Gransnet forums

News & politics

Remembrance Day Ceremony

(137 Posts)
Devorgilla Fri 23-Oct-15 22:22:12

This is to be cut short because of the age of the Queen and other Veterans. Fair enough! They are getting on a bit...BUT why should only David Cameron have the right to lay a wreath as a Government Official? Don't know about you but I take exception to this in the Year of the Somme. The majority of dead and injured were from the working class so why do we deny other parties more representative of that group the right to lay the wreath? By all means make life easier for her Majesty but let all parties be represented. It is important to me and I think a lot of other people who knew families whose men never came home. You were wrongly advised on this Your Majesty and should reverse the decision.

Ana Sat 24-Oct-15 19:04:22

Has anyone any idea by exactly how much the service would have been 'cut short'? I doubt it would have been such that anyone (dead or alive) would have felt their day had been blighted.

The Remembrance Day service takes up only one part of the day, after all.

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 19:00:23

Ceesan, the queen did not fight for our country, and I have only said the dead of the wars deserve one day in the year to have full respect, not a service cut short , where is my lack of respect?

Alea Sat 24-Oct-15 18:58:03

Why oh why has a perfectly reasonable topic descended into this level of bad tempered vituperative mudslinging??
Is it a case that we get grumpier as we get older or is it just that some people thrive on a ding dong?
It's worse than PMQs.

Ceesnan Sat 24-Oct-15 18:49:31

Anniebach do you really have so little respect for those who fought for their country? Shame on you.

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 18:36:15

One participant is getting on a bit,

Elegran Sat 24-Oct-15 18:35:47

x posts, ana ! grin

Elegran Sat 24-Oct-15 18:35:16

Ah, but some posters think that everything is a right-wing plot and an excuse for DC to get his ugly mug into the photo opportunities! (or for royalty to lord it over us all)

Ana Sat 24-Oct-15 18:34:12

Everything's a right wing/royalist plot to some people...hmm

nigglynellie Sat 24-Oct-15 18:31:57

That is actually what I was saying Not To Old!! Hardly a right wing plot!!

NotTooOld Sat 24-Oct-15 18:28:59

Oh, honestly. What a fuss. They are shortening the ceremony at the Cenotaph (or not, I'm confused now) because the participants are getting on a bit and many cannot cope with standing around in the cold for ages. Sounds like common sense to me. Congraulations to whomever thought up the idea.

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 18:22:27

Thabk you nigglenellie, I did think I was allowed to post my opinions but your permission and approval means so much

nigglynellie Sat 24-Oct-15 18:18:53

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 18:14:51

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

nigglynellie Sat 24-Oct-15 18:12:01

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

rosesarered Sat 24-Oct-15 18:05:40

No need, the posts are there for all to see! grin

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 18:00:32

Suppose you keep a file rosesarered , poor you

Elegran Sat 24-Oct-15 17:59:44

Kill the old ones off to join their comrades, eh?

rosesarered Sat 24-Oct-15 17:58:44

That was your most ridiculous and melodramatic post to date!

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 17:54:53

Full respect for those thousands and thousands of war dead , many were teenagers, who died lying in the mud , is second to the comfort of those eho have lived a long life ? Not for me

Elegran Sat 24-Oct-15 17:50:29

If it is the consideration being given to an elderly queen that sticks in the throat, then perhaps it is time to consider two things.

The sovereign is the commander-in-chief of the armed forces, and as such it is her duty to be present and take the salute at the service of remembrance for those who died while serving under her. She would no doubt consider it a dereliction of that duty to leave early.

The older (and well venerated) veterans who find the long service in the cold a great strain would think it a disgrace to admit that the ceremony was too much for them, but their respect and chivalry toward their ageing female sovereign, who they swore to serve when they joined the armed forces, would allow them to accept a shortened ceremony out of concern for her.

So it was not just that pesky royal personage whose comfort (and pride) was considered. Not that it matters now, as it seems that it is back to the long-drawn-out status quo.

Anniebach Sat 24-Oct-15 17:50:13

rosesarered, please , the playing of the ' for a Christian ' card has been played so often on this forum it's boring and pathetic ,

Ana Sat 24-Oct-15 17:50:01

x posts, roses

Ana Sat 24-Oct-15 17:49:09

(my question was to ajenela, BTW)

rosesarered Sat 24-Oct-15 17:49:05

Exactly, Ana which is why a slightly shortened ceremony would have been a good idea.

rosesarered Sat 24-Oct-15 17:48:05

Maybe this is what puts people off Christians.