Gransnet forums

Health

Cider vinegar vs cholesterol and blood sugar (but not so much effect on weight loss and inflammation)-

(42 Posts)
Greyduster Fri 02-Sept-16 09:09:57

I used to take cider vinegar - a tablespoon diluted in water with honey added. Don't know if it did me any good, but good things were said about it. I read that Ranulph Feinnes, the polar explorer, has been taking it for years as it is the only thing that keeps him from seizing up and he couldn't function without it. Considering how many bits of his extremities he has lost to frostbite I'm surprised he is still functioning at all, cider vinegar or not. Does anyone know how long it keeps? I've still got some in my pantry but I can't remember when I bought it.

Scooter58 Fri 02-Sept-16 08:50:30

Interested in the use of Cider Vinegar re Arthritis Anya,can I ask do you dilute it in a drink or take it neat?.

PRINTMISS Fri 02-Sept-16 08:20:19

We have a bottle of cider vinegar in the cupboard, find it great if anyone has an upset stomach, settles it very quickly (as does a sharp cooking apple), also soothes a sore throat, on both occasions of course it is diluted with a some water, and sipped, rather than 'downed'.

Izabella Thu 01-Sept-16 22:16:53

Been using this for ages since reading about it on the diabetic forums. Works for me. Also useful for killing off the sweet tooth!

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 21:56:55

Stansgran No, not the same.
When apple juice is fermented, the sugar in the apple juice turns to alcohol. That's cider.
If the fermentation process carries on, the alcohol turns to acetic acid. That's cider vinegar.

Bags I never gave my DCs undiluted fruit juice, always diluted it at least 1:4 because of the amount of sugar in it.

merlotgran Thu 01-Sept-16 21:19:29

Poultry keepers have been giving it to chickens for years.

poultrykeeper.com/health-suppliments/apple-cider-vinegar/

thatbags Thu 01-Sept-16 20:55:01

One of my nephews needed dental treatment when he was very young (preschool, I think). His dentist thought the problem was the apple juice that he drank all day long from a toddler sippy cup.

Stansgran Thu 01-Sept-16 20:31:44

I had my GC here this summer and was horrified to find they didn't clean their teeth at all in the morning. So the would drink some apple juice and go to school. Is apple juice the same as a cider vinegar? Not trying to derail at all.

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 17:41:06

Should have made clear that the prisms will remineralise as long as they aren't brushed away!

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 17:39:56

It depends what you've eaten/drunk. Acidic things will cause calcium to be lost from the enamel, and if you brush straight away, the enamel prisms will collapse and this results in tooth wear.

The enamel will remineralise, and calcium containing things like milk, cheese and yoghurt will help.

This is a personal view, but if you've eaten something sweet which will contribute to decay as opposed to tooth wear, then brushing with a fluoride toothpaste soon afterwards is probably better on balance IMHO, rather than leaving the sticky substrate there for the bacteria to feed on, and produce acid between your teeth which would lead to cavities, and plaque which will inflame your gums.

Anya Thu 01-Sept-16 14:30:27

Thanks for that advice Jane ...I think I read somewhere that the same rule applies re brushing after any meal. Is that the case?

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 14:06:33

Does anyone really eat two bagels for breakfast and nothing else?
What if they had a cup of tea with them? Or ate an apple?

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 14:02:19

Anya re your tooth enamel. Don't brush your teeth too soon after drinking the vinegar (or orange juice). Leave some time (at least an hour) for the enamel to remineralise, which it will do, especially if you have a drink of milk or eat some cheese.
Hope your arms are healing well flowers

Anya Thu 01-Sept-16 13:50:21

Hate to think what it's doing to my teeth enamel!

Anya Thu 01-Sept-16 13:49:23

Not a fan of MM's brand of populist science either. But in support of cider vinegar I have taken up when had a flare-up of arthritis in my hands before now. So as I'm trying to cut out painkillers for my broken arms I've been taking some at breakfast and the pain does ease up.

Hardly scientific I know but ....

janeainsworth Thu 01-Sept-16 13:19:48

Hmmm.......
It turned out that the cider vinegar, but not the malt vinegar, had a big impact, reducing the amount of sugar in the volunteers' blood by 36% over 90 minutes.
Drinking dilute apple cider vinegar appeared to bring blood sugar levels down
This could be because the acetic acid in the cider vinegar suppresses the breakdown of starches, which means that if you consume it before a carb-rich meal, less sugar will get absorbed. We expected the malt vinegar to have a similar effect to the cider vinegar, but in our small study it didn't

So it obviously wasn't the acetic acid, was it? So it must have been something else in the cider vinegar.
I think MM's experiment might have had more value if he had carried on and tested his volunteers' response to eating their bagels after drinking diluted apple juice, diluted orange juice or even plain water.
As for the cholesterol result, reducing the levels by 13% in people whose cholesterol isn't already raised above 'normal' levels doesn't mean that the same result will be achieved in people whose cholesterol is high. If someone's level is 9, reducing it by 13% would only bring it down to around 7.8 anyway, and they would still probably be advised to take statins.

I'm not a big fan of MM as you might realise! grin

Elegran Thu 01-Sept-16 12:48:11

Very interesting and positive results from some of the tests done (though only with 30 volunteers) by Michael Mosley and Dr James Brown for a new series of Trust Me, I'm A Doctor which returns on Thursday 1 September on BBC Two at 20:00

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-37229792