I wasn’t as a kid - because we couldn’t afford to be fussy. My mum lost my Dad and had 6 kids under the age of 13 to bring up single handedly. So you really are what you were given - and if you didn’t like it someone else would ask to have it.
My daughter on the other hand, was born fussy. She hated baby milk, and never ate much in the way of baby food.
If I gave her something she didn’t like the look or smell or taste of, she would vomit.
No. Not self inflicted. Uncontrollable.
She had very ‘safe’ foods she could eat growing up. Other stuff she couldn’t stand to look at because it set her off.
Couldn’t have the kitchen door open in the mornings. That caused problems. Couldn’t bear to eat breakfast. And this went on for years. And years. And still goes on to a degree now.
She’s 41 - and was diagnosed with ARFID at the age of 38.
Look it up. It’s not just about kids being fussy and only eating what they want. It’s not about giving in to them when they say they don’t like something they’ve never even tried. They KNOW they won’t like it. Full stop. And you cannot force them to eat.
ARFID sufferers struggle to eat lots of foods for lots of reasons. The sight. Smell. Texture. They know it’s not right for them.
My daughter grew up on dry toast, cheap pizza from Bejams (back in the late 80s
- 10 saucer sized pizzas for £1) chicken nuggets and sometimes a small amount of chips (6/8).
She didn’t like squash or juices and would only drink a fennel drink from Boots.
Chocolate was a no no, as was any type of cream, custard, or blancmange. Soup and stews and mashed potatoes were too ‘baggy’ to eat. Slimy and not nice. No sauces except a small blob of tomato ketchup in a little pot so she could ‘dip’ if she wanted to.
Plain pasta with grated cheese. No sauces. Would eat raw white cabbage but not cooked. It went on and on.
Now she can mostly control it. Doesn’t eat what doesn’t appeal to her, and makes wise but still fairly safe choices.
She will try a food now if she wants to. But will say if she doesn’t like it and won’t ever touch it again.
We tried arancini rice balls the other day. They were a no no. Too baggy and squidgy inside. But saying that I didn’t like them either.
Lots of people say kids are too spoilt, they’ll scream for nuggets or pizza as opposed to a meat and two veg meal.
From experience I’d say let them eat it.
Because ‘fed’ is better than not eating at all which is what ARFID sufferers will do if faced with a plate of what they consider to be ‘yuk!’
Gransnet forums
Food
Were you a fussy eater as a child and are you now?
(112 Posts)I was a very fussy eater s a child but had it knocked out of me at boarding school when I realised that if you’re hungry enough you’ll eat almost anything. My youngest DD was an extremely fussy eater which I didn’t handle well at all which I do now regret. She is still really fussy but prefers to call herself “particular.” She now has two teenage sons who seem to be permanently starving so she will never know what I went through!
I was a fussy eater and a teacher (deputy head) at primary school bullied me about it for years. Slapped the back of my legs for saying I don't like it when asked why I left a bit of dinner. Pulled me out of dinner line in front of whole class and gave me a dolls plate and said you don't need a real plate, because you waste food. Various things like this, the straw that broke the camels back was refusing to let me leave a bit of watercress. So I sat all through lunch hour on my own with staff clearing hall around me, no pudding allowed. When lunch hour was over she made me sit on the cold concrete steps out side the staff room all afternoon with the plate and bit of watercress until I ate it. I didn't. I told my mum what had been happening and she was very angry and went and had words, it stopped then. As it turned out Mum had been evacuated during the war she was 9 and her little sister was 4 and was treated similarly by the woman they stayed with. Mum had felt terribly guilty that she couldn't help her sister, so she never forced me to eat. When I married I was determined to eat everything so that my children would not see me being fussy. My worst problem was dark greens I would heave involuntarily at the smell of them apparently my aunt had the same problem. I'm not very fussy now.
i came from the sort of household where you age what was put before you not have a choice. if you did not want it fine you had it cold for next meal but there were no snacks, crisps, sweets, sandwiches etc.
we had sweets once a week so if we did not eat tea then we stayed hungry!
i personally think that people these days give kids a lot of choice too much choice. the amount of waste families seem to generate with all the choices they present to kids
As a child, I hated most meat, so Mum was happy to give it to the rest of the family. Then, strangely, when chicken giblets appeared on the menu, I loved them.
School meat 🤮 which meant sitting there till nearly the end of lunch, when I was suddenly given pudding and 5 minutes to eat it.
No chance of being a fussy eater in our house. I was always hungry due to being active so ate nearly everything put in front of me. The only things I don’t eat now are salmon and desiccated coconut. I love food !
My daughter announced once “ I shall eat cauliflower when I am 4!”
She is 45 now and still doesn’t eat it and she has always hated bananas or anything with dried fruit such as mince pies. No idea why.
Was never given an opportunity to be a fussy eater, a meal was put on the table and you ate it ( even the dreaded liver!). Being fussy was just never heard of.
I ate everything Ma put in front of me, it was ration time. If you didn't eat what was put in front of you there wasnt anything else.
Indeed! The silver lining in a less then perfect childhood is the deep gratitude and joy of very simple things - a peaceful home, smell of something good cooking, theres not a lot to top it!
I loathed and I mean loathed the fat on meat that schools made us eat. I still hate it and always very finely cut off any fat from meat. At my primary school we had to sit there until we had a clean plate. I was bullied by the children too, who often put the bits of dinner they did not want on to my plate!
It didn’t occur to me I could be fussy as a child. Money was tight, food never wasted. We ate home cooked food and I suspect my Mum simply didn’t cook anything she thought I’d not eat although I do remember struggling with breast of lamb. There was always a home made cake and often a simple cooked pudding with custard.
