Gransnet forums

News & politics

Welfare cash cards

(196 Posts)
RINKY Thu 03-Jan-13 20:41:42

A second reading of the above bill is on January 23rd. Appears to be a popular item to try and stop benefit claimants from spending our hard earned cash being spent on drink drugs smoking and gambling. It can only be used for food and transport. this is obviously an attempt to help focus the spending, especially when claiments have children.
I personally think this may help and is worth a try, I hate seeing kids standing around outside betting shops and making do with a sausage roll for breakfast while mother smokes away, what do others think?

vampirequeen Wed 13-Feb-13 15:08:57

I know I said I'd vote for a chimp etc but I do believe that Labour are the better party. It's not just habit or indoctination.

I didn't follow the party line in the police commissioner election because I thought the job should go to someone who actually knew what it was to be a police officer and understood how the system works rather than the septuagenarian class traitor who was the Labour candidate.

Ana Wed 13-Feb-13 14:41:40

I thought so afterwards, gracesmum - but too late! Isn't it funny how sometimes words just look wrong...although they're not? hmm

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 14:39:21

phoenix, Always Labour Governments because I know they help the poor.

gracesmum Wed 13-Feb-13 14:32:11

No, Ana I think you were right first time with led (past tense of to lead, unlike read which is both past and present, but pronounced differently of course)
#pedantsRus.smile

Anne58 Wed 13-Feb-13 13:37:24

So who do you usually vote for Ivanhoe ?

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 13:25:47

Lilygran , Well said.

Lilygran Wed 13-Feb-13 13:22:11

The problem with selling off council houses was not in allowing people to buy the house they lived in but in not allowing councils to use the money to replenish the housing stock. Having said that, Ivanhoe, whichever colour of party in power comes up with a wizard wheeze, no subsequent government will change it if it is to their advantage. I didn't like Thatcher or what she did to the country (and the miners). But my feelings about Blair and Brown are even more visceral as they betrayed the thousands who voted for them, more than once, in the reasonable expectation that things would be different under Labour. Were they?

Anne58 Wed 13-Feb-13 12:59:28

I have not kept a record of my voting over the past however many years, so I couldn't really say.

I also do not approach my personal selection process with any preconceived ideas in that I have no ingrained political leanings towards any particular party.

Each individual on their own merit. Can't be doing with the "4 legs good, 2 legs bad" approach. (Apologies to George Orwell)

Ana Wed 13-Feb-13 12:57:46

Don't fall for it, phoenix! One false move and you'll either be castigated for ruining the country or press-ganged into Ivanhoe's rebel army....shock

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 12:54:22

phoenix , What party do you largely vote for at general elections ?

Anne58 Wed 13-Feb-13 12:04:45

Unlike some who vote for a particular party regardless (VQ's comment re voting for a chimpanzee if it was wearing a red rosette for example) I tend to start with a local perspective, which I apply to general elections, local council elections and more recently the one relating to the police commissioners.

I read every piece of literature and go to the hustings when possible. I then make my choice as to who to vote for. My choice of candidate doesn't always win, but at least I can feel confident that I have made a reasonably informed decision.

Therefore I would not be able to say that I was a Tory voter, a Labour voter or even a Monster Raving Loony Party voter, although the cnadidate for the latter did actually get elected in one of the local council elections somewhere in the county (Devon).

There are certain issues that if looked at on a national basis, seem reasonable, but when considered locally are not.

For example the move for increased house building. Locally we have more houses than are needed, but a dearth of jobs. My husband has to live away during the week as he couldn't find anything locally, and I have been out of work since being made redundant in March of last year.
Wind farms too are very relevant round here.

So basically I put the needs of the immediate area first in my mind, and look for a politician who understands them and can make sensible, achievable proposals to deal with them

Ana Wed 13-Feb-13 11:54:16

Well, he certainly came very close to doing so. It was only Clegg's personal dislike of Gordon Brown (and the fact that otherLabour big-wigs seemed to be rather hostile to the idea) that prevented us having a Lab/Lib coalition.

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 11:50:36

phoenix, Forgive me please if you already told me this, but are you a Tory voter ?

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 11:49:13

Ana, Nick Clegg could not join forces with Gordon Brown because Gordon Brown lead a "failed" Government.

This was a point raised at the time by Nick Robinson the BBC's political analyst.

Ana Wed 13-Feb-13 11:17:36

Should be 'lead'!

Ana Wed 13-Feb-13 11:16:15

And you might just as well blame the LibDems for the government we have, as it was their decision to join forces with the Conservatives rather than Labour led by Gordon Brown (even after GB offered to resign...).

Anne58 Wed 13-Feb-13 11:05:11

No need to rewrite what I said, I'm perfectly capable of remembering.

The point being that we currently have a coalition government, which not one person in the country could have voted for even if it was what they wanted, which of course it wasn't. Hence my comment that nobody actually voted for the current government.

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 10:50:54

phoenix, ""Ivanhoe as ever you miss the point"".

What "point" am I missing then ?

Anne58 Wed 13-Feb-13 10:42:05

Ivanhoe as ever you miss the point. I don't know why you don't just shout into a bucket, at least then you would hear what you seem to want to hear.

By the way, do you suffer from high blood pressure?

absent Wed 13-Feb-13 10:37:58

That's told you phoenix. I bet you didn't know any of that. grin I guess that this is just one more thread to avoid.

Ivanhoe Wed 13-Feb-13 10:35:15

phoenix , May I point out that due to the crass Thatcher/Major 18 Tory years, which lead to a Labour landslide in 1997, I never would have believed Cameron's Tory's would have got any votes at all, but they did, and Clegg signed up with them, giving us a further 5 year Parliamentary term of right wingTory rule, only worse, because Cameron now is getting away with what Thatcher started, ie rolling back the State, in cluding the welfare State and everything that comes with it.

The right of the Tory party in Government believe in a small State and low income tax, and that what we have got.

Anne58 Tue 12-Feb-13 23:48:49

May I just point out that no one actually voted for the current government?

POGS Tue 12-Feb-13 23:44:26

moon

Ivanhoe Tue 12-Feb-13 23:30:20

Ana, There are different postings to go to.

Ana Tue 12-Feb-13 23:28:04

So, having made your point, can we now hope you won't keep repeating it ad infinitum on every single politics thread? Please?

#enoughisenough