Gransnet forums

News & politics

Are "Free" Schools heading for trouble?

(5 Posts)
Lilygran Thu 20-Jun-13 14:36:41

I think there is definitely trouble ahead. When schools were doing badly under the LEAs, it was local government's responsibility to get it sorted out. Now so many schools are independent of local councils, and the councils don't have the staff, expertise or the resources to take it on anyway, it's hard to see who and how it can be handled. A local authority school has to agree to be 'supported' but a free school or academy doesn't. It's OK saying schools will 'go out of business' if they are failing because parents will take their children away but that might not be straightforward either. It's not like changing the garage you go to! And I'm quite interested in the financing of education now. The on-line Times Ed said yesterday that the government is owed £6 billion by training providers who have been overpaid and then gone bust.

FlicketyB Thu 20-Jun-13 14:33:45

Well, they haven't been going long so teething problems are to be expected. I wouldn't want to reach an opinion until they have been running for 5 years.

I do think we need more variety in the education system. The present 1,000 pupils plus sized warehouse schools do not suit every child.

Eloethan Thu 20-Jun-13 14:14:59

Mamie Yes, it's shocking isn't it.

Mamie Thu 20-Jun-13 14:12:09

I see that one has been put into special measures by Ofsted already. Several are "in need of improvement" and not a single one has been rated outstanding. So costly, ineffective and set up at great expense where there are surplus places; meanwhile there is a school places crisis elsewhere in the country. hmm

Eloethan Thu 20-Jun-13 14:00:51

In Sweden, educational disruption is being caused by the closure of the largest free school operators in the country, a decision that has been arrived at because these schools have been found to be not financially viable.

Surely this is more evidence that the free school project that Gove has been pushing forward here, is a gimmicky, ill thought out one that may well end up as a costly disaster.

www.guardian.co.uk/education/2013/may/31/free-schools-education