegetables being a rarity in hotel/restaurant meals in Austria, ditto in the Czech Republic. Plenty of meat, potatoes and dumplings, though!

A little notice on the Austrian restaurant table (ski resort) read ‘Vitamins are good - calories are better!’ 😂

JackyB Thu 03-Oct-24 10:06:30

I moved here in 1976,admittedly from a very rural area of East Anglia. Almost all the vegetables we ate.came from the garden.

NotSpaghetti Thu 03-Oct-24 10:04:13

JackyB - don't know when you were in Germany but my parents used to cook red cabbage with juniper berries in the UK. Definitely as early as the 1960s and we had white asparagus if Dad could get hold of it in London - one of my mother's favourites.*

JackyB Thu 03-Oct-24 09:54:11

I have never had the white turnips. They were one of the things my mother never made, I think I out of deference to my father's delicate digestion ( which I think I have partly inherited). I also never had cucumber and she never made roast pork, but we did have bacon and ham. And she also never served spinach although he said he liked spinach - she just didn't know how to cook it, I think. And was amazed when my sister and I showed her that it was the easiest and quickest veg to cook!

When I first came to Germany I had to get to know lots of new kinds of veg. Celeriac was/is an absolute staple, asparagus was always white, there was kohlrabi, salsify, red cabbage (all unknown to me and probably not known anywhere else in the UK at the time) only French beans but no runner beans.

I really missed swedes. I asked my mother-in-law and she said that was only for cattle. Nowadays you can get a far wider variety of vegetables and they are becoming a bit more modern in their way of cooking them. Back in the day, you would rarely get vegetables, except sauerkraut, with a meal in a restaurant, you were always served a salad as the greens.

Witzend Thu 03-Oct-24 09:23:10

Goldieoldie15

Who cares ! Both are disgusting. I think they were first grown to feed cattle. A bit like kale

Not to mention mangel-wurzels!

Baggs Thu 03-Oct-24 09:21:03

pably15

mt61.....mashed potetoes...

✔️

Witzend Thu 03-Oct-24 08:47:05

I read somewhere that both swedes and turnips fell out of favour for a long time in France, because during WW2 those were about all that was left to them by the invading Germans.

But the article added that they were coming back into favour, and I’ve certainly seen turnips (the smaller white ones) in a French supermarket.

Goldieoldie15 Thu 03-Oct-24 08:38:09

Who cares ! Both are disgusting. I think they were first grown to feed cattle. A bit like kale

TillyWhiz Thu 03-Oct-24 06:42:48

I love them both. Live in the South, both are readily available in the supermarkets in winter. My online delivery has brought me turnips as large as swedes and swedes as small as turnips! 😁

Llamedos13 Thu 03-Oct-24 03:40:56

Here in Canada we call turnips rutabagas.Took me a while to figure out they were really turnips.I boil them up with carrots then mash them, quite tasty with a bit of roast beef.

pably15 Thu 03-Oct-24 00:01:47

mt61.....mashed potetoes...

paddyann54 Wed 02-Oct-24 22:52:56

You can make a lovely delicate cream of turnip soup …that’s yellow turnip .I,ve never made it with the wee white bitter ones

flappergirl Wed 02-Oct-24 20:21:55

pen50

A swede was originally a Swedish turnip. Are they rutabagas in the US?

Yes they are. Rutabaga is Swedish for "red bag".

Here in the West Country a swede is the large one with yellow flesh and a turnip is smaller and white. I don't like the latter at all but the former mashed with lashings of butter and white pepper (has to be white pepper) is absolutely delicious.

Sarahr Wed 02-Oct-24 19:51:57

Swede and turnip. A swede is yellow and not quite as big as a football. A turnip is the size of a tennis ball and is white. You have neeps (turnips) and tatties with haggis. You don't have swede with it. Swede is totally different.
Children tend to learn from the parents and if the parents don't teach them correctly it gets passed down future generations.
When I was a child my parents used German names for various things, having lived in Germany for some years. When I went shopping many years later I had to describe a grapefruit in the green grocers as I had only ever known it as Pampelmuse. However, I was correct in both languages.
Not so with those who call a swede a turnip. Totally different veg.

Allira Wed 02-Oct-24 19:34:03

After reading this thread we just had to have mashed swede and carrots tonight, mashed with butter and black pepper.

Mt61 Wed 02-Oct-24 19:27:25

Baggs

Especially with lashings of butter and haggis and champit tatties.

What is champit tatties?

pably15 Wed 02-Oct-24 18:56:37

Baggs....champit tatties neeps haggis and a wee drop o' whisky sauce,,,

lizzypopbottle Wed 02-Oct-24 18:26:26

Mashed together carrot and turnip and carrot and swede, lovely grub and the same thing to me, but I am from the north. I think 'turnips' are white. I don't like 'em.

Dogmum2 Wed 02-Oct-24 16:42:11

Swede - orange. Lovely mashed with butter, carrot and black pepper

Turnip - little white things that Mum used to hide in stews and i would bite into thinking it was potato and it wasn't (yuk!) I now never eat stew made by anyone else but me, as they may be lurking......

posset Wed 02-Oct-24 15:58:14

www.bbcgoodfood.com/glossary/swede-glossary

Hope the link works.

dogsmother Wed 02-Oct-24 14:40:36

Oh Jax…I am. A swede is a swede, a turnip is a turnip. Neeps and tatties will do as slang though.

David49 Wed 02-Oct-24 13:35:41

Turnips, Swedes, Cabbages, Cauliflowers, Rape, and many others are all members of the Brassica family, you can cook and eat the leaves and roots if you want to.
Farm and wild animals eat them raw

Chulachuli Wed 02-Oct-24 12:53:48

Swedes are definitely yellow and an essential in Cornish pasties

Mojack26 Wed 02-Oct-24 12:41:39

Yip to me they are all varieties of turnips. Swedes are just tiny turnips and whiter...who cares..love them especially mashed with potatoes.