Gransnet forums

News & politics

David Cameron's speech

(152 Posts)
Luckygirl Wed 07-Oct-15 21:51:31

I have to say that I am really feeling the need for a finger-down-throat icon. DC's speech was sickening. A pretence of being caring; a set of plans for a greater Britain for heaven's sake - does he think we are totally brainless!? If this is what he has in mind - all this caring for the poor and disadvantaged etc. - why the heck has he not applied himself to it in the last 5 years? It is all so cynical. It makes me despair. What a creep. I really do think that is absolutely the most cynical political speech I have ever heard. I hate with a passion these "Churchillian" sound bites that all politicians seem to feel are necessary to communicate with us; the ponderous delivery; the well-placed tear - oh vomit vomit!

And all those back-slappers standing and applauding him - yuk!

Politics is such a dirty game.

durhamjen Thu 08-Oct-15 21:04:39

www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/oct/07/camerons-assault-on-poverty-pledge-undone-by-new-figures

Shame his speech was rubbish. It would be nice if he actually did what he said.

durhamjen Thu 08-Oct-15 22:02:00

richardhutton.wordpress.com/

Brilliant. Never heard of him before, but hope to again.

Luckygirl Thu 08-Oct-15 22:14:12

You are right nanakate.

durhamjen Thu 08-Oct-15 22:22:28

By the way, Lucky, has anyone answered your question?

Luckygirl Thu 08-Oct-15 22:25:57

No!

I had hoped that the opportunity to defend DC would be irresistible - but apparently not.

CindySherman Fri 09-Oct-15 00:27:31

jinglbellsfrocks, I'm not suggesting that it gets tacked on to the curriculum as it is. I'm suggesting that the curriculum needs overhauling to allow space for it. How about less teaching for testing (at all ages) and more space for critical thinking? Then we might get an education system rather than a schooling system.

CindySherman Fri 09-Oct-15 00:29:56

Actually, oldbony, the privy council originally existed to wipe the monarch's bum!

CindySherman Fri 09-Oct-15 00:37:16

Lucky, no-one can defend DC because he is indefensible!

grammargran Fri 09-Oct-15 11:10:01

oldbony - I don't think vitriolic language is exclusive to lefties. I felt parts of DC's speech came close. You say - and I paraphrase a bit - that because of the coalition DC was unable to put into practice(!) all that he would have liked. I say, thank heaven for that. luckygirl In answer to your question: very little!

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 09-Oct-15 14:27:46

Or of course CindySherman, the parents could do a bit of the teaching themselves. But that would require time off of Mumsnet which is obviously in such a short supply these days of want it all,right now.

thatbags Fri 09-Oct-15 14:48:38

Dan Hodges (a Labourite if ever there was one) in the Telegraph, if I remember rightly, thinks Cameron's speech shifted the Cameron and the Conservative Party (because of the positive response DC's speech got at conference) towards the centre in political terms, rather than further to the right. I'll look for a link if anyone wants it.

durhamjen Fri 09-Oct-15 16:32:59

Dan Hodges is a Blairite, rather than Labourite.

durhamjen Fri 09-Oct-15 16:41:17

I think you's find it difficult to find an article by him in the Telegraph to support the idea that he is a Labourite. Not looking because it will reduce the number of articles I can read that I want to read.
I bet he and his mother have lots of political arguments.

Luckygirl Fri 09-Oct-15 19:03:08

Indeed DC's speech was an attempt to negate their highly right wing unsympathetic image and the rise of JC could very well be a factor in the decision.

For me, as you will have noticed grin, that speech came across as cynical posturing, which I find entirely sickening.

Gracesgran Fri 09-Oct-15 19:48:42

I love the Richard Hutton piece Jen

nigglynellie Fri 09-Oct-15 19:58:40

The 'groom of the stool' wiped the monarchs backside, nothing to do with the privy council. The last monarch to have this services was Edward V1th. His groom was Sir Michael Stanhope who was subsequently executed for felony.

Luckygirl Fri 09-Oct-15 20:42:11

Apparently the groom was a very powerful person in court as he had the ear, as well as the arse of the king! Oh joy!

durhamjen Fri 09-Oct-15 21:53:42

Yes, Gracesgran; so true.

"Furthermore, Cameron is quite right to help people break the cycle of dependency upon benefits, by leaving them penniless. If we simply redefine poverty, until it no longer includes anybody at all, then the government will go down as a historical first. Nothing could be more egalitarian than his belief that poverty and neglect should apply to the whole of the UK – not just isolated regions. For if you make everyone poor then nobody will ever notice. “If you’re working and still struggling, the problem is that you’re just not poor enough. Let us help you with that”, he might explain."

Cameron just bringing together the speeches of Hunt and IDS, with a touch of Osborne.

thatbags Sat 10-Oct-15 19:34:00

Dan Hodges seems to think he's a Labourite: "Over the past few weeks I had started to become genuinely despondent about what was happening to the Labour Party. I spent a fair part of my life working for Labour and the wider Labour movement. I obviously spend a lot of my time writing about it. A lot of my friends are, or once were, in the Labour Party. A lot of the people I most respect in public life are in the Labour Party."

POGS Sat 10-Oct-15 21:00:35

Dan Hodges and his mother ex Labour MP Glenda Jackson are obviously 'Labourite'. Uncontestable.

What is happening is anybody who does not agree with the far left of Labour or Jeremy Corbyn are either having their 'credentials' challenged as to their support to the Labour Party or being called 'Blairite' 'Tories'. Nothing new but more widely used to discredit/insult those who are not far left of Labour.

Labour MP Liz Kendle had to suffer the latter during the Leadership Contest and no doubt will continue to be chastised by the far left of Labour for as long as she remains a democratically elected Labour Member of Parliament. The fact is she showed more maturity in how she dealt with it than those who chose to call her a 'Tory'.

rosesarered Sat 10-Oct-15 21:56:39

All this stuff citing Blairites and Labourites is barmy.

Ana Sat 10-Oct-15 22:05:10

Not if you're on the extreme left, roses!

rosesarered Sat 10-Oct-15 22:18:29

Hardly anybody is on the extreme left, that's why it's so daft.

durhamjen Sun 11-Oct-15 23:47:49

julijuxtaposed.wordpress.com/2015/10/07/its-you-conservative-government-please-stop/

durhamjen Mon 12-Oct-15 00:24:51

www.tes.com/news/school-news/breaking-views/there-has-been-unprecedented-attack-our-wonderful-profession-one

I like this.I wish more people would stand up to Tory MPs.