Gransnet forums

News & politics

UKIP

(86 Posts)
emtoda Fri 03-May-13 17:21:08

The results are still coming in, but it is obvious that UKIP have done very well and the main political parties have been given a shock and there has already been comments about it leading to a change in the political system. It may prove to be a blip of course, but I hope not, it is time the present party political system was done away with, but the main political parties will do their best to maintain the status quo. But how democratic is it when the people we elect are chosen by a committee, not by us, and our representatives are not free to vote in the way we want them to, but by the Party Whips. Also, despite all the blah we get about policies, when it comes to it, there is very little difference between one party and another. So I think that a government run by INDEPENDENTS, not those with left, right or other political leanings, but in the way his constituents want.

Bags Sat 04-May-13 14:26:43

Moving to and taking over in some cases.

JessM Sat 04-May-13 13:18:58

Either that tegan or they are cynically implying they are anti-immigration to get votes in the hope of being able to progress their anti-europe agenda.
Not only the NHS would collapse if our "immigrants" up sticks. Hotels acroos England would have to close. And many other businesses would be seriously adrift with much needed skills disappearing out of the door. We are indeed a nation of immigrants - and migrants - we have done our share of moving to other lands.

Ariadne Sat 04-May-13 11:17:46

I think you are right, Tegan. And that is scary!

Tegan Sat 04-May-13 10:04:46

I watched a programme about a burial site in Winchester and tests showed that, even back then Britain was a very diverse multicultural society. UKIP are just a watered down 'acceptable' [I use that term very loosely] version of the BNP imo.

Ariadne Sat 04-May-13 09:51:43

I think maybe we should, inthefields! But let's hope that, as Ella says, it will give the other parties enough of a shock to shatter their complacency - though I doubt it. sad

inthefields Sat 04-May-13 09:11:14

I actually find it all quite worryingly reflective of a 1930's 'new' party which garnished grassroots support by seeming to address their concerns.

An overview of history reveals there is nothing much new under the sun - what goes around comes around.

Should we be worrying about the potential implications of UKIP success beyond the obvious shortfall on wider policies?

Ella46 Sat 04-May-13 08:51:45

The NHS would collapse!

Greatnan Sat 04-May-13 08:30:32

I think this is your first post, Cintique, so welcome to the site.
I found your post a little hard to read, but I got the general drift.
I would just like to tell you that my sister in a suburb of Manchester with virtually nil immigrants tells me that she has long waits to see her doctor mainly because of the large numbers of elderly people in the area.
Wouldn't it be disastrous if all the medical professionals from ethnic minority groups decided to up sticks and go 'home'!

gillybob Sat 04-May-13 08:29:14

I voted UKIP in the by-election following the resignation of David Miliband. Admittedly as a kind of protest vote against the complacency of the Labour Party who have been in power in my town since 1935 and do not have to do or say anything to gain votes. The result was as predicted Labour got in, but with a much reduced majority with UKIP achieving around 6000 votes. Sadly the Labour Party could put a donkey up as a candidate here and they would still gain power.

Aka Sat 04-May-13 08:20:31

I agree with most of what has been posted on this subject so far. UKIP do appeal to the 'closet racist', but there is also an underlying feeling that they have floated to the top, like scum in dirty water, issues which need to be dealt with. If it is indeed the case that in immigration is putting undue strain on our services then a national debate needs to centre around this and all parties work together to find a solution that is both humanitarian and practical.
Fat chance.

Ella46 Sat 04-May-13 07:59:09

They (UKIP) are clearly not up to much, but if they give the major parties a good sharp shock, and make them re-evaluate their policies, then that can only be a good thing as far as I can see.

JessM Sat 04-May-13 07:44:36

Protest vote against the government. Who was the only person to get booed in the Olympics stadium in a festival of good natured sportsmanship - Osborne.
It is newsworthy because it is a threat to major parties - and in particular the Tories because so many of them are anti- Europe.

MiceElf Sat 04-May-13 07:41:49

That is a scary blog. I'm sure it must represent the views of some people but it's all polemic and fact lite. I do think that once Farage and his henchmen are subjected to a forensic interrogation by Paxman or some other, they will quickly reveal themselves for what they are. That hasn't happened yet. But it will.

MiceElf Sat 04-May-13 07:34:54

Whoops! I'll go and look.

Bags Sat 04-May-13 07:27:05

I did, further up this thread.

MiceElf Sat 04-May-13 07:19:03

No, can you post a link?

Bags Sat 04-May-13 07:17:48

I think you,re right, mice, but what troubles me is the WHY? Did you look at that article by Russell Taylor? There are some sound bites in it.

MiceElf Sat 04-May-13 07:09:46

After the almost wall to wall coverage by the BBC I've now had a look at a little background. And once again the BBC reporting was deeply biased. Ukip have 50 council seats, the Greens 200, not a mention that I noticed.

I've also taken a look at their policies - such as they are - what a ragbag of right wing nonsense. Amongst others they want to reverse the smoking ban, reverse the hunting ban, ditch anything to do with equality, they oppose same sex marriage, they want to raise defence spending by 40%, and their taxation proposals were probably written by an innumerate nine year old. They want to double prison places.

They are the extreme right Wong of the Conservative party containing many former and expelled Tories, and two of their most prominent members are now in prison for benefit fraud and expenses fraud. (No surprise that they want to double prison places then)

So why have gained around a quarter of the votes cast by the 30% who bothered to vote?

Well, what I said above in my first post is part of the reason, but having slept on it I realise that these few Councillors are unlikely to be reelected. They will have to do some work now, and their track record for diligence and service is distinctly ropey. Farage's attendance record is bouncing at the bottom of the total MEP list, and he has described his members in less than flattering terms.

He gets a good press because he comes over as a cheeky chappie who is good humoured. A bit like Boris without a brain really.

It's a flash in the pan. It won't last, but what there is, is very depressing.

laidback Sat 04-May-13 01:58:01

Soz to be a bit dense, have been busy the last last few weeks.So r u saying,or is ukip saying they are against immigration and europe? So what are your alternatives or policies? Catching some news tonight, bods in bassildon,essex, R ukip mad. But why? How Does this encompass a realistic economic policy?

cintique Sat 04-May-13 01:08:29

Most of the comments regarding UKIP show generally how uneducated the majority of people are have they even bothered to find out who UKIP are! Basically they are against the common market because of the cost we cannot afford to be a member the Euro has had it they should have given up on the Euro Eighteen Months ago. We need to get out the Common Market Now! Then reduce immigration for economic reasons has anybody tried to get medical treatment lately how booked up are your Doctors Dentists Occupational Therapists Wake Up the Country is having great problems absorbing the recent spate of people from all nationalities wishing to make their life here in the UK all UKIP are saying is slow down we cannot absorb so many so quickly! It has nothing to do with race politics or religion

nanaej Fri 03-May-13 22:21:54

Unfortunately UTWIT have gained ground and I think we should all be worried. They are trying to appeal to the 'middle class' as well as the 'white'working class' by their 'kick the-immigrant- cat' policies.

It appears to only have two policies 1) Get rid of immigrants
2) Get out of Europe

I have to say it is incredibly naive to think that getting rid of 'foreigners' would be the solution to all the woes of the country!

As to getting out of Europe that is also presented in a Little Englander fashion with no real policies for alternatives.

That is not to say that I think there should not be a full review of immigration policies or that being part of EEC is not without its drawbacks! But you do not need to be right of Genghis Khan to sort it all out!

Ana Fri 03-May-13 21:47:11

Hear, hear MiceElf. I think that's absolutely right.

MiceElf Fri 03-May-13 21:26:03

Indeed, but I do think that their surge is in large part due to the total exasperation with the other parties. Remember the Liberal surges of the past. Or the SDP which was supposed to be a sea change. Never really came to much despite the gallons of spilt ink. So, although I think the it's true that the beleaguered will vote for them, I don't think that in he long term it's sustainable.

There are matters which have been ignored by the leaders of both parties, and that's for very different reasons, but a debate on those matters, immigration, housing, welfare and so on, needs to take place without automatic positions being taken and vested interests disguising the real agenda. So many feel disenfranchised and even local government offers no solutions. So often power in in the hands of the permanent officers who are massively well paid and pursue their own empire building agenda. Elected Councillors don't stand a chance - unless of course they themselves are permanent officials in a neighbouring borough.

If the big parties are not brave enough to set a moral agenda and listen and take account of the electorate, they don't deserve success at the ballot box.

Galen Fri 03-May-13 21:14:51

Couldn't agree more!

Ariadne Fri 03-May-13 21:00:57

Oh deary, deary me - I live in Bideford, which has gone UKIP. Not surprised, but oh deary, deary me!

Seriously; of course, UKIP are doing what political parties in earlier times did - talk the language which those who are feeling beleaguered understand, so that "immigration" ticks all their reactive boxes. Hitler and Mussolini used the same tactics to appeal to the bourgeoisie......we might just ignore the potential of UKIP at our peril.