Gransnet forums

News & politics

Parts of the Brain that were the last to develop the first to decline

(29 Posts)
janerowena Tue 25-Nov-14 14:01:45

I would assume from the article that the information would be used as an additional aid to diagnosis of early-onset Alzheimer's so that treatment available could be started as soon as possible, no more.

janeainsworth Tue 25-Nov-14 08:07:41

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-30180804
I'm afraid I don't really understand your point either,soapsoanelive
Of course there's always a risk that scientific discovery may be misapplied, but are you saying that scientists shouldn't pursue knowledge?

FlicketyB Tue 25-Nov-14 06:52:34

I am not sure I quite understand your point soapsoanelive. What the doctors have found is a physical link between a certain area of the brain and certain mental conditions. No different from finding a link between one particular gene or groups of genes and specific diseases. Like the discovery of the BRCA gene that results in the women in families with it having a high probability of getting breast cancer. This knowledge has enabled doctors to help these women by proper monitoring and, sometimes, pro-active surgery.

This research has shown that part of the brain is linked with both schizophrenia and dementia and that this part of the brain is one of the last to mature and earliest to deteriorate. This discovery has only just been made. How it can be used to help those with these debilating illnesses we do not yet know. It may lead to the development of new therapies for their control or development or monitoring of those who have been identified as at risk from these illnesses because of early indicators or family history.

I am never very sure what the difference is between 'social labelling' and diagnosing a condition. At various times in the life of myself and my children we have been diagnosed with conditions that are sometimes consider 'social labelling'. We haven't been socially labelled, mainly because we haven't labelled ourselves or tried to live off our diagnosis but the diagnosis of the conditions has been invaluable in both receiving therapeutic treatment and also understanding the source of some difficulties we have.

soapsoanelive Tue 25-Nov-14 05:56:37

Brain's Dementia Weak Spot Identified

BBC news have just reported that intuitive links that doctors made between schizophrenia and dementia (they used to call schizophrenia 'early dementia') may just be right. MRI imaging of the areas of the brain last to develop, the parts used in high level functions such as seeing and hearing are the first to decline in sufferers. It's reported that this is a breakthrough in research and could be really useful in developing treatments.

Hmmm....what do you think when you read these kinds of articles? Speaking purely as a utopian idealist I have a feeling that I want more to be said about how social diversity and difference and ageing categories have changed over the last, say hundred years. Are we kinder, for example in our 'assessments' of people? Do we give also when we take information, make assessments? Is the new technology used to give back to the people being examined? How does this discovery help people live good lives? Or is it marketing material that can be picked up and used by expensive care providers? Well, you know, I think....

Because we used to judge the effects of medications that people with schizophrenia suffered as if they were the illness itself. Historically, IQ tests have been misapplied in infant and primary schools. Everyone has their list of concerns about social labelling. In the 21st century my interest is in how technology might be out of control and although doctors may want to do no harm that the technology is in the service of much earlier embedded stereotypes that do noone any favours.

What do you think?