I was having a conversation along these lines with DD re her retraining as a Maths teacher. She really wants to do it, but SIL points out to her that they don't need her to work and I suspect he would rather she was at home with the DGC. She would love that - for the moment, too, but having startedher course if she were to drop out she wold not get back on. But we have 2 friends, both formerly high powered solicitors who had strokes in their 40's/50's and therefore unable to continue to work and earn at their former rate, and I feel DD is wise to have a plan B both for when the boys are at school and in the event of any catastrophe in their life/marriage. It seems a bit pessimistic to dwell on it but also common sense. Although she has an excellent degree, without a professional qualification it could be a lot harder to earn a good salary were anything like that to happen Am I being a prophet of doom? I suspect not. I wish Andrew Marr all the best - I like his dry, incisive style and intellect.