Gransnet forums

Food

Dried pasta - what's the difference?

(29 Posts)
ferry23 Sun 15-Dec-24 16:51:02

Does anyone use the very cheap dried spaghetti - it's about 29p in most supermarkets?

I'm just wondering how different it can possibly be from own brands which are around 75p or the branded varieties which are considerably more expensive.

Possibly gluten content which could make the cheap one clump together in the pan.

Just interested to see if there's a vast difference.

NotSpaghetti Wed 18-Dec-24 00:34:25

*when buying dried!

NotSpaghetti Wed 18-Dec-24 00:31:39

Pasta from Gragnano not far from Naples, is generally the best. It is still made the traditional way.
You really can taste the difference why buying dried.

nanna8 Tue 17-Dec-24 23:53:52

I make my own, no comparison and I wouldn’t go back to the shop bought stuff. I do cheat in that I have an automatic machine you just chuck egg, flour and water in, I gave up with the kneading a while back but if you can be bothered that is even nicer.

ileea Tue 17-Dec-24 23:49:51

I buy store brand tri-coloured rotini. It is the house favourite. I have tried others and no one likes them especially not the ones made with whole wheat flour.

Witzend Tue 17-Dec-24 09:41:31

Personally I don’t notice any difference* between dried varieties - I often buy Asda’s Smartprice penne for e.g. macaroni cheese, and any old spaghetti for spag Bol.

Obviously the fresh variety is nicer, but I find the package sizes either not quite enough, or just too much. At least with dried you can use exactly as much as you need.

*I can accept that my taste buds may not be of the most ‘gourmet’ variety though!

Anneeba Mon 16-Dec-24 17:07:56

I have found that, wouldn't you know it, the super expensive top dried brand of wholemeal spaghetti tastes much nicer than supermarket own. The latter reminds me I'm being worthy, whereas the former is just delicious 😋. Not so bad when it's on offer, but a lot more than cheap white spaghetti.

wibblywobblywobblebottom Mon 16-Dec-24 16:10:24

No.

AuntieE Mon 16-Dec-24 16:06:03

I have never been able to detect any difference at all between the various brands of pasta, except the price!

Skydancer Mon 16-Dec-24 15:20:50

Oh sorry. I see. I imagine you get what you pay for. Cheap items normally have cheap ingredients.

win Mon 16-Dec-24 15:17:23

Skydancer

I don't know what the ACTUAL difference is but fresh does taste better in my opinion.

OP was not asking about the difference between fresh and dried, but between the cheap dried and the more expensive ones.

There is obviously a huge difference between dried and fresh also in the calorie intake.

Cateq Mon 16-Dec-24 15:05:35

I don’t mind dried spaghetti, macaroni or penne, but much prefer fresh for lasagna. Not that I make the lasagna that’s hubby job. DGD just loves her Pappa’s lasagna and our AC’s argue over who’s taking home any leftovers smile

cc Mon 16-Dec-24 13:36:54

I actually prefer dried pasta to fresh, as do many others I think?

cc Mon 16-Dec-24 13:35:11

I think that the cheaper pasta has a softer texture, even if carefully cooked. Personally I like a bit more "bite" though I know that others like softer pasta.

Marydoll Sun 15-Dec-24 23:09:30

I believe the more expensive pasta uses higher quality semolina flour and the drying process is slower.

Allira Sun 15-Dec-24 22:14:55

Deedaa

More expensive pasta is made using bronze dies which give the pasta a rougher surface. This means the sauce sticks to the pasta better. Thin sauces will run off cheap pasta and pool in the plate. Italians also think that the water used to make the pasta is important. They use far less sauce in their pasta sauces than we we do so you can really taste the difference in the pasta.

I wasn't sure why some pasta has a rougher texture than others so thanks Deedaa
I knew the sauce sticks to that type of pasta better.

If only there was a similar gf pasta!

Deedaa Sun 15-Dec-24 21:59:52

More expensive pasta is made using bronze dies which give the pasta a rougher surface. This means the sauce sticks to the pasta better. Thin sauces will run off cheap pasta and pool in the plate. Italians also think that the water used to make the pasta is important. They use far less sauce in their pasta sauces than we we do so you can really taste the difference in the pasta.

25Avalon Sun 15-Dec-24 21:59:24

The supermarket own ones tend to be a bit more chewy and not quite as nice but you can hardly tell the difference.

Redrobin51 Sun 15-Dec-24 21:24:33

We've had both and to be honest I couldn't tell the difference.

Tenko Sun 15-Dec-24 21:22:47

I use supermarket own brand pasta and it’s fine with a lovely sauce .

Greenfinch Sun 15-Dec-24 20:57:45

I always use cheap spaghetti. With a tasty sauce on top it is surely very difficult to tell the difference.

Calendargirl Sun 15-Dec-24 20:54:40

I buy the cheap supermarket spaghetti.

Don’t have it that often, but with my home made pasta sauce, good quality beef mince, onions, garlic, peppers, it seems fine.

Skydancer Sun 15-Dec-24 19:00:13

I don't know what the ACTUAL difference is but fresh does taste better in my opinion.

RosiesMaw2 Sun 15-Dec-24 18:42:15

I think it’s the sauce that makes the difference!

AskAlice Sun 15-Dec-24 18:20:56

I agree with ordinarygirl - it's to do with the quality of the flour used. When I make my own pasta I use 00 grade flour which is more finely milled. If I have run out of that I've used ordinary plain flour in the past and the difference isn't really in the taste but in the texture. 00 grade flour gives the pasta a silkier texture, whereas plain flour gives a coarser, grainier version.

ordinarygirl Sun 15-Dec-24 18:11:44

I imagine a basic flour rather than a finer flour but not much in terms of taste. I generally find the basic flour pasta takes longer to cook but I don't know why