School dinners were a challenge at times, usually I was hungry and ate whatever was there.
As an adult I definitely have preferences. Although I eat meat, Mr C is a committed carnivore, I prefer vegetable based food and never, ever eat lamb!
Our sons were not at all fussy as children with the exception of brocolli and sprouts they’d eat anything. Two of our grandchildren on the other hand are incredibly fussy.
That’s quite sad really, she obviously enjoyed food but not cooking it! I’m surprised you didn’t have rickets as a child! My mother was a pretty abysmal cook but she did try and although her attempts were not very appealing they were healthy.
Thank you for all your posts, I’ve been very interested in your stories.
Bazza
I think I would have been very happy if my mother hadn’t attempted to cook! She did learn when she retired, a bit late for me though. I do wonder keepcalm what did you eat? No Deliveroo then, I guess mostly tinned food?
Toast in the main, sometimes with beans. Jam sandwiches, there were shop cakes or buns and biscuits too. There was the odd tin of soup I think.
My mum went to a local hospital canteen (she didn't work there, just went to eat) for a lunch time meal a few times a week.
I was unused to cooked food and had trouble at school trying alien (to me) things like 'gravy dinners' & cooked veg.
I was told that beans had more 'goodness' than steak so it wasn't worth the 'trouble' of cooking. There were tins of fish that my dad would eat on toast after work.
I left home & school at 15 and pretty soon learnt to cook a few things. The 'eating out' issues in my previous post are, I think obviously linked but I tried hard not to pass them on!
I don't really understand as she was a greedy eater when out or visiting with absolutely no food fads or intolerances, sad really.
I think I would have been very happy if my mother hadn’t attempted to cook! She did learn when she retired, a bit late for me though. I do wonder keepcalm what did you eat? No Deliveroo then, I guess mostly tinned food?
My youngest was a fussy eater. Now she is an adventurous eater, and cooks interesting and healthy foods for her family.
I share others horrible memories of warm school milk. It has left me with a lifelong adversion to anything featuring it - I can't be near porridge or rice pudding..
Reading through these it really does seem that my mum was unusual in not cooking!
I was a fussy eater, didn't like home made soup,,,or beef, if I had been allowed, I'd have lived on chips and gravy.
I still don't like some meat...I eat lots of salad and chicken....and soup ..
No it wasn't allowed as we didn't have much money so you were expected to eat what was served. I was always hungry and as Mom wasn't a good cook I actually relished school meals. I'm not fussy now ut prefer good, plain food.
Like some others here I was a child during and just after the Second World War, so food was scarce when I was a child. I ate everything except the fat on meat. Once at school I sat in front of some fatty, gristly meat for an entire afternoon. They said I had to sit there until I ate it. I was still there at 4.30, so they had to let me go. I won! Otherwise I loved food- oh, except rabbit, a common source of wartime protein. My mother would say it was chicken, but I always knew. No problems with vegetables. I ate all of them. I liked anything sweet, and I liked school milk!
I am fussier now, because it is possible to be. I don’t really eat any meat, though not a complete vegetarian. I love potato in any guise, and bread. I am not, and never was overweight.
My mother was a nurse and stood no nonsense about taking pills ot medicine and I just would not have been allowed to be fussy about food . I ate what I was given .
I was very picky, not an easy thing to be just after the war. I stopped drinking milk when I was 18 months old. I used to have some in tea but in those days it was often tinned milk which I wouldn't touch.My mother didn't like cheese or tomatoes so they were rarely on offer. My mother's vegetable of choice were mashed swede, boiled marrow in a plain white sauce, and very stringy runner beans - all of which I hated. Peas were a rare treat in the summer and meat came full of fat and gristle. You wouldn't think it now but I was a very skinny child.
I had a friend who was beaten by her father if she didn't eat all her food. She's 80 now and has had food issues all her life.
My parents couldn't afford to bring up kids who wouldn't eat the food they were offered. If I really hated something the first time it was served (pigs' trotters, brawn and cucumber were among those horrors), then they'd give me something else the next time. Demanding something different at the time wouldn't even have occurred to me. I was loved and looked after very well but ours definitely wasn't a child-driven household! That's how I learned that food costs money and the world isn't set up like a big sparkly ladder with me at the top, expecting to be given whatever I wanted with immediate capitulation by the providers!
I don't remember having meals I didn't like at home. I never stayed for school lunch. I'm fussy now - I don't eat lamb, pork (including ham, bacon, etc.), eggs, shellfish, or offal
I wasn't allowed to be fussy. I ate what was given to me or I went hungry.
I wasn't a fussy eater at home. Like you Fallingstar I hated the milk then and ever since. Horrible! in the winter, lumps of ice "just like ice cream" we were told, of course it wasn't and completely gone off in the summer. I don't know why we had to have it foisted on us I also had absolute terror of white matter with lumps, mashed potato and rice pudding. Forced to eat those until we threw up. Absolute abuse, most of us have something we can't stomach. I vowed I'd never force a child of mine to eat anything they didn't like. That came back to slap me in face with my second one, I thought he'd be just like my first who ate everything, if only
.His faddiness became apparent during weaning when he spat most foods out. A nightmare! Of course he eats everything now, including broccoli which was his very own number one food of the devil as a child.
I didn’t like the milk at school and can’t drink it now. I think our generation were put off it for a lifetime.
Ours would be kept in crates near a big iron radiator in the winter and left to bask in the sun from a big window in the summer. Was always curdled.
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »
