Gransnet forums

Food

Bought Christmas cakes crumble when cut

(6 Posts)
winterwhite Wed 18-Nov-26 18:18:45

Anyone else noticed this or know how to get round it?

Never had this problem in all the years I made my own Christmas cake. My marzipan may have fallen backwards off the sides, often. I may have only achieved a forked up snow scene with the icing, usually. But at least it always cut cleanly with the bread knife with no constant dipping in hot water.

For the last 3 years I’ve bought a good one, overlooking the fondant icing wh I dislike. But however carefully I cut it, the inside crumbles into chunks. Why would that be? Not enough eggs, or butter? Too much dried fruit? Tastes OK but disappointing to serve.

Has anyone cracked this nut?
.

B3dot Wed 18-Nov-26 18:33:26

Naughty naughty, why are you trying them out in November?

Fallingstar Wed 18-Nov-26 18:35:09

I have found slab cakes easier to cut than round ones. But do make my own which is gluten free so tends to crumble but xanthen gum and more eggs usually solves this problem.

winterwhite Thu 19-Nov-26 11:08:04

Have a heart B3! I was just thinking rather dolefully about this year. Looks as though not enough egg might be the reason. My mother's Christmas cakes in my childhood never crumbled either so it's not just that I was always stingy with the fruit.

JenniRen Thu 19-Nov-26 11:23:35

Rich fruit cakes should be left to mature, they may be crumbly if you sample them too soon 😀

winterwhite Thu 19-Nov-26 18:13:02

I assume the maturing is done before delivery. I order the Christmas cake in Sept-Oct and cut it on Christmas Eve.

I was just hoping others may know a way round this crumbling.