Gransnet forums

News & politics

It will bring down David Cameron

(173 Posts)
obieone Thu 25-Feb-16 07:36:56

If he carries on I think. The Out campaign are not allowed to access any Government material that does not back the case for staying in the EU.

David Cameron thinks he knows what democracy is, and that others dont.

It will be a slow burning issue in my opinion, much like Hillary Clinton and the email scandal. And could ultimately bring him down.

Do you agree?

obieone Tue 01-Mar-16 16:11:34

If I read daphnedill's link correctly, the left behinders are the unskilled.
I dont blame them at all. It must be galling, if they want a job, for it to be taken instead by an immigrant who is willing to work for less money.

rosesarered Tue 01-Mar-16 16:11:09

Yes Anya that sounds about right that you said 'the gullible,the soft hearted, the bitter and those who blindly follow one political philosophy' ( re. The great divide.)

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 16:04:55

so they lazily parrot the political opinions
spread for the gullible masses to soak up and repeat, in lieu of having any genuine political thoughts of their own

One could say the same about left-wing dogma spouted repeated in many areas too.

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 16:02:36

So, reading the above and thinking laterally, the Government of the day was elected by 'Leftbehinders'.

Surely they should be re-named 'Infronters'

confused

Ana Tue 01-Mar-16 15:57:04

daphnedill's recent posts seem to be paraphrasing the opinion contained in an article entitled 'How to Criticise the Tory party' by Thomas G Clark on the website Another Angry Voice.

The delusion of these "I'm alright Jack" Tory voters is easy to understand. Many of them take their political opinions directly from the pages of the right-wing Tory press, and the education system deliberately denied them the cognitive tools necessary in order to actually think about and critique what they've read, so they lazily parrot the political opinions the tory/neoclassical establishment spead for the gullible masses to soak up and repeat, in lieu of having any genuine politcal thoughts of their own.

Lots more in this vein, obviously a very bitter, although eloquent man.

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 15:45:26

Is 'Leftbehinder' a new term for 'Has-Been' grin

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 15:39:23

'Those whose values aren't in tune with modern Britain'?

It sounds very sinister to me.

Ana Tue 01-Mar-16 15:37:44

'Those whose values aren't in tune with modern Britain'?

What on earth's that supposed to mean?

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 15:35:05

X post daphnedill

If you read political commentary, it's become quite a common term to describe those whose values aren't in tune with modern Britain.

That's what I mean by political pundits labelling people.
Perhaps they are the 'Infronters'

daphnedill Tue 01-Mar-16 15:33:14

Anya, 'Left-behinders' (as I wrote before) aren't necessarily poor. There's a subset of 'left-behinders' called 'I'm alright Jacks'. If you read political commentary, it's become quite a common term to describe those whose values aren't in tune with modern Britain. You can often identify them, because they think political correctness is destroying the country.

Jalima Tue 01-Mar-16 15:32:47

Good post Anya

'Toffs' and 'Leftbehinders'? confused

When will these pundits stop trying to pigeon-hole everyone?

As the term 'Toff' has been coined mainly to describe someone who has been to a top public school followed by Oxbridge, then does that mean the majority of people are 'Leftbehinders?'

Surely people are allowed to have a different viewpoint from someone else without having a label put upon them?
Amongst my family, friends and wider circle (none of them toffs or leftbehinders) there are extremely differing views on the EU, including many who are still undecided.

Jane10 Tue 01-Mar-16 13:23:03

Well said Anya!

Mamie Tue 01-Mar-16 11:09:36

I realise that some people won't want to read this because it is by Polly Toynbee - but I found this article really interesting.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/mar/01/david-cameron-war-labour-allies-eu-referendum-one-nation-leadership

Anya Tue 01-Mar-16 10:40:56

I'd disagree with that view of polarisation daphne - most of us are neither 'toffs' nor 'left behinders' but, as roses said, somewhere in the middle.

What is more noticeable perhaps is that a certain section of society has acquired a voice and is shouting loud and clear 'unfair'. And there are those who are using the genuine 'left behinders' to further their own agenda.

This great divide is a myth put forward by the media, statisticians and certain politically ambitious others, and believed by the gullible, the soft hearted, the bitter and those who blindly follow one political philosophy.

The poor will always be with us, I think someone said. But while the greedy and downright lazy and dishonest seek to take for themselves the benefits that ought to go to the genuinely needy them society will struggle to provide the duty of care we all agree ought to be there.

daphnedill Tue 01-Mar-16 10:14:04

No, rosared. 'Left-behinders' aren't necessarily poor. It's a term which has been used to describe people who don't buy into modern Britain.

www.economist.com/news/britain/21693223-britains-great-european-divide-really-about-education-and-class-tale-two-cities

It hasn't always been like that. After WW2 there was a consensus that education, health and social care mattered. The war had brought the country together and there was a reduction in inequality. The rise in white collar jobs and fall in manual labour and unskilled jobs has meant that some people haven't seen any benefit from the country's increasing wealth and they don't share the same values as those at the top of the pecking order, although they've been conned by them. They've been 'left behind'.

rosesarered Tue 01-Mar-16 09:28:31

Toffs and left-behinders ( the poor?) As was always the way, with most of society being somewhere in the middle of that spectrum.

daphnedill Tue 01-Mar-16 09:22:44

What this is showing is that British society is becoming increasingly polarised between 'toffs' and 'left-behinders'. There is no pretence of creating a One Nation country. Leaving the EU won't solve that.

daphnedill Tue 01-Mar-16 09:16:39

I really couldn't care less about the internal politics of the Conservative Party. The referendum is too important to be used as a political football. My local Conservative Association couldn't be more Europhile, so I guess it's safe ;-) I wonder if MPs are actually representing their constituents. I linked to a map of attitudes across the country. For example, Wirral is broadly pro-EU, yet Birkenhead's MP, Frank Field, belongs to the BREXIT camp. Another example is Cornwall. Somebody on here said that all the Cornish MPs want to leave, yet the map shows that the constituents don't. Cornwall is a recipient of huge amounts of EU funding, so that's not surprising.

rosesarered Tue 01-Mar-16 09:01:27

That's because he really wants us to stay IN!

obieone Tue 01-Mar-16 08:55:45

Seems he really doesnt trust democracy any more, not even from his own side.
The whole thing is beginning to have echoes of the last year or so of Margaret Thatcher.

www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/secret-plan-to-axe-90-per-cent-of-tory-associations-which-would-smooth-george-osbornes-coronation-as-leader/ar-BBqascr?li=BBoPWjQ

I also agree with POGS. His lack of much idea about what an Out result would look like suggests a lack of vision

POGS Mon 29-Feb-16 22:42:07

DJ

Same situation today. EU Referendum Date and Regulation.

I must admit , wait for it grin I thought John Redwood and Bill Cash had them all on the ropes, especially the front benches on both sides.

durhamjen Mon 29-Feb-16 21:40:59

Last Friday there was supposed to be a debate on the cost/benefit of the EU. Hardly any MPs turned up. They are supposed to be continuing it next Friday.

POGS Mon 29-Feb-16 21:25:28

If anything will bring him down it's this persistent negativity of the UK's prospects.

I fully understand that facts and figures need to be given but so far I am hearing only scenarios, not the full, honest facts probably because nobody can be assured what will happen whether we are In or Out. The EU might implode for all we know.

In the meantime I am wondering why I want him to stay as PM . He has said he will do as the British People have told him to do whether that be the UK is In or Out of the European Union. In his words 'that is my job'. Fine , good, I like it. Now I wonder what heart he would have in negotiating deals if he has given up and can only think we are doomed if we leave.

I want to know our Prime Minister can see the UK 's future as a positive either way because he has an utmost faith in his governance and believes in the British public, entrepreneurship. I worry this Referendum Campaign is spooking the financial markets by this Campaign of Fear and is an own goal.

durhamjen Mon 29-Feb-16 20:41:05

But I think he did it quickly because there were going to be obvious splits in the front bench. The longer it went on, the less control he would have over the cabinet.

thatbags Mon 29-Feb-16 19:33:47

He was advised by somebody important (will look it up if anyone wants) to put off referendum until 2017 in order to be able to negotiate a better EU deal for Britain.