Good point jess
I am guilty of this, but not re. men like R.F.
For instance, I don't like grandfathers, well that is the cloak they use, posting on this site. With all respect for their being.
Gransnet forums
News & politics
Ffeinnes - admirable or daft?
(81 Posts)Reckless Ranulph is planning to walk across Antarctica, in the winter - constant darkness, several tens of degrees below freezing - you know the kind of thing.
Is this an admirable venture for someone in his late 60s or is he bloody daft so-and-so that cannot accept that this is probably a daft thing to do at his age, and may endanger the lives of others if he has to be rescued?
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19609293
Jess. 
Interesting carpathia thank you.
Maybe he is a victim of sound-bytism.
I wonder if we are, just a tad, just the teeniest bit, misanthropic on GN. in the sense of the weeniest tendency to be critical of men? Retires to gaze at navel.
It's a strange thing, raising money for charity. It was only recently that we realised that, usually it's only after someone dies that we become aware of their charitable deeds. I was always fascinated by that girl who 'walked round the world' after she said she'd do it at the Live Aid concert. Read a couple of her books; found her a very complex character. In fact, going to google her to find out what she's doing these days. I've got a book called Pole Dance by Tom Avery who gave a talk at a local school; he went to the South Pole..never got round to reading it, I'm afraid, but it was a very interesting talk.
Thanks, Butternut and Greatnan!
NfkDumpling, yes, the yellow dozers are a bit Top Gear, but in these temperatures and windspeeds there is no way they could do it unsupported*, and the research and fundraising is worth the exhaust fumes - it will have been argued over and approved by the Antarctic experts who are very protective of the place.
*given the number of people who now trot around the polar regions on their own, after Ran and Mike Stroud nearly killed themselves doing it first, winter crossings will be a package holiday in 50 years... Humans are amazingly competitive and only need a spur to beat a record!
Oh, btw - the beat-the-Norwegians thing is a 100-yr old Antarctic joke...
I was full of admiration when I saw the piece on television - until I saw the two enormous tracked yellow monsters belching black fumes chugging along with him.
Carpathia It's been enlightening to read your informed posts.
An extraordinary man who does extraordinary things.
Carpathia - you have convinced me! I withdraw my criticism.
Oldgreymare - John Blashford-Snell is one of Ran's longest and strongest supporters, so if you admire him, and he admires Ran...
Operation Raleigh has been a phenomenal success over the years, and has been specifically targeted at young people. Blashers is a one-off, and a good egg.
Ran's expeditions have had different motivations, but the inspiration happens nevertheless. This time, if you look at the website, you'll see there is some significant research which has never been done because the Antarctic winter is so vicious.
The money the expedition will raise (target £10 million) goes to a charity fighting avoidable blindness, so the efforts by Ran and the whole team will benefit large numbers of people very quickly. There aren't many people in the world who can raise that kind of money in a lifetime; Ran has done this many times over. I don't know the total sums he's raised for charities, but it's in the tens of millions, which I'd say was justification in itself – wouldn't you?
And may I say, gently, that as his expeditions are privately funded by business sponsors, and everyone on the expedition is a volunteer, and the contingency plans if rescue is needed are also privately funded, Ran doesn't need to justify himself to anyone. Nor does he need to prove himself, recognised the world over as an extraordinary achiever.
Carpathia, many years ago I attended a talk given by Col. John Blashford Snell shortly after he led an expedition from Anchorage in Alaska to Terra del Fuego in S. America via the notorious Darien Gap. The talk was fascinating and led me to become an admirer of a man who is a highly respected explorer.
For anyone interested, 'Google' him and read his biography... amongst many other things he initiated Operation Raleigh which has inspired many young people the world over. He remains involved with the development of opportunities for young people.
I am not against anyone wishing to be 'an explorer' but I do question the justification of setting off on what he terms ' the worlds last great challenge' and cannot see how this, if he succeeds, will benefit many people.
I suppose he wants to pop off in harness, I could think of better ways of going though
I saw the interviews where he said he never got any A-levels so this was the only thing he could do to support his family. Really? What about book tours and inspirational speeches to salesmen etc. I think it's very irresponsible of him with a (2nd) wife and young children to consider. Yes, he will be thoroughly checked over healthwise before he leaves but with his medical history I think he's mad!
I'm astonished at all the negativity about this story, and am pleased to see that Wisewoman and Barrow have more positive responses.
Ran Fiennes is an astonishing individual and has been an inspiration for young men and women for over 40 years. If you had spoken to some of the young who were at the Royal Geographical Society last week you would understand something of his worth to the world.
Also bear in mind that every expedition he has led has done significant scientific research en route and has many awards for the contribution he and his teams have made to the advancement of science in a variety of fields, from medicine to oceanography over the years.
AND please be aware that he has raised many, many millions of pounds for charities such as Marie Curie cancer care, multiple sclerosis, British Heart Foundation and now a charity fighting blindness. He is not a rich man and does indeed make a living from books and lectures; he is not rewarded for the journeys themselves.
Above all, I'd stress that he is one of the sanest and most modest people I've ever known, and his expeditions are famous for their brilliance of planning and the low incidence of injury and loss, given the extreme conditions.
Please look at the BBC report and the Coldest Journey website to learn and understand more about someone who, aged 68, refuses to give in to age and continues to celebrate life in the way he does best.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19609293
http://www.thecoldestjourney.org/
I declare an interest - I have known Ran all my life, so have the advantage of being quite well informed, but every year my admiration for him increases as he concedes nothing to age - unlike me!
I think the whole thing is a vanity project.
I heard him speak once and he was really good - but it didn't make me want to follow him on his mad schemes though I enjoy hearing about them. I understand he's already lost some of his extremities to frost bite. He's the type who can't sit still - the call of the wild and all that. However, if he gets into trouble some team or other will have to risk their necks to help him and there lies the rub.
He's a meshugganeh! He's also a showoff, which is a bad combination!
he obviously just seems driven to it and I admire him. I'm not sponsoring him,so good luck to him. I don't have a feeling that he would be a cosy companion that sits by the fire and chats, so maybe this suits his family. Maybe he is nuts, but there is room in the world for a few eccentrics, I like that.
Yes Bagsdefinitely attention seeking. The explorer tag is what annoys me as quite frankly it really doesn't apply. Explorers go to undiscovered places and regail us with their new finds. As he says, it is how he has earned a living and that is why we hear so much about his outings - he has to publicize them to get sponsorship!!
His currentjolly could be labelled an endurance test
Methinks that if he wants to spend a winter in the cold and dark, there's many an O.A.P. who will offer him a house-share! 
I don't care.
I think we knew who you meant Jess and the wig still bugs me however his name is spelt!!
Some names just beg to be misssssspelt methinks Bags. Obviously did not try hard enough. He will be ffffffffrieizing no doubt.
He did remarry very soon after his wife died I think. I say good luck to him but I still found the wig quite shocking.
I'm not sitting listening to my arteries hardening, but I am not taking a load of heavy plant to an environmentally sensitive area.
Better still - give him his full name.
Sir Ranulph Twisleton-Wykeham-Fiennes,
With a name like that he was bound to be eccentric.
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »

