I wonder if we have to be quite so exact Illte. This is Edward Lear’s limerick no.91 from a book, which has differing numbers of syllables but still has a good rhythm when read aloud:
There was a Young Lady of Russia, Who screamed so that no one could hush her; Her screams were extreme, No one heard such a scream, As was screamed by that lady of Russia.
I agree Miss Tree. Difficult sometimes to keep to the rhythm but yes, I agree it’s 88558 according to the following which I googled...
‘Limericks all follow the same structure and pattern which sets them apart from other poetic forms and makes them easily identifiable.
A limerick consists of five lines arranged in one stanza. The first line, second line, and fifth lines end in rhyming words. The third and fourth lines must rhyme. The rhythm of a limerick is anapestic, which means two unstressed syllables are followed by a third stressed syllable. The first, second, and final line each have three anapests—da dum da da dum da da dum. The third and fourth lines have two anapests-—da dum da da dum.‘
Some of the limericks on the Gransnet threads are really good and worthy of publication I think . Some don’t keep to the rules. I know games are for enjoyment and it’s all about the taking part but I wondered if anyone else would feel like me ? Could we have a thread of limericks which stick to the 88558 syllable rules ? I hope it’s not out of order to suggest this. What do gamesters think? AIBU ?