Gransnet forums

News & politics

Measles vaccination

(105 Posts)
j08 Thu 18-Apr-13 23:28:22

You couldn't make it compulsory, could you? Children still have to belong to the parents surely. #bbcquestiontimenow

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 20:27:25

"Nonu are you all right? Why are you eating a prawn cocktail? "

I'm sorry but that is just laughable.

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 20:28:31

Not wooden spoon at all Bags. Just don't like to see other posters subjected to what some might call bullying.

Ana Fri 19-Apr-13 20:29:39

Or mockery.

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 20:29:51

The "expiry" was a joke regarding the subject of vaccinations and possible illnesses. What's wrong with that?

Bags Fri 19-Apr-13 20:38:51

Nothing at all. I just didn't 'get it'.

Bags Fri 19-Apr-13 20:39:37

Since it was followed by a thank you for being allowed to eat something. The meaning simply wasn't clear to me.

Bags Fri 19-Apr-13 20:40:42

It looks as if Absent and Tegan mightn't have got it too.

I get it now, thanks.

Greatnan Fri 19-Apr-13 20:40:58

Since when has expressing concern been bullying or mocking?

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 20:44:17

Somehow, you get a feeling for people's motives Greatnan. That's all.

Greatnan Fri 19-Apr-13 20:49:21

I really don't think you are in a position to judge my motives, jingle. I am quite a complex person!

annodomini Fri 19-Apr-13 20:49:36

That video you linked to is certainly a smallpox vaccination scar. The ones we had as babies grew with us!

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 20:59:33

Why would I have been talking about you? confused

Nonu Fri 19-Apr-13 20:59:39

JO , Ana < Thanks , am off to watch

Ice road truckers , with my Life long companion.

I am not off the radar, despite what they say .

A little humour goes along way , sweetens life

moon

Ana Fri 19-Apr-13 21:18:44

Nonu! wink

Galen Fri 19-Apr-13 21:50:16

jing that video is a smallpox scar. The BCG is smaller and circular.

j08 Fri 19-Apr-13 22:09:58

shock I didn't watch all of that video! What was he doing? And why?!

Eeuurghh!

annodomini Fri 19-Apr-13 22:53:41

Don't know why he was baring his shoulder - I just watched that bit.

JessM Fri 19-Apr-13 23:23:06

Just to return belatedly to the debate...
Some countries require a vaccination certificate before a child can be admitted to state funded education. I approve. The seat belt argument is a good one and it can be extended. We all remember the heated libertarian debate about wearing adult seat belts but one of the prices we pay for living in an affluent organised society is that there will be laws that will infringe our liberties to some degree e.g.
Driving on the left
Not driving while intoxicated
Not leaving grandad's corpse to rot on the patio
Educating our children in some manner approved by the state (you can home educate but you will be inspected to see you are making an adequate job of it)
For a few, very infectious diseases - measles and whooping cough for instance, it is not at all unreasonable for the state to require vaccination of children. It protects the child (even if the parents believe differently and don't have the sense to do so voluntarily) and it protects vulnerable individuals in the community such as: newborns (very vulnerable to whooping cough), children having chemotherapy, children born with immune deficiencies. There are many genes that give us our complex immune systems and not everyone has the full deck of cards. This may be why some kids (like yours Orcas) do not form a strong immunity to certain vaccines. But if there is very good herd immunity they will be protected.
Anyone still trying to undermine the credibility of the MMR is being highly irresponsible. Nothing at all to suggest single shots safer. When a baby is born it faces thousands of different microbes in its first moments and its immune system has evolved to cope. A three shot vaccine is nothing in comparison.

Mishap Sat 20-Apr-13 12:11:15

There are ways of encouraging parents to have their children vaccinated. For instance...

- having special health visitors whose sole job is to go to the homes of children who have not been immunised and offer to do it there. There is evidence that this vastly increases uptake, and that some parents don't do it because they have just not got around to it, rather than having any strong feelings about it.

- making it a requirement that evidence of immunisation is brought to nurseries, pre-schools and schools at the time of registration. Those who had not had their children immunised would be given clear written leaflets explaining the facts; and the information that they had fallen through the net would be fed back to the special health visitor.

- immunisation sessions in schools and nurseries, following contact with parents of course.

We just need to make it as easy as possible to do the right thing; and the literature about it needs to directly address parents' concerns and explain that the "scare" was unfounded.

Greatnan Sat 20-Apr-13 12:36:57

Thanks, Mishap, they sound like eminently sensible suggestions.

Orca Sat 20-Apr-13 13:01:41

Do not say that anyone questioning the safety of the MMR is being irresponsible. You are not entitled to make that statement without qualifying it by saying 'in my opinion...' You have to take into consideration the genuine fears of parents and you cannot ride roughshod over these fears. If you want more children to be vaccinated, and that is surely the aim, then you need to offer parents choices and yes, encouragement.
The 'scare' as you call it mishap may have been unfounded , if you are referring to the autism and bowel cancer side effects, only time will tell, but there are other genuine fears around the MMR vaccine which have yet to be addressed. Any responsible health officer will admit there is always a risk with any vaccination. There have been in the past with the mumps element of the MMR which is why it was withdrawn in Canada when I was working there.

Greatnan Sat 20-Apr-13 13:05:58

Orca, the whole argument was unfounded and led to the disastrous drop in take up, which has led to the current epidemic.

sunseeker Sat 20-Apr-13 14:29:44

I am in favour of vaccination but against it being compulsory. Surely the best way would be to present parents with the FACTS and let them decide for themselves.

I can remember my parents putting me forward for every jab that was going so presume I have had the measles one - also remember having a vaccine drop on a sugar cube - polio?

Galen Sat 20-Apr-13 14:32:54

Yes polio!

Galen Sat 20-Apr-13 14:34:23

Actually I think that needs topping up every now and then if you're going to areas where polio is endemic. Eg round med.
hmm must check up on mine